Fig. 1. Two-dimensional and three-dimensional convolution network diagrams. (a) 2D-CNN; (b) 3D-CNN
Fig. 2. Normal and dilated convolution kernel diagrams. (a) Normal kernel; (b) dilated kernel (r=2)
Fig. 3. Seven permutation and combination types of dilated and normal convolutional layers and two activation function distribution strategies. (a) Type 1; (b) type 2; (c) type 3; (d) type 4; (e) type 5; (f) type 6; (g) type 7; (h) distribution strategy Ⅰ; (i) distribution strategy Ⅱ
Fig. 4. Receptive field's distributions of different convolution combinations. (a) Dilation parameter distribution is (2,2,2); (b) dilation parameter distribution is (1,2,2); (c) dilation parameter distribution is (1,1,2)
Fig. 5. Network structure
Fig. 6. Corresponding precision of dilation rate in two datasets. (a) Indian Pines spectral dimension; (b) Salinas spectral dimension; (c) Indian Pines spatial dimension; (d) Salinas spatial dimension
Fig. 7. Pseudo-color composite images of two datasets. (a) Indian Pines; (b) Salinas
Fig. 8. Classification images of different network models in Indian Pines dataset. (a) True value image; (b) SVM; (c) 2D-CNN; (d) Res-3DCNN; (e) M3D-DCNN; (f) 3D-CNN; (g) Dilated-3D-CNN
Fig. 9. Classification images of different network models in Salinas dataset. (a) True value image; (b) SVM; (c) 2D-CNN; (d) Res-3DCNN; (e) M3D-DCNN; (f) 3D-CNN; (g) Dilated-3D-CNN
Structure type | Indian Pines | Salinas |
---|
Kappa | OA | AA | OA-mean | Kappa | OA | AA | OA-mean |
---|
Type 1-Ⅰ | 95.852 | 96.976 | 92.041 | 96.942 | 95.797 | 96.986 | 94.524 | | 96.823 | Type 2-Ⅰ | 95.676 | 96.851 | 91.499 | 95.534 | 96.794 | 94.748 | | Type 3-Ⅰ | 95.885 | 97.000 | 91.383 | 95.388 | 96.690 | 94.694 | | Type 4-Ⅰ | 95.155 | 96.480 | 90.501 | 96.505 | 95.862 | 97.028 | 95.027 | 96.943 | Type 5-Ⅰ | 94.811 | 96.232 | 89.872 | 95.808 | 96.991 | 94.772 | Type 6-Ⅰ | 95.609 | 96.801 | 91.559 | 95.554 | 96.810 | 94.666 | Type 7-Ⅰ | 95.680 | 96.855 | 91.335 | 96.855 | 95.320 | 96.644 | 94.192 | 96.644 |
|
Table 1. [in Chinese]
Structure type | Indian Pines | Salinas |
---|
Kappa | OA | AA | OA-mean | Kappa | OA | AA | OA-mean |
---|
Type 1-Ⅱ | 95.976 | 97.066 | 91.912 | 96.973 | 95.804 | 96.989 | 94.793 | 96.944 | Type 2-Ⅱ | 95.698 | 96.866 | 91.800 | 95.883 | 97.045 | 94.903 | Type 3-Ⅱ | 95.866 | 96.987 | 91.956 | 95.532 | 96.796 | 94.432 | Type 4-Ⅱ | 95.775 | 96.921 | 91.839 | 96.689 | 95.455 | 96.741 | 94.262 | 96.856 | Type 5-Ⅱ | 94.798 | 96.220 | 90.179 | 95.718 | 96.928 | 94.737 | Type 6-Ⅱ | 95.783 | 96.927 | 91.543 | 95.676 | 96.898 | 94.682 | Type 7-Ⅱ | 95.618 | 96.808 | 91.351 | 96.808 | 95.457 | 96.739 | 94.568 | 96.739 |
|
Table 2. [in Chinese]
Class name | Classification accuracy |
---|
SVM | 2D-CNN | Res-3DCNN | M3D-DCNN | 3D-CNN | Dilated-3D-CNN |
---|
