• Journal of Inorganic Materials
  • Vol. 35, Issue 10, 1071 (2020)
Yanan WANG1、2、3, Hua LI1、2、3, Zhengkun WANG1, Qingfeng LI1, Chen LIAN1, and Xin HE1
Author Affiliations
  • 1School of Mechanical Engineering, Shandong University, Jinan 250061, China
  • 2Key Laboratory of High-Efficiency and Clean Mechanical Manufacture of Ministry of Education, Shandong University, Jinan 250061, China
  • 3National Demonstration Center for Experimental Mechanical Engineering Education, Shandong University, Jinan 250061, China
  • show less
    DOI: 10.15541/jim20190622 Cite this Article
    Yanan WANG, Hua LI, Zhengkun WANG, Qingfeng LI, Chen LIAN, Xin HE. Progress on Failure Mechanism of Lithium Ion Battery Caused by Diffusion Induced Stress[J]. Journal of Inorganic Materials, 2020, 35(10): 1071 Copy Citation Text show less
    Different scales of diffusion-induced stress in lithium-ion batteries
    1. Different scales of diffusion-induced stress in lithium-ion batteries
    Relationship between volume change ratio of graphite and SOC[9]
    2. Relationship between volume change ratio of graphite and SOC[9]
    Radial stress and tangential stress in the active particle[12]
    3. Radial stress and tangential stress in the active particle[12]
    Lithiation process of the spherical silicon particle[14]
    4. Lithiation process of the spherical silicon particle[14]
    (a) Nanowire particle and its lithiation process[23]; (b) Initial state and lithiation expansion state of nanowire particle with initial delamination defect[25]; (c) Initial state and lithiation expansion state of nanowire particle with mechanical clamping[26]
    5. (a) Nanowire particle and its lithiation process[23]; (b) Initial state and lithiation expansion state of nanowire particle with initial delamination defect[25]; (c) Initial state and lithiation expansion state of nanowire particle with mechanical clamping[26]
    (a) Solid sphere particle with carbon-coated shell[31]; (b) Lithium concentration distribution of carbon-coated solid sphere particle and hollow sphere particle during lithiation[32]; (c) Nanotube particle with carbon-coated shell[33]
    6. (a) Solid sphere particle with carbon-coated shell[31]; (b) Lithium concentration distribution of carbon-coated solid sphere particle and hollow sphere particle during lithiation[32]; (c) Nanotube particle with carbon-coated shell[33]
    (a) Delithiation process of spherical particle with two-phase deintercalation mechanism[35]; (b) Surface tangential stress of spherical particle during lithiation process with two-phase deintercalation mechanism[36], the hollow circle, solid circle, asterisk and star represent the initial dimensionless sizes of the particles as 0.01, 0.1, 1.0 and 10.0, respectively; (c) Relationship between critical dimension and discharge rate[42]
    7. (a) Delithiation process of spherical particle with two-phase deintercalation mechanism[35]; (b) Surface tangential stress of spherical particle during lithiation process with two-phase deintercalation mechanism[36], the hollow circle, solid circle, asterisk and star represent the initial dimensionless sizes of the particles as 0.01, 0.1, 1.0 and 10.0, respectively; (c) Relationship between critical dimension and discharge rate[42]
    (a) Lithium concentration distribution in the multi-particle model at 60% Depth of Discharge (DOD)[46,47]; (b) Multi-particle model considering homogeneous matrix and single-particle-matrix representative unit[48]; (c) Multi-particle-matrix electrode structure considering homogeneous matrix and diffusion-induced stress distribution of active particles during 1C discharge[50]
    8. (a) Lithium concentration distribution in the multi-particle model at 60% Depth of Discharge (DOD)[46,47]; (b) Multi-particle model considering homogeneous matrix and single-particle-matrix representative unit[48]; (c) Multi-particle-matrix electrode structure considering homogeneous matrix and diffusion-induced stress distribution of active particles during 1C discharge[50]
    (a) Multi-particle model established by X-ray scanning, (Black: The active particles and the binder; Blue: The electrolyte)[53]; (b) Diffusion-induced stress distribution of multi-particle model when fully charged at 1C rate[54]
    9. (a) Multi-particle model established by X-ray scanning, (Black: The active particles and the binder; Blue: The electrolyte)[53]; (b) Diffusion-induced stress distribution of multi-particle model when fully charged at 1C rate[54]
    Schematic diagrams of models
    10. Schematic diagrams of models
    (a) Initial state and lithiation deformation of the double-layer electrode considering plasticity of the current collector[62]; (b) Symmetrical electrode model composed of graphite active layers and copper current collector[63]; (c) Relationship between the elastic modulus of graphite and silicon and SOC[69]
    11. (a) Initial state and lithiation deformation of the double-layer electrode considering plasticity of the current collector[62]; (b) Symmetrical electrode model composed of graphite active layers and copper current collector[63]; (c) Relationship between the elastic modulus of graphite and silicon and SOC[69]
