• Laser & Optoelectronics Progress
  • Vol. 58, Issue 12, 1212006 (2021)
Lili Shi, Weiguo Liu*, Ailing Tian, and Bingcai Liu
Author Affiliations
  • School of Defence Science and Technology, Xi’an Technological University, Xi’an, Shaanxi 710021, China
  • show less
    DOI: 10.3788/LOP202158.1212006 Cite this Article Set citation alerts
    Lili Shi, Weiguo Liu, Ailing Tian, Bingcai Liu. Comparison on Noise Resistance of Temporal Phase Unwrapping Algorithms[J]. Laser & Optoelectronics Progress, 2021, 58(12): 1212006 Copy Citation Text show less
    Normalized absolute phase diagrams (each row represents a method of phase decompression, with noise increasing from left to right). (a)--(d) Multi-frequency(hierarchical) phase unwrapping method; (e)--(h) negative exponential fitting method; (i)--(l) multi-wavelength (heterodyne) method; (m)--(p) multi-wavelength(heterodyne) method based on fringe location
    Fig. 1. Normalized absolute phase diagrams (each row represents a method of phase decompression, with noise increasing from left to right). (a)--(d) Multi-frequency(hierarchical) phase unwrapping method; (e)--(h) negative exponential fitting method; (i)--(l) multi-wavelength (heterodyne) method; (m)--(p) multi-wavelength(heterodyne) method based on fringe location
    Error trend diagram of four algorithms at different noise levels
    Fig. 2. Error trend diagram of four algorithms at different noise levels
    Normalized phase unwrapping results(the first row represents the value of the entire surface, and the second row corresponds to the expansion of the first row result in 800th row). (a)(e) Multi-frequency(hierarchical) phase unwrapping method; (b)(f) negative exponential fitting method; (c)(g) multi-wavelength (heterodyne) method; (d) (h) multi-wavelength(heterodyne) method based on fringe location
    Fig. 3. Normalized phase unwrapping results(the first row represents the value of the entire surface, and the second row corresponds to the expansion of the first row result in 800th row). (a)(e) Multi-frequency(hierarchical) phase unwrapping method; (b)(f) negative exponential fitting method; (c)(g) multi-wavelength (heterodyne) method; (d) (h) multi-wavelength(heterodyne) method based on fringe location
    Three-dimensional reconstruction diagrams. (a) Deformed fringe pattern; (b) wrapped phase map; (c) unwrapped phase map of negative exponential fitting; (d) reconstruction by multi-frequency(hierarchical) phase unwrapping method; (e) reconstruction by negative exponential fitting method; (f) reconstruction by multi-wavelength (heterodyne) method; (g) reconstruction by multi-wavelength (heterodyne) method based on fringe location
    Fig. 4. Three-dimensional reconstruction diagrams. (a) Deformed fringe pattern; (b) wrapped phase map; (c) unwrapped phase map of negative exponential fitting; (d) reconstruction by multi-frequency(hierarchical) phase unwrapping method; (e) reconstruction by negative exponential fitting method; (f) reconstruction by multi-wavelength (heterodyne) method; (g) reconstruction by multi-wavelength (heterodyne) method based on fringe location
    Temporal phase unwrapping algorithmRMSE /radSSE /radR
    Multi-frequency(hierarchical)0.00850869.940.9991
    Negative exponential fitting0.00849169.360.9991
    Multi-wavelength(heterodyne)0.017371290.340.9961
    Multi-wavelength(heterodyne) based on fringe location0.012172142.430.9981
    Table 1. Error comparison of four unwrapping algorithms
    Lili Shi, Weiguo Liu, Ailing Tian, Bingcai Liu. Comparison on Noise Resistance of Temporal Phase Unwrapping Algorithms[J]. Laser & Optoelectronics Progress, 2021, 58(12): 1212006
    Download Citation