• Chinese Optics Letters
  • Vol. 19, Issue 8, 081403 (2021)
Bin Ma1、*, Jiaqi Han1, Jing Li2, Ke Wang1, Shuang Guan1, Xinshang Niu1, Haoran Li1, Jinlong Zhang1, Hongfei Jiao1, Xinbin Cheng1, and Zhanshan Wang1
Author Affiliations
  • 1Institute of Precision Optical Engineering, Tongji University, Shanghai 200092, China
  • 2Beijing Research Institute of Telemetry, Beijing 100094, China
  • show less
    DOI: 10.3788/COL202119.081403 Cite this Article Set citation alerts
    Bin Ma, Jiaqi Han, Jing Li, Ke Wang, Shuang Guan, Xinshang Niu, Haoran Li, Jinlong Zhang, Hongfei Jiao, Xinbin Cheng, Zhanshan Wang. Damage characteristics of dual-band high reflectors affected by nodule defects in the femtosecond regime[J]. Chinese Optics Letters, 2021, 19(8): 081403 Copy Citation Text show less
    Schematic diagram of nodule structure.
    Fig. 1. Schematic diagram of nodule structure.
    Angle-dependent transmission curve.
    Fig. 2. Angle-dependent transmission curve.
    (a) FDTD-simulated |E2| distributions for the nodule. (b) |E2| along the coating without the nodule.
    Fig. 3. (a) FDTD-simulated |E2| distributions for the nodule. (b) |E2| along the coating without the nodule.
    Damage state can be qualitatively described. (a) At low energy, rupture occurs on the side of the nodule that contacts the laser first. (b) Damage occurs at the place where the electric field is enhanced inside the nodule. (c) Modification of the film appears around the nodule. It is observed as a bright spot under a Nomarski microscope, which is the blister of film. (d) Large-scale catastrophic damage centered on the nodule.
    Fig. 4. Damage state can be qualitatively described. (a) At low energy, rupture occurs on the side of the nodule that contacts the laser first. (b) Damage occurs at the place where the electric field is enhanced inside the nodule. (c) Modification of the film appears around the nodule. It is observed as a bright spot under a Nomarski microscope, which is the blister of film. (d) Large-scale catastrophic damage centered on the nodule.
    LIDT results of each sample for R-on-1 process.
    Fig. 5. LIDT results of each sample for R-on-1 process.
    R-on-1 process mainly includes five states. 0. Initial nodule. 1. Rupture occurs on the nodule surface. This condition is observed as a change in scattered light under an online microscope. 2. A slight blister appears in the region of the light spot with the nodule as the center, and the height is approximately 30-50 nm. 3. The blister becomes serious, and its height reaches the micron level. 4. Limited growth on the surface near the nodule accompanied by the expansion of the blister area. 5. Growth to the inner layer.
    Fig. 6. R-on-1 process mainly includes five states. 0. Initial nodule. 1. Rupture occurs on the nodule surface. This condition is observed as a change in scattered light under an online microscope. 2. A slight blister appears in the region of the light spot with the nodule as the center, and the height is approximately 30-50 nm. 3. The blister becomes serious, and its height reaches the micron level. 4. Limited growth on the surface near the nodule accompanied by the expansion of the blister area. 5. Growth to the inner layer.
    (a) FDTD-simulated |E2| distribution for the nodule. (b) Electric field distribution along the coating. (c) FIB profile of state 1. (d) FIB profile of state 2.
    Fig. 7. (a) FDTD-simulated |E2| distribution for the nodule. (b) Electric field distribution along the coating. (c) FIB profile of state 1. (d) FIB profile of state 2.
    Size of Seeds2 µm1.5 µm1 µm0.5 µm
    Range of AOI8.1°–81.9°12.8°–77.2°18.5°–71.5°26.1°–63.9°
    Table 1. Incidence Angle Range of Different Size Nodules
     LIDT (J/cm2)
     2 µm1.5 µm1.0 µm0.5 µmHR Film
    State 20.3090.3770.481
    State 30.5190.4840.4980.4970.473
    State 40.5320.5150.5120.5090.487
    Table 2. Measured LIDTs of Different Size Nodules and HR Film at States 2 to 4
     LIDT (J/cm2)
    State12345
    2 µm seed nodule0.2890.4030.5190.7120.943
    HR film0.3950.510.6730.952
    Table 3. Measured LIDTs of the 2 µm Seed Nodules and the HR Film for the Second Type of Film
    Bin Ma, Jiaqi Han, Jing Li, Ke Wang, Shuang Guan, Xinshang Niu, Haoran Li, Jinlong Zhang, Hongfei Jiao, Xinbin Cheng, Zhanshan Wang. Damage characteristics of dual-band high reflectors affected by nodule defects in the femtosecond regime[J]. Chinese Optics Letters, 2021, 19(8): 081403
    Download Citation