• Opto-Electronic Advances
  • Vol. 6, Issue 12, 230172 (2023)
Maciej Trusiak* and Malgorzata Kujawinska**
Author Affiliations
  • Institute of Micromechanics and Photonics, Warsaw University of Technology, 8 Sw. A. Boboli Street, Warsaw 02-525, Poland
  • show less
    DOI: 10.29026/oea.2023.230172 Cite this Article
    Maciej Trusiak, Malgorzata Kujawinska. Deep learning enabled single-shot absolute phase recovery in high-speed composite fringe pattern profilometry of separated objects[J]. Opto-Electronic Advances, 2023, 6(12): 230172 Copy Citation Text show less

    Abstract

    A recent article in the Opto-Electronic Advances (OEA) journal from Prof. Qian Chen and Prof. Chao Zuo’s group introduced a new and efficient 3D imaging system that captures high-speed images using deep learning-enabled fringe projection profilometry (FPP). In this News & Views article, we explore potential avenues for future advancements, including expanding the measurement range through an extended number-theoretical approach, enhancing quality through the incorporation of horizontal fringes, and integrating data from other modalities to broaden the system's applications.

    However, obtaining high-quality absolute phase information remains challenging due to variations in reflectance, shadows, and high directional gradients in shape. Also, the depth of a measured 3D scene (a measurement range) is limited. The authors emphasize their plans to explore advanced network structures and integrate more suitable physical models into deep learning networks to achieve higher speed, accuracy, and robustness in 3D shape measurement using fewer neural networks or in an end-to-end manner. These AI based enhancements can be assisted by modification of the measurement scenario followed by the proposed DCFPP processing scheme. In Fig. 2 we present two possible avenues for future research. The first scenario can be utilized when the extension of the measurement range is required. In such a case third or additional wavelengths (fringe pattern frequencies) can be added to project more complex composite fringe pattern (Fig. 2(a, b)) and follow a similar framework as proposed in the Gushov-Solodkin algorithm23. In this way the measurement range W is expanded from LCM(λh; λl) ≥ W for two wavelength scheme up to LCM(λh; λm; λl) ≥ Wext for three wavelength scheme, where LCM represents the least common multiple function. The second proposed modification relies on projection a cross fringe composite pattern, namely both vertical and horizontal (or generally inclined with a given angle) fringe families followed by utilizing of the proposed DCFPP processing scheme separately for the information extracted from vertical and horizontal fringes and finally merging the reconstructed phases (Fig. 2(c)).

    Such measurement and processing scenario could be investigated to minimize directional errors including reduction of the influence of variations of reflectance and occurrence of shadows in an object.

    Back cover of Volume 5, Issue 5 of OEA in 2022.

    Figure 1.Back cover of Volume 5, Issue 5 of OEA in 2022.

    High-speed and high-precision 3D imaging has become a crucial aspect of numerous scientific and industrial applications1, 2. From robotics and autonomous navigation to biomedical imaging and cultural heritage preservation, the demand for accurate non-contact and real-time measurements of 3D surface geometry continues to grow. Structured light (SL) based 3D imaging techniques3, 4 have already proven their great usefulness and capability in meeting these demands. However, traditional SL approaches often require multiple frames5, 6 to achieve high-resolution reconstructions, leading to longer acquisition times and potential motion artifacts.

    To solve the phase ambiguity problem, Takeda et al.10 introduced frequency multiplexing (FM) to fringe projection profilometry1-4 to encode two fringe patterns with different spatial carriers into a single snapshot measurement which can be demodulated from the FM composite fringe to remove the periodic phase ambiguity. Alternatively, Zhang et al.11 proposed the color frequency multiplexing SL method, in which three sinusoidal fringe patterns with different frequencies are encoded into the red, green and blue (RGB) channels of a color image and three wrapped phases with different frequencies can be demodulated from the RGB channels of the captured image. However, as derivatives of FTP, these FM techniques achieved limited success for measuring complex surfaces due to the unavoidable frequency overlapping, spectrum leakage, and channel crosstalk.