    (a) Double-layer silicon electrode cracks to form silicon islands (above), and double-layer electrode model of a silicon island constrained by a current collector (below)[73]; (b) Diffusion-induced stress distribution of the double-layer electrodes of silicon islands with initial defects after lithiation, the length ratios of the long and short axes of the initial defects are 0.2, 0.4, 0.6, 0.8 and 1, respectively[75]
    12. (a) Double-layer silicon electrode cracks to form silicon islands (above), and double-layer electrode model of a silicon island constrained by a current collector (below)[73]; (b) Diffusion-induced stress distribution of the double-layer electrodes of silicon islands with initial defects after lithiation, the length ratios of the long and short axes of the initial defects are 0.2, 0.4, 0.6, 0.8 and 1, respectively[75]
    Failure of particles in the NMC311 positive electrode[77]
    13. Failure of particles in the NMC311 positive electrode[77]
    Scanning electron micrographs of a silicon-carbon composite anode
    14. Scanning electron micrographs of a silicon-carbon composite anode
    Crack propagation of a silicon electrode[80]
    15. Crack propagation of a silicon electrode[80]
    (a) Diffusion-induced stress in the graphite anode during the first 3 cycles[85]; (b) Evolution of diffusion-induced stress in a Ge electrode during lithiation and delithiation, the arrows represent the moment when the electrode fractures[86]
    16. (a) Diffusion-induced stress in the graphite anode during the first 3 cycles[85]; (b) Evolution of diffusion-induced stress in a Ge electrode during lithiation and delithiation, the arrows represent the moment when the electrode fractures[86]
    Distribution of diffusion-induced stress in the cell unit during discharge, DOD are (a) 8%, (b) 54%, (c) 67% and (d) 100%, respectively[90]
    17. Distribution of diffusion-induced stress in the cell unit during discharge, DOD are (a) 8%, (b) 54%, (c) 67% and (d) 100%, respectively[90]
    Surface pressure during charge and discharge of a prismatic cell [93]
    18. Surface pressure during charge and discharge of a prismatic cell [93]
    (a) Experimental schematic diagram of the external constraint and EIS test[94]; (b) Impedance as a function of cycle times at different external pressures[95]; (c) Effect of external constraints on cycle lifetime of the cell, of which blue, green, yellow and red lines representing external constraints of 0, 0.05, 0.5 and 5 MPa, respectively[96]; (d) SOH as a function of cycle times, of which blue, red, yellow, and purple lines representing no external constraint, constant thickness constraint, elastic element constraint, and constant force spring constraint, respectively[97]
    19. (a) Experimental schematic diagram of the external constraint and EIS test[94]; (b) Impedance as a function of cycle times at different external pressures[95]; (c) Effect of external constraints on cycle lifetime of the cell, of which blue, green, yellow and red lines representing external constraints of 0, 0.05, 0.5 and 5 MPa, respectively[96]; (d) SOH as a function of cycle times, of which blue, red, yellow, and purple lines representing no external constraint, constant thickness constraint, elastic element constraint, and constant force spring constraint, respectively[97]
    Deformation of jelly roll after charge and discharge cycles (a) X-ray scan result and (b) Laser microscope result[101]
    20. Deformation of jelly roll after charge and discharge cycles (a) X-ray scan result and (b) Laser microscope result[101]
    FactorSpecific interpretationRef.
    Particle shapeSolid sphere, hollow sphere, ellipsoid, cube, etc.[14-20]
    Particle sizeRadius/diameter, shell thickness, aspect ratio, edge length, etc.[14-20]
    Material propertiesLithium expansion coefficient, elastic modulus, plastic deformation, strain rate, partial molar volume, medium expansion rate, lithium diffusion coefficient, etc.[10, 21-22][28-30]
    Nanowires and nanotubesSlender linear or tubular structures with small diameters[11, 23-30]
    Coating shellCarbon coating, alumina coating, etc.[31-34]
    Phase separationSingle- and two-phase deintercalation mechanism[34-37]
    Dislocation effectMicroscopic defects in crystalline materials caused by local irregular arrangement of atoms[38-41]
    Charging and discharging conditionsRatio and strategy of charging and discharging, etc.[4, 42-44]
    Table 1. Factors affecting diffusion-induced stress in a single particle model
    Failure phenomenonCorresponding mechanismRef.
    Capacity decay/lifetime reductionSide reaction of active particles and electrolyte results in regeneration of SEI film[99]
    Excessive stress causes fracture of electrode[100]
    Uneven distribution of pressure inside cell brings about lithium precipitation on electrode[100, 103]
    Deformation of jelly roll leads to delamination between active layer and current collector[101]
    Impedance risePorosity decreasing and tortuosity increasing of positive and negative electrodes and separator[94-95]
    Deformation of jelly roll leads to delamination between active layer and current collector[101]
    Table 2. Failure phenomenon of cell and their corresponding mechanism
    Yanan WANG, Hua LI, Zhengkun WANG, Qingfeng LI, Chen LIAN, Xin HE. Progress on Failure Mechanism of Lithium Ion Battery Caused by Diffusion Induced Stress[J]. Journal of Inorganic Materials, 2020, 35(10): 1071
    Download Citation