• Infrared and Laser Engineering
  • Vol. 51, Issue 3, 20220104 (2022)
Lipeng Xia1、2、3, Yuheng Liu1、2、3, Peiji Zhou1、*, and Yi Zou1
Author Affiliations
  • 1School of Information Science and Technology, ShanghaiTech University, Shanghai 201210, China
  • 2Shanghai Institute of Microsystem and Information Technology, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Shanghai 201210, China
  • 3University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, China
  • show less
    DOI: 10.3788/IRLA20220104 Cite this Article
    Lipeng Xia, Yuheng Liu, Peiji Zhou, Yi Zou. Advances in mid-infrared integrated photonic sensing system (Invited)[J]. Infrared and Laser Engineering, 2022, 51(3): 20220104 Copy Citation Text show less
    Mid-infrared absorption spectra for common gases[5]
    Fig. 1. Mid-infrared absorption spectra for common gases[5]
    Mid-infrared integrated on-chip sensing system
    Fig. 2. Mid-infrared integrated on-chip sensing system
    Mid-IR waveguide sensing units. (a) The germanium strip waveguide designed by Yu-Chi Chang et al. for cocaine sensing[42]; (b) SEM image of the air-clad pedestal silicon waveguide designed by Pao Tai Lin et al.[43]; (c) Microscope image of the monolithic integrated sensor designed by Yi Zou et al. using germanium waveguides[44]; (d) The strip waveguide designed by Neetesh Singh et al. for D2O sensing[6]; (e) The suspended silicon waveguide designed by Floria Ottonello-Briano et al. for CO2 sensing (top) and the support structure of the designed suspended silicon waveguide (bottom)[8]
    Fig. 3. Mid-IR waveguide sensing units. (a) The germanium strip waveguide designed by Yu-Chi Chang et al. for cocaine sensing[42]; (b) SEM image of the air-clad pedestal silicon waveguide designed by Pao Tai Lin et al.[43]; (c) Microscope image of the monolithic integrated sensor designed by Yi Zou et al. using germanium waveguides[44]; (d) The strip waveguide designed by Neetesh Singh et al. for D2O sensing[6]; (e) The suspended silicon waveguide designed by Floria Ottonello-Briano et al. for CO2 sensing (top) and the support structure of the designed suspended silicon waveguide (bottom)[8]
    Mid-IR slot waveguide & iHWG sensing units. (a) SEM image of the mid-infrared slot waveguide designed by Nedeljkovic et al. [46]; (b) Simulation result of the mid-infrared slot waveguide by the same team in 2015[47]; (c) The “silicon-liquid-silicon” nanofluidic slot-waveguide based on-chip chemical sensor designed by Pao Tai Lin et al[48]; (d) Schematic of a spiral iHWG etched on silicon substrate designed by Shaonan Zheng et al (top), the cross section of the spiral iHWG (bottom left) and the schematic assembly of LED, iHWG, and PD (bottom right)[50]
    Fig. 4. Mid-IR slot waveguide & iHWG sensing units. (a) SEM image of the mid-infrared slot waveguide designed by Nedeljkovic et al. [46]; (b) Simulation result of the mid-infrared slot waveguide by the same team in 2015[47]; (c) The “silicon-liquid-silicon” nanofluidic slot-waveguide based on-chip chemical sensor designed by Pao Tai Lin et al[48]; (d) Schematic of a spiral iHWG etched on silicon substrate designed by Shaonan Zheng et al (top), the cross section of the spiral iHWG (bottom left) and the schematic assembly of LED, iHWG, and PD (bottom right)[50]
    Mid-IR ring resonator based sensing units. (a) SEM image of the racetrack resonator designed by Benedetto Troia et al[58]; (b) Cascaded ring resonators for acetone/IPA sensing designed by Yuhua Chang et al[59]; (c) The ring resonator based N2O sensor designed by Clinton J Smith et al[62] ; (d) The sensor on a CaF2 substrate based on ring resonators designed by Yu Chen et al[63]
    Fig. 5. Mid-IR ring resonator based sensing units. (a) SEM image of the racetrack resonator designed by Benedetto Troia et al[58]; (b) Cascaded ring resonators for acetone/IPA sensing designed by Yuhua Chang et al[59]; (c) The ring resonator based N2O sensor designed by Clinton J Smith et al[62] ; (d) The sensor on a CaF2 substrate based on ring resonators designed by Yu Chen et al[63]
    Mid-IR photonic crystal waveguide sensing units. (a) The schematic of the mid-infrared silicon-on-sapphire photonic crystal waveguide coupled microcavity designed by Yi Zou et al[72]; (b) The mid-infrared photonic crystal waveguide based TEP sensor designed by the same group: SEM image of the holey photonic crystal waveguide (left) and SEM image of the slotted photonic crystal waveguide (right) [73] ; (c) The schematic of the ethanol sensor based on photonic crystal designed by Ali Rostamian et al[74]
    Fig. 6. Mid-IR photonic crystal waveguide sensing units. (a) The schematic of the mid-infrared silicon-on-sapphire photonic crystal waveguide coupled microcavity designed by Yi Zou et al[72]; (b) The mid-infrared photonic crystal waveguide based TEP sensor designed by the same group: SEM image of the holey photonic crystal waveguide (left) and SEM image of the slotted photonic crystal waveguide (right) [73] ; (c) The schematic of the ethanol sensor based on photonic crystal designed by Ali Rostamian et al[74]
    Mid-IR in-plane sensing units based on materials except group-IV. (a) The Ta2O5 waveguide designed by Marek Vlk et al for acetylene sensing[85]; (b) SEM image of chalcogenide waveguide designed by Mingquan Pi et al for CO2 sensing (left) and the sensor schematic (right)[90]; (c) Schematic of the bendable AlN-on-borosilicate waveguide based chemical sensor (left) and cross-section (right) designed by Tiening Jin et al[92]
    Fig. 7. Mid-IR in-plane sensing units based on materials except group-IV. (a) The Ta2O5 waveguide designed by Marek Vlk et al for acetylene sensing[85]; (b) SEM image of chalcogenide waveguide designed by Mingquan Pi et al for CO2 sensing (left) and the sensor schematic (right)[90]; (c) Schematic of the bendable AlN-on-borosilicate waveguide based chemical sensor (left) and cross-section (right) designed by Tiening Jin et al[92]
    Scheme of the monolithically integrated plasmonic waveguide sensor designed by Benedikt Schwarz et al[34]
    Fig. 8. Scheme of the monolithically integrated plasmonic waveguide sensor designed by Benedikt Schwarz et al[34]
    Mid-IR out-of-plane sensors. (a) The flexible surface plasmon resonance biochemical sensor based on PDMS materials designed by Chiao-Yun Chang et al[93]; (b) The dual-resonance Mid-IR MPA multifunctional chemical sensing platform designed by Dongxiao Li et al[17]; (c) The multi-resonance metasurface based label-free biosensor designed by Daniel Rodrigo et al[108]; (d) Schematic of the biosensor for passively capturing analyte molecules designed by Xianglong Miao et al[117]; (e) Schematic of the cross-section of the graphene-metallic metasurface biosensor designed by Yibo Zhu et al[119]