    New concept in FPP based SL considers implementation of deep learning based frameworks to solve intensity-phase domain transition problem12-16. It is based on fringe pattern analysis via especially tailored convolutional neural networks. Phase, although the most important, is one of the parameters that describe and thus can be demodulated from a fringe pattern, alongside with fringe pattern density17, orientation18 and background19, 20. In the recent work21 entitled “Deep-learning-enabled dual-frequency composite fringe projection profilometry for single-shot absolute 3D shape measurement” published in Opto-Electronic Advances (DOI: 10.29026/oea.2022.210021), Prof. Qian Chen and Chao Zuo’s group, among main actors in the DL-based SL field, proposed a novel single-shot high-precision 3D imaging method called deep learning-enabled composite fringe projection profilometry (DCFPP) technique, which showcases how deep learning can effectively assist in recovering the absolute phase, thereby enabling precise 3D shape reconstruction from a single frequency-multiplexed fringe image of intricate or isolated objects. This article was selected as the back cover paper of Volume 5, Issue 5 of OEA in 2022 (Fig. 1). Diverging from conventional end-to-end network architectures16, 22, which often exhibit poor accuracy in directly predicting absolute phase or depth from images12, this research introduces a novel approach. It leverages a dual-frequency compound fringe pattern as the sole input to the network and modifies the output to three components encompassing the wrapped phase arctangent function numerator and denominator terms and the absolute phase map. This work opens new avenues for single-shot, instantaneous 3D shape measurement of discontinuous and/or mutually isolated objects in fast motion.

    Possible future extension of the proposed DCFPP technique: (a) the example triple-frequency projected vertical and cross fringe patterns and their spectra, (b) the hardware system and (c) the enhanced shape reconstruction using cross fringe pattern and two channel reconstructions for vertical and horizontal composite fringe patterns.

    Figure 2.Possible future extension of the proposed DCFPP technique: (a) the example triple-frequency projected vertical and cross fringe patterns and their spectra, (b) the hardware system and (c) the enhanced shape reconstruction using cross fringe pattern and two channel reconstructions for vertical and horizontal composite fringe patterns.

    In comparison to the traditional Fourier transform method, the presented approach mitigates the reduced 3D measurement accuracy caused by spectrum aliasing resulting from generally low spatial frequency of the projected double-frequency pattern. The proposed method achieves performance similar to that of the traditional 12-step phase-shifting method, which is a remarkable result for a single-shot approach. The study demonstrates the efficacy of deep learning in synthesizing both temporal and spatial information, effectively addressing the spectrum-aliasing problem. The article concludes that this approach overcomes the limitations of traditional multi-frequency composite methods and single end-to-end deep learning networks. The utilization of two joined networks proves advantageous as it decomposes the problem into two lines, aligning with the inherent working principle of networks that decompose problems into subsets of convolutional layers.

    Another promising avenue for future research involves merging information from other modalities, such as digital image correlation, to enable dynamic 3D shape and displacement mapping24, potentially advancing the fields of experimental mechanics and structural integrity.

    Nevertheless, high-precision 3D reconstruction using only one single pattern has been the ultimate goal of structured light 3D imaging in perpetual pursuit. Fourier transform profilometry (FTP)7, in which the wrapped phase is decoded by Fourier filtering in the fringe pattern spatial frequency domain, enables to demodulate the phase from a single fringe pattern. However, the FTP technique limited to measuring smooth surfaces with limited height variations. In addition, the wrapped phase retrieved by FTP suffers from periodic ambiguity, which typically requires multi-frequency temporal phase unwrapping methods to unwrap and obtain the continuous, absolute phase distribution8. Spatial carrier phase shifting methods were also proposed, with similar single-shot limitations9.

    References

    [1] S Zhang. High-speed 3D shape measurement with structured light methods: a review. Opt Lasers Eng, 119-131(2018).

    [2] XY Su, QC Zhang. Dynamic 3-D shape measurement method: a review. Opt Lasers Eng, 191-204(2010).

    [3] J Geng. Structured-light 3D surface imaging: a tutorial. Adv Opt Photonics, 128-160(2011).

    [4] SS Gorthi, P Rastogi. Fringe projection techniques: whither we are. Opt Lasers Eng, 133-140(2010).

