• Opto-Electronic Advances
  • Vol. 5, Issue 2, 200051 (2022)
Tangyao Shen1、†, Jiajun Qin2、†, Yujie Bai1、†, Jia Zhang3, Lei Shi1、*, Xiaoyuan Hou1, Jian Zi1、*, and Bin Hu3、*
Author Affiliations
  • 1Department of Physics, Fudan University, Shanghai 200433, China
  • 2Department of Physics, Chemistry and Biology (IFM), Linköping University, Linköping 58183, Sweden
  • 3Department of Materials Science and Engineering, University of Tennessee, Knoxville, Tennessee 37996, USA
  • show less
    DOI: 10.29026/oea.2022.200051 Cite this Article
    Tangyao Shen, Jiajun Qin, Yujie Bai, Jia Zhang, Lei Shi, Xiaoyuan Hou, Jian Zi, Bin Hu. Giant magneto field effect in up-conversion amplified spontaneous emission via spatially extended states in organic-inorganic hybrid perovskites[J]. Opto-Electronic Advances, 2022, 5(2): 200051 Copy Citation Text show less

    Abstract

    Up-conversion lasing actions are normally difficult to realize in light-emitting materials due to small multi-photon absorption cross section and fast dephasing of excited states during multi-photon excitation. This paper reports an easily accessible up-conversion amplified spontaneous emission (ASE) in organic-inorganic hybrid perovskites (MAPbBr3) films by optically exciting broad gap states with sub-bandgap laser excitation. The broad absorption was optimized by adjusting the grain sizes in the MAPbBr3 films. At low sub-bandgap pumping intensities, directly exciting the gap states leads to 2-photon, 3-photon, and 4-photon up-conversion spontaneous emission, revealing a large optical cross section of multi-photon excitation occurring in such hybrid perovskite films. At moderate pumping intensity (1.19 mJ/cm2) of 700 nm laser excitation, a significant spectral narrowing phenomenon was observed with the full width at half maximum (FWHM) decreasing from 18 nm to 4 nm at the peak wavelength of 550 nm, simultaneously with a nonlinear increase on spectral peak intensity, showing an up-conversion ASE realized at low threshold pumping fluence. More interestingly, the up-conversion ASE demonstrated a giant magnetic field effect, leading to a magneto-ASE reaching 120%. In contrast, the up-conversion photoluminescence (PL) showed a negligible magnetic field effect (< 1%). This observation provides an evidence to indicate that the light-emitting states responsible for up-conversion ASE are essentially formed as spatially extended states. The angular dependent spectrum results further verify the existence of spatially extended states which are polarized to develop coherent in-phase interaction. Clearly, using broad gap states with spatially extended light-emitting states presents a new approach to develop up-conversion ASE in organic-inorganic hybrid perovskites.

    Introduction

    Organic-inorganic hybrid perovskites are known as solution-processing semiconductors with highly efficient light emission covering entire visible spectrum region under down-conversion condition1-5. It has been reported that the photoluminescence quantum yield can be as high as 90% in solid states6-8. Recently, such hybrid perovskites have demonstrated lasing actions through ASE at low pumping fluence9-18. This development indicates that hybrid perovskites are potential lasing materials with solution processing-tunable properties through down-conversion excitation. Although it is often difficult to realize up-conversion lasing actions in most light-emitting materials due to small multi-photon absorption cross section and dephasing in excited states during multi-photon excitation19-21, experimental studies have shown successful up-conversion ASE in both inorganic cesium perovskites and organic-inorganic hybrid (MAPbBr3) perovskites22-29. This indicates great potential for coherent control of light emitting states through multi-photon excitation in hybrid perovskites. Yet, it still demands further investigations to reveal the underlying mechanisms responsible for up-conversion ASE.

    Toward unrevealing the collective emission of up-conversion ASE, magnetic field effect is proposed to be an effective tool. This method has been widely reported in exploring the behavior between light emitting states in organics and halide perovskites30-34. Generally, weak coupling of these excited states results in a relatively small magnetic field effects (less than 10%)32, which hinders its applications in real functional devices. In view of coherent emission in ASE region, much stronger coupling of excited states for collective correlations is expected, giving rise to a great potential to facilitate magnetic field effects.

    In this work, we prepare the perovskite (MAPbBr3) films with large grains in scale of several micrometers through our previous reported method35, 36 to investigate the possibilities of using gap states to realize up-conversion ASE. By absorption measurements, high broad-band absorption is observed in the sub-bandgap energy region, indicating the formation of gap states in spectral region from 600 nm to 1300 nm. These gap states give rise to a large cross section of multiphoton absorption, resulting in strong up-conversion PL under low pumping intensities. More interestingly, the up-conversion ASE shows a significant increasement (over 120%) upon applying the magnetic field of 1.2 T, generating giant magnetic field effects. The observed giant magnetic field effects provide an evidence to show that an orbital order is formed in spatially extended states by exciting broad gap states. Essentially, with orbital order the spatially extended states develop a cooperative interaction towards generating an ASE in hybrid halide perovskites prepared with large grains through fast crystallization.

    Materials and methods

    Preparation of perovskite (MAPbBr3) films

    The perovskite films were spin-coated with the thickness of 1 micrometer onto the ITO/PEDOT:PSS substrates at N2 atmosphere. Essentially, the perovskite films were prepared with one-step spin-coating method by using the precursor solution (1.5 mmol PbBr2 and 1.58 mmol MABr in 1 mL DMF solution) at the spinning rate of 3000 rpm for 1 minute, followed by annealing at 60oC for 30 minutes. The grain size can be largely changed by partially replacing DMF with DMSO. Prior to the preparation of perovskite films, the PEDOT:PSS films were spin-coated on glass substrates with the thickness of 40 nm, followed with the thermal annealing at 150oC for 0.5 h. With the glass/PEDOT substrates, high-quