Gutte et al.76 | FC-DNN | CNN | Simulation of the breast phantom | 286,300 slices (from 2863 volumes) | Simulation/in vitro phantom | Reduce limited-bandwidth artifacts | CNR (versus DAS) 0.01 → 2.54 |
PC 0.22 → 0.75 |
Deng et al.83 | U-Net and VGG | U-Net | In vivo mouse liver | 50 | Numerical simulation data/in vitro phantom/in vivo data | Reduce limited-view artifacts from the circular US array | SSIM (versus DAS) 0.39 → 0.91 |
PSNR 7.54 → 24.34 |
Zhang et al.85 | DuDoUnet | U-Net | k-Wave simulation | 1500 | k-Wave simulation | Reduce limited-view artifacts from the linear US array | SSIM (versus U-Net) 0.909 → 0.935 |
PSNR 19.4 → 20.8 |
Lu et al.77 | LV-GAN | GAN | k-Wave simulation of absorbers and vessels/in vitro phantom of microsphere and vessel structure | 793 pairs (absorbers)/1600 pairs (vessels)/ | k-Wave simulation of absorbers and vessels/in vitro phantom (microsphere and vessel structure) | Reduce limited-view artifacts from the circular US array | SSIM (versus DAS) 0.135 → 0.871 |
30 pairs (microsphere) | PSNR 9.41 → 30.38 |
CNR 22.72 → 43.41 |
22 pairs (vessel structures) |
Lan et al.78 | Y-Net | — | k-Wave simulation of segmented blood vessels from DRIVE data set | 4700 | k-Wave simulation/in vitro phantom/in vivo human palm | Reduce limited-view artifacts from the linear US array | SSIM (versus DAS) 0.203 → 0.911 |
PSNR 17.36 → 25.54 |
SNR 1.74 → 9.92 |
Guan et al.89 | FD-UNet | U-Net | k-Wave simulation:/k-Wave simulation of realistic vasculature phantom from micro-CT images of mouse brain | 1000 simulation/1000 (realistic vasculature) | k-Wave simulation:/k-Wave simulation of realistic vasculature phantom (micro-CT images of the mouse brain) | Reduce artifacts from sparse data in the circular US array | SSIM (versus DAS) 0.75 → 0.87 |
PSNR 32.48 → 44.84 |
Farnia et al.90 | U-Net | U-Net | k-Wave simulation from the DRIVE data set | 3200 | k-Wave simulation from DRIVE data set/in vivo mouse brain | Reduce artifacts from sparse data in the circular US array | SSIM (versus DAS) 0.81 → 0.97 |
PSNR 29.1 → 35.3 |
SNR 11.8 → 14.6 |
EPI 0.68 → 0.90 |
Guo et al.91 | AS-Net | Non | k-Wave simulation of human fundus culi vessel/in vivo fish/in vivo mouse | 3600/1744/1046 | k-Wave simulation of human fundus culi vessel/in vivo fish/in vivo mouse | Reduce artifacts from sparse data and speed up reconstruction from the circular US array | SSIM (versus DAS) 0.113 → 0.985 |
PSNR 8.64 → 19.52 |
Lan et al.92 | Ki-GAN | GAN | k-Wave simulation of retinal vessels from public data set | 4300 | k-Wave simulation of retinal vessels from public data set | Remove artifacts from sparse data from the circular US array | SSIM (versus DAS) 0.215 → 0.928 |
PSNR 15.61 → 25.51 |
SNR 1.63 → 11.52 |
DiSpirito et al.93 | FD U-Net | U-Net | In vivo mouse brain | 304 | In vivo mouse brain | Improve the image quality of undersampled PAM images | SSIM (versus zero fill) 0.510 → 0.961 |
PSNR 16.94 → 34.04 |
MS-SSIM 0.585 → 0.990 |
MAE 0.0701 → 0.0084 |
MSE 0.0027 → 0.00044 |
Vu et al.95 | DIP | CNN | In vivo blood vessels | — | In vivo blood vessels/non-vascular data | Improve the image quality of undersampled PAM images | SSIM (versus bilinear) 0.851 → 0.928 |
PSNR 25.6 → 31.0 |
Godefroy et al.96 | U-Net/Bayesian NN | U-Net | Pairs of PAI and photographs of leaves/Corresponded numerical simulation | 500 | PAI and photographs of leaves/numerical simulation | Reduce limited-view and limited-bandwidth artifacts from the linear US array | NCC (versus DAS) 0.31 → 0.89 |
SSIM 0.29 → 0.87 |
Vu et al.98 | WGAN-GP | GAN | k-Wave simulation: disk phantom and TPM vascular data | 4000 (disk)/7200 (vascular) | k-Wave simulation: disk phantom and TPM vascular data/tube phantom/in vivo mouse skin | Reduce limited-view and limited-bandwidth artifacts from the linear US array | SSIM (versus U-Net) 0.62 → 0.65 |
PSNR 25.7 → 26.5 |
Zhang et al.100 | RADL-net | CNN | k-Wave simulation | 161,000 (including augmentation and cropping from 126 vascular images) | k-Wave simulation/vascular structure phantom/in vivo mouse brain | Reduce limited-view and sparsity artifacts from the ring-shaped US array | SSIM (versus DAS) 0.11 → 0.93 |
PSNR 17.5 → 23.3 |
Davoudi et al.101 | U-Net | U-Net | Simulation: planar parabolic absorber and mouse/in vitro circular phantom/in vitro vessel-structure phantom/in vivo mouse | Not mentioned/28/33/420 | Simulation: planar parabolic absorber and mouse/in vitro circular phantom/in vitro vessel-structure phantom/in vivo mouse | Reduce limited-view and sparsity artifacts from the circular US array | SSIM (versus input) 0.281 → 0.845 |
Davoudi et al.102 | U-Net | U-Net | In vivo human finger from seven healthy volunteers | 4109 (including validation) | In vivo human finger | Reduce the limited-view and sparsity artifacts from the US circular array | SSIM (versus U-Net) 0.845 → 0.944 |
PSNR 14.3 → 19.0 |
MSE 0.04 → 0.014 |
NRMSE 0.818 → 0.355 |
Awasthi et al.103 | Hybrid end-to-end U-Net | U-Net | k-Wave simulation from breast sinogram images | 1000 | k-Wave simulation of the numerical phantom, blood vessel, and breast/ horsehair phantoms/ in vivo rat brain | Super-resolution, denoising, and bandwidth enhancement of the PA signal from the circular US array | PC (versus DAS) 0.307 → 0.730 |
SSIM 0.272 → 0.703 |
RMSE 0.107 → 0.0617 |
Schwab et al.105 | DALnet | CNN | Numerical simulation of 200 projection images from 3D lung blood vessel data | 3000 (after cropping) | Numerical simulation/in vivo human finger | Reduce limited-view, sparsity and limited bandwidth artifacts | SSIM (versus input) 0.305 → 0.726 |
Correlation 0.382 → 0.933 |
Choi et al.52 | 3D-pUnet | U-Net | In vivo rat | 1089 | In vivo rat/in vivo mouse/in vivo human | Reduce limited-view and sparsity artifacts | MS-SSIM (versus input) 0.83 → 0.94 |
PSNR 32.0 → 34.8 |
RMSE 0.025 → 0.019 |