    [5] R Sitnik, M Kujawińska, JM Woźnicki. Digital fringe projection system for large-volume 360-deg shape measurement. Opt Eng, 443-449(2002).

    [6] C Zuo, SJ Feng, L Huang, TY Tao, W Yin et al. Phase shifting algorithms for fringe projection profilometry: a review. Opt Lasers Eng, 23-59(2018).

    [7] M Takeda, K Mutoh. Fourier transform profilometry for the automatic measurement of 3-D object shapes. Appl Opt, 3977-3982(1983).

    [8] C Zuo, L Huang, ML Zhang, Q Chen, A Asundi. Temporal phase unwrapping algorithms for fringe projection profilometry: a comparative review. Opt Lasers Eng, 84-103(2016).

    [9] M Pirga, M Kujawinska. Two directional spatial-carrier phase-shifting method for analysis of crossed and closed fringe patterns. Opt Eng, 2459-2466(1995).

    [10] M Takeda, Q Gu, M Kinoshita, H Takai, Y Takahashi. Frequency-multiplex Fourier-transform profilometry: a single-shot three-dimensional shape measurement of objects with large height discontinuities and/or surface isolations. Appl Opt, 5347-5354(1997).

    [11] ZH Zhang. Review of single-shot 3D shape measurement by phase calculation-based fringe projection techniques. Opt Lasers Eng, 1097-1106(2012).

    [12] C Zuo, JM Qian, SJ Feng, W Yin, YX Li et al. Deep learning in optical metrology: a review. Light Sci Appl, 39(2022).

    [13] SJ Feng, Q Chen, GH Gu, TY Tao, L Zhang et al. Fringe pattern analysis using deep learning. Adv Photonics, 025001(2019).

    [14] W Yin, Q Chen, SJ Feng, TY Tao, L Huang et al. Temporal phase unwrapping using deep learning. Sci Rep, 20175(2019).

    [15] JM Qian, SJ Feng, TY Tao, Y Hu, YX Li et al. Deep-learning-enabled geometric constraints and phase unwrapping for single-shot absolute 3D shape measurement. APL Photonics, 046105(2020).

    [16] der Jeught S Van, JJJ Dirckx. Deep neural networks for single shot structured light profilometry. Opt Express, 17091-17101(2019).

    [17] M Cywińska, F Brzeski, W Krajnik, K Patorski, C Zuo et al. DeepDensity: convolutional neural network based estimation of local fringe pattern density. Opt Lasers Eng, 106675(2021).

    [18] M Cywińska, M Rogalski, F Brzeski, K Patorski, M Trusiak. DeepOrientation: convolutional neural network for fringe pattern orientation map estimation. Opt Express, 42283-42299(2022).

    [19] ZS Li, JS Sun, Y Fan, YB Jin, Q Shen et al. Deep learning assisted variational Hilbert quantitative phase imaging. Opto-Electron Sci, 220023(2023).

    [20] M Cywińska, K Szumigaj, M Kołodziej, K Patorski, V Mico et al. DeepVID: deep-learning accelerated variational image decomposition model tailored to fringe pattern filtration. J Opt, 045702(2023).

    [21] YX Li, JM Qian, SJ Feng, Q Chen, C Zuo. Deep-learning-enabled dual-frequency composite fringe projection profilometry for single-shot absolute 3D shape measurement. Opto-Electron Adv, 210021(2022).

    [22] H Nguyen, YZ Wang, ZY Wang. Single-shot 3D shape reconstruction using structured light and deep convolutional neural networks. Sensors, 3718(2020).

    [23] VI Gushov, YN Solodkin. Automatic processing of fringe patterns in integer interferometers. Opt Lasers Eng, 311-324(1991).

    [24] A Papanikolaou, D Dzik-Kruszelnicka, M Kujawinska. Spatio-temporal monitoring of humidity induced 3D displacements and strains in mounted and unmounted parchments. Herit Sci, 15(2022).

    Maciej Trusiak, Malgorzata Kujawinska. Deep learning enabled single-shot absolute phase recovery in high-speed composite fringe pattern profilometry of separated objects[J]. Opto-Electronic Advances, 2023, 6(12): 230172
    Download Citation