    Fig. 9. Mid-IR out-of-plane sensors. (a) The flexible surface plasmon resonance biochemical sensor based on PDMS materials designed by Chiao-Yun Chang et al[93]; (b) The dual-resonance Mid-IR MPA multifunctional chemical sensing platform designed by Dongxiao Li et al[17]; (c) The multi-resonance metasurface based label-free biosensor designed by Daniel Rodrigo et al[108]; (d) Schematic of the biosensor for passively capturing analyte molecules designed by Xianglong Miao et al[117]; (e) Schematic of the cross-section of the graphene-metallic metasurface biosensor designed by Yibo Zhu et al[119]
    Reconstructive spectrometers. (a) Reconstructive spectrometer simulation based on inverse design proposed by Tianran Liu et al[135]; (b) Schematic of a tunable reconstructive spectrometer based on black phosphorus proposed by Shaofan Yuan et al[136]; (c) Reconstructive spectrometer with a multi-lattice periodic array of metal nano-aluminum disks designed by Hwa-Seub Lee et al[137]
    Fig. 10. Reconstructive spectrometers. (a) Reconstructive spectrometer simulation based on inverse design proposed by Tianran Liu et al[135]; (b) Schematic of a tunable reconstructive spectrometer based on black phosphorus proposed by Shaofan Yuan et al[136]; (c) Reconstructive spectrometer with a multi-lattice periodic array of metal nano-aluminum disks designed by Hwa-Seub Lee et al[137]
    Spatial heterodyne Fourier transform spectrometers. (a) SEM image of a MZI array spectrometer designed by Milos Nedeljkovic et al[140]; (b) SEM image of a MZI array spectrometer designed by Qiankun Liu et al [142] ; (c) Schematic diagram of thermo-optical scanning MZI array spectrometer designed by Miguel Montesinos-Ballester et al[143]; (d) Schematic diagram and SEM image of a micromechanical structure-type Fourier transform spectrometer designed by Alaa Fathy et al[144]
    Fig. 11. Spatial heterodyne Fourier transform spectrometers. (a) SEM image of a MZI array spectrometer designed by Milos Nedeljkovic et al[140]; (b) SEM image of a MZI array spectrometer designed by Qiankun Liu et al [142] ; (c) Schematic diagram of thermo-optical scanning MZI array spectrometer designed by Miguel Montesinos-Ballester et al[143]; (d) Schematic diagram and SEM image of a micromechanical structure-type Fourier transform spectrometer designed by Alaa Fathy et al[144]
    Principle and structure diagram of the dual-comb spectrometer. (a) Frequency domain and time domain schematic of the dual-comb spectrometer[147]; (b) Schematic of the on-chip dual-comb spectrometer based on the optical parametric oscillator by Mengjie Yu et al[150];(c) Schematic and optical microscope image of a nonlinear dissipative Kerr soliton dual-comb spectrometer in the near-infrared by Tong Lin et al[151]
    Fig. 12. Principle and structure diagram of the dual-comb spectrometer. (a) Frequency domain and time domain schematic of the dual-comb spectrometer[147]; (b) Schematic of the on-chip dual-comb spectrometer based on the optical parametric oscillator by Mengjie Yu et al[150];(c) Schematic and optical microscope image of a nonlinear dissipative Kerr soliton dual-comb spectrometer in the near-infrared by Tong Lin et al[151]
    Optical response range of some absorbing materials
    Fig. 13. Optical response range of some absorbing materials
    Mid-IR integrated photodetectors. (a) Schematic of the integrated InSb photodetector on Si substrate reported by Bowen Jia et al[160]; (b) Schematic of the high-performance InAs/InAsSb superlattice mid-infrared detector directly grown on Si substrate proposed by Evangelia Delli et al[161]; (c) Schematic of the GeSn mid-infrared detector proposed by Cong Hui et al[163]; (d) Schematic of the GeSn mid-infrared detector proposed by Huong Tran et al[164] ; (e) Schematic of a graphene-based heterostructure photodetector proposed by Xiaomu Wang et al[165]; (f) Schematic of the photodetector based on chalcogenide glass-on-graphene waveguide integration proposed by HongTao Lin et al[24]; (g) Schematic of the metal-graphene-metal waveguide integrated detector reported by Zhibo Qu et al[166]; (h) Schematic of the waveguide-integrated black phosphorus mid-infrared detector proposed by Li Huang et al[167]
    Fig. 14. Mid-IR integrated photodetectors. (a) Schematic of the integrated InSb photodetector on Si substrate reported by Bowen Jia et al[160]; (b) Schematic of the high-performance InAs/InAsSb superlattice mid-infrared detector directly grown on Si substrate proposed by Evangelia Delli et al[161]; (c) Schematic of the GeSn mid-infrared detector proposed by Cong Hui et al[163]; (d) Schematic of the GeSn mid-infrared detector proposed by Huong Tran et al[164] ; (e) Schematic of a graphene-based heterostructure photodetector proposed by Xiaomu Wang et al[165]; (f) Schematic of the photodetector based on chalcogenide glass-on-graphene waveguide integration proposed by HongTao Lin et al[24]; (g) Schematic of the metal-graphene-metal waveguide integrated detector reported by Zhibo Qu et al[166]; (h) Schematic of the waveguide-integrated black phosphorus mid-infrared detector proposed by Li Huang et al[167]
    Ref.WaferWavelength/μmStructurePerformance & applications
    [6] SOS3.96Strip waveguide0.25% D2O sensing (Experimental)
    [8] SOI4.24Suspended waveguide0.1% CO2 sensing Propagation loss: 3 dB/cm (Experimental)
    [46] SOI3.8Slot waveguidePropagation loss: 9-10 dB/cm 0.04 dB/interface (Experimental)
    [47] SOI3.8Slot waveguidePropagation loss: 1.40.2 dB/cm 0.09 dB/interface 0.18 dB/bend (Experimental)
    [48] SOI2.5-4Slot waveguideDifferentiating n-bromohexane (R-Br) isopropanol (R-OH) toluene (Ar-CH3)
    [50] 4.26iHWGPropagation loss: 0.170.07 dB/mm (Experimental)
    [51] 4.5iHWGHigh sensitivity N2O sensing with analytical LOD of 0.0005%
    [58] SOI3.7-3.8Ring resonatorQ: ~8000 FSRvernier: 98 (Experimental)
    [59] SOI3.65-3.95Ring resonatorQ: ~4000 FSRvernier: 90 Acetone/IPA sensing with sensitivity: 3000 nm/RIU LOD: 0.002 RIU Theoretical <1% IPA in acetone sensing
    [62] SOS4.46Ring resonatorQ: ~40000 (Experimental) Sufficient for 0.5% N2O sensing (Theoretical)
    [63] CaF25.2Ring resonatorEthanol, toluene, IPA sensing with low mass loading LOD of 0.05 ng, 0.06 ng and 0.09 ng (Experimental)
    [73] SOS3.43Photonic crystal0.001% TEP sensing (Experimental)
    [74] SOI3.4Photonic crystalEthanol sensing with LOD of 250 ppb (Experimental)
    [85] Si2.566Ta2O5 free-standing shallow rib waveguide High sensitivity C2H2 sensing with LOD of 0.0007% (Experimental)
    [90] Si4.319ChG-on-MgF2 waveguide ~ 0.3% CO2 sensing (Experimental)
    [92] Borosilicate2.5-2.65AlN waveguideIdentification of methanol, ethanol and water
    [34] N-doped InP6.5Plasmon waveguideH2O/C2H5OH sensing with a high dynamic range of concentration (0-60%) and a resolution of 0.06%
    Table 1. Characteristics of the Mid-IR in-plane sensing units
    Ref.Wavelength/μmDevicePerformance & applications
    [93] ~5.09MIM-disk LSPR sensorFlexible sensor Sensivity: 1670 nm/RIU (Experimental) Detecting A549 cancer cells in a PBS+ solution
    [17] ~6.19 for C=C & ~7.98 for C-O-CMultifunctional chemical sensing platform based on dual-resonant infrared plasmonic MPAdetecting the states of PECA, including vibrational detection, thickness measurement, and observation of polymerization and curing
    [108] 5.88-6.67 for amide I–II & 3.33-3.57 for CH2Multi-resonant infrared metasurface sensorReal-time monitoring of lipid-protein systems in aqueous environments
    [117] 5.88-7.14Biosensor with passive molecule trapping functionalityL-proline & D-glucose sensing with a mass down to ~1 pg (Experimental)
    [119] ~6.67Hybrid graphene-metallic metasurface sensorMeasuring the monolayers of sub-nanometer-sized molecules or particles Affinity binding-based quantitative detection of glucose down to 200 pM (36 pg/mL) (Experimental)
    Table 2. Characteristics of the mid-IR out-of-plane SPR sensors
    Ref.StructureWavelength/WavenumberFeatureNotes
    [135] Disorder structure3 000-3 500 nmSingle channel FWHM can achieve 39 nmSimulation
    [136] Black phosphorus2-9 μm90 nm resolution with 4-7 μm bandwidth
    [137] Nano metal disk array1 000-4 000 cm−1Can recover two peaks with FWHM 76 cm−1, center interval 115 cm−1
    Table 3. Summary of reconstructive spectrometers
    Ref.StructureWavelength/WavenumberFeature
    [140] 42 MZIs array3.75 μm2.7 nm resolution with 57 nm bandwidth
    [141] 12 MZIs array3 000 cm−1Better than 10 cm−1 resolution with 50 cm−1 bandwidth
    [142] 19 MZIs array5-8.5 μmBetter than 15 cm−1 resolution with 132 cm−1 FSR
    [143] 10 MZIs array with thermo-optics modulation7.7 μmBetter than 15 cm−1 resolution with 603 cm−1 FSR
    [144] 4 channels MI with one MEMS driver1.55 μm, 2 μm2.4 nm resolution at 1.55 μm, 4.9 nm resolution at 2 μm
    Table 4. Summary of spatial heterodyne Fourier transform spectrometers
    Ref.Comb generationWavelength/μmPerformanceNotes
    [150] OPO2.9-3.14.2 cm−1 resolution with 200 nm bandwidth Provide an example for Mid-IR dual-comb on-chip spectrometer
    [151] DKS1.55Better than 400 kHz resolution with 37.5 THz bandwidth
    Table 5. Summary of dual-comb spectrometers
    Ref.TypeMaterialSpectral range or cutoff wavelengthKey featureNotes
    R: Responsivity, D*: Detectivity
    [159] InAsSb/InSbInAs/GaAs5-8 μm at 80 KLow dark current density
    [160] InSb~5.7 μm at 80 K ~6.3 μm at 200 K R: 0.7 A/W, D*:8.8×109 Jones
    [161] InAs/InAsSb~5.5 μm at 200 KR: 0.88 A/W, D*: 1.5×1010 Jones
    [165] 2D materialGraphene2.75 μm at room temperatureR: 0.13 A/WWaveguide integrated
    [166] Graphene3.8 μm at room temperatureR: 2.2 mA/WWaveguide integrated
    [24] Graphene2.0-2.55 μm (Research range)R: 250 mA/WWaveguide integrated
    [162] WS20.2 μm-3.043 μmR: 224 mA/W, D*: 1.5×1012 Jones
    [167] BP3.68-4.03 μm at room temperature (Research range)R: 23 A/W at 3.68 μm and 2 A/W at 4 μm Waveguide integrated
    [136] BP2-9 μmN/ATunable range
    [163] IVGeSn~2.3 μm at room temperatureR: 93 mA/W
    [164] GeSn~3.65 μm at 300 K, 22.3% SnR: 16.1 A/W, D*: 1.1×1010 Jones at 77 K and 12.5% Sn R: 3.2 mA/W, D*: 1.1×108 Jones at 300 K and 22.3% Sn
    Table 6. Summary of mid-IR integrated photodetectors
    Lipeng Xia, Yuheng Liu, Peiji Zhou, Yi Zou. Advances in mid-infrared integrated photonic sensing system (Invited)[J]. Infrared and Laser Engineering, 2022, 51(3): 20220104
    Download Citation