Background | 69.123 | 98.797 | 98.406 | 99.240 | 99.376 | 99.653 | Alfalfa | 24.348 | 52.174 | 73.587 | 69.130 | 82.065 | 82.065 | Corn-notill | 61.583 | 85.007 | 84.352 | 88.235 | 93.092 | 94.492 | Corn-mintill | 40.126 | 80.624 | 86.640 | 89.329 | 92.948 | 94.555 | Corn | 29.473 | 77.426 | 84.325 | 88.270 | 93.418 | 92.806 | Grass-pasture | 73.113 | 83.013 | 83.046 | 86.115 | 90.971 | 91.766 | Grass-trees | 75.993 | 89.370 | 89.411 | 92.493 | 94.945 | 96.075 | Grass-pasture-mowed | 23.750 | 58.036 | 70.893 | 70.714 | 78.750 | 81.786 | Hay-windrowed | 85.471 | 97.406 | 97.416 | 97.699 | 98.180 | 98.441 | Oats | 22.750 | 49.250 | 47.000 | 72.000 | 75.250 | 87.000 | Soybean-notill | 55.710 | 84.767 | 84.268 | 88.971 | 93.897 | 95.307 | Soybean-mintill | 71.536 | 91.440 | 89.668 | 93.733 | 96.449 | 97.132 | Soybean-clean | 40.780 | 72.686 | 75.941 | 86.169 | 89.771 | 92.119 | Wheat | 84.293 | 93.317 | 94.756 | 95.683 | 96.585 | 97.390 | Woods | 55.486 | 86.644 | 86.067 | 92.518 | 95.636 | 95.945 | Buildings-Grass-Trees-Drives | 28.455 | 58.503 | 63.965 | 77.532 | 87.946 | 90.303 | Stone-Steel-Towers | 33.441 | 77.796 | 81.667 | 86.237 | 90.860 | 89.570 | Kappa | 54.791 | 88.317 | 88.514 | 92.541 | 95.377 | 96.304 | OA | 64.636 | 91.721 | 91.820 | 94.622 | 96.634 | 97.303 | AA | 51.496 | 78.603 | 81.848 | 86.710 | 91.185 | 92.730 |
|
Table 3. [in Chinese]
Class name | Classification accuracy |
---|
SVM | 2D-CNN | Res-3DCNN | M3D-DCNN | 3D-CNN | Dilated-3D-CNN |
---|
Background | 70.502 | 98.295 | 98.365 | 98.491 | 98.672 | 98.806 | Brocoli-green-weeds-1 | 94.556 | 95.768 | 91.594 | 86.573 | 95.888 | 96.374 | Brocoli-green-weeds-2 | 95.456 | 98.332 | 97.772 | 98.552 | 98.355 | 98.395 | Fallow | 44.098 | 86.180 | 73.336 | 86.282 | 89.653 | 90.567 | Fallow-rough-plow | 60.740 | 82.123 | 80.289 | 86.596 | 88.238 | 90.585 | Fallow-smooth | 47.043 | 87.957 | 87.580 | 89.402 | 91.423 | 91.356 | Stubble | 98.964 | 96.419 | 95.926 | 87.176 | 96.583 | 96.638 | Celery | 91.562 | 96.462 | 96.159 | 97.399 | 97.122 | 97.837 | Grapes-untrained | 83.636 | 92.165 | 92.618 | 93.300 | 95.896 | 96.643 | Soil-vinyard-develop | 64.362 | 93.482 | 92.085 | 93.865 | 95.142 | 96.079 | Corn-senesced-green-weeds | 79.297 | 92.466 | 90.876 | 92.527 | 95.597 | 95.165 | Lettuce-romaine-4wk | 71.196 | 94.180 | 93.153 | 94.094 | 95.781 | 95.058 | Lettuce-romaine-5wk | 31.651 | 95.916 | 90.497 | 94.714 | 97.738 | 98.093 | Lettuce-romaine-6wk | 22.858 | 86.096 | 71.331 | 90.291 | 91.745 | 92.651 | Lettuce-romaine-7wk | 52.255 | 86.670 | 83.944 | 88.426 | 89.789 | 90.792 | Vinyard-untrained | 38.987 | 85.982 | 83.519 | 87.330 | 93.218 | 95.129 | Vinyard-vertical-trellis | 97.662 | 95.990 | 96.006 | 96.231 | 96.068 | 96.388 | Kappa | 61.951 | 93.267 | 92.013 | 93.226 | 95.567 | 96.149 | OA | 70.697 | 95.185 | 94.324 | 95.178 | 96.820 | 97.236 | AA | 67.343 | 92.028 | 89.121 | 91.838 | 94.524 | 95.091 |
|
Table 4. [in Chinese]