• Laser & Optoelectronics Progress
  • Vol. 57, Issue 10, 101012 (2020)
Ping Zhang1, Yongze Ding2、**, Zhipeng Wang1, Beichen Li1、*, and Zhiren Tian3
Author Affiliations
  • 1School of Electrical and Information Engineering, Tianjin University, Tianjin 300072, China
  • 2School of Microelectronics, Tianjin University, Tianjin 300072, China
  • 3China Southern Power Grid Co., Ltd., Guangzhou, Guangdong 510670, China
  • show less
    DOI: 10.3788/LOP57.101012 Cite this Article Set citation alerts
    Ping Zhang, Yongze Ding, Zhipeng Wang, Beichen Li, Zhiren Tian. Accurate Reading and Reliability Estimation Model of Substation Pointer Meter[J]. Laser & Optoelectronics Progress, 2020, 57(10): 101012 Copy Citation Text show less
    Overall flow chart of proposed method
    Fig. 1. Overall flow chart of proposed method
    Detection of pointer tip positioning
    Fig. 2. Detection of pointer tip positioning
    Schematic of the meter reading
    Fig. 3. Schematic of the meter reading
    Overall flow chart of instrument reading algorithm
    Fig. 4. Overall flow chart of instrument reading algorithm
    Flow chart of consistently significant algorithm
    Fig. 5. Flow chart of consistently significant algorithm
    Two-parameter Gaussian model. (a) Gaussian model curves of distance; (b) Gaussian model curves of angle
    Fig. 6. Two-parameter Gaussian model. (a) Gaussian model curves of distance; (b) Gaussian model curves of angle
    Two-parameter three-dimensional Gaussian model. (a) Schematic of three-dimensional Gaussian model; (b) top view of three-dimensional Gaussian model
    Fig. 7. Two-parameter three-dimensional Gaussian model. (a) Schematic of three-dimensional Gaussian model; (b) top view of three-dimensional Gaussian model
    Results of initial tick mark, end tick mark, and hand extraction. (a) Original input images; (b)tick rings; (c) meter rings; (d) experimental results by proposed method
    Fig. 8. Results of initial tick mark, end tick mark, and hand extraction. (a) Original input images; (b)tick rings; (c) meter rings; (d) experimental results by proposed method
    Comparison of pointer location results. (a) Traditional Hough method; (b) proposed method
    Fig. 9. Comparison of pointer location results. (a) Traditional Hough method; (b) proposed method
    Comparison of consistently significant detection effects. (a) Original input image; (b) consistent saliency detection; (c) single image saliency detection
    Fig. 10. Comparison of consistently significant detection effects. (a) Original input image; (b) consistent saliency detection; (c) single image saliency detection
    Comparison of consistently significant image reading results. (a) Significant image reading results; (b) partial enlargements; (c) deviation from the rectangular frame by two algorithms
    Fig. 11. Comparison of consistently significant image reading results. (a) Significant image reading results; (b) partial enlargements; (c) deviation from the rectangular frame by two algorithms
    NumberAveragevalue ofmanual readingReading resultof proposedalgorithmErrorrate /%
    10.0150.01595.6
    20.0230.02414.6
    30.0170.01606.3
    40.0660.06792.8
    50.0320.03303.1
    Table 1. Error rate of initial tick reading results
    NumberProposed algorithmHough algorithm
    AngledeviationDistancedeviationReliabilityestimation /%AngledeviationDistancedeviationReliabilityestimation /%
    12.002.26953.703.4193
    2-0.993.6495-4.217.6288
    30.000.001009.313.310
    40.961.35976.865.4287
    5-2.291.91955.322.4192
    Table 2. Test results of reliability estimation model
    Ping Zhang, Yongze Ding, Zhipeng Wang, Beichen Li, Zhiren Tian. Accurate Reading and Reliability Estimation Model of Substation Pointer Meter[J]. Laser & Optoelectronics Progress, 2020, 57(10): 101012
    Download Citation