• Laser & Optoelectronics Progress
  • Vol. 55, Issue 11, 111005 (2018)
Qiaoyue Li1、*, Gangcheng Shang2, Qiang Tian3, Xi Chen1, Xixi Han1, Yu Zhou1, and Leida Li1
Author Affiliations
  • 1 School of Information and Control Engineering, China University of Mining and Technology, Xuzhou, Jiangsu 221116, China
  • 2 Communication and Information Center, State Administration of Work Safety, Beijing 100013, China
  • 3 Automatic Mine Office, Shanxi Lu'An Environmental Energy Development Co., Ltd., Changzhi, Shanxi 0 46102, China
  • show less
    DOI: 10.3788/LOP55.111005 Cite this Article Set citation alerts
    Qiaoyue Li, Gangcheng Shang, Qiang Tian, Xi Chen, Xixi Han, Yu Zhou, Leida Li. No-Reference Quality Assessment Method of Evaluating Scanning Electron Microscopy Images Based on Multi-Scale Characteristics[J]. Laser & Optoelectronics Progress, 2018, 55(11): 111005 Copy Citation Text show less
    Illustration of interactive system used in subjective viewing experiments
    Fig. 1. Illustration of interactive system used in subjective viewing experiments
    (a) Clear SEM images and (b)(c) corresponding contrast distortion images
    Fig. 2. (a) Clear SEM images and (b)(c) corresponding contrast distortion images
    Flow chart of proposed method
    Fig. 3. Flow chart of proposed method
    F statistics of the other metrics against the proposed method
    Fig. 4. F statistics of the other metrics against the proposed method
    AlgorithmPLCCSRCCRMSE
    FRMS-SSIM0.61160.60170.6846
    PSNR0.59140.55870.5839
    GMSD0.58770.55610.5859
    SSIM0.56180.54090.5222
    FSIM0.47930.45320.6355
    PCQI0.47210.44620.6792
    NRCORNIA0.81990.79330.3996
    DESIQUE0.76210.73090.4510
    BRISQUE0.72990.70380.4761
    Bliinds20.72160.69650.4786
    BIQI0.64620.63010.5356
    DIIVINE0.58540.56080.5611
    SSEQ0.57890.54640.5672
    NSS0.48640.47720.6170
    QAC0.42510.43000.6554
    NIQE0.35180.42340.6782
    FOR CDNR-CDIQA0.48640.47720.6170
    Proposed0.85040.82110.3733
    Table 1. Results of mainstream quality assessment methods and proposed method tested in the SEM database
    MetricMS-SSIMPSNRGMSDSSIMFSIMPCQINR-CDIQACORNIA
    11111110
    MetricDESIQUEBRISQUEBLLINDS-IIBIQIDIIVINESSEQQACNIQE
    11111111
    Table 2. Statistical performance results of compared metrics against the proposed method
    Qiaoyue Li, Gangcheng Shang, Qiang Tian, Xi Chen, Xixi Han, Yu Zhou, Leida Li. No-Reference Quality Assessment Method of Evaluating Scanning Electron Microscopy Images Based on Multi-Scale Characteristics[J]. Laser & Optoelectronics Progress, 2018, 55(11): 111005
    Download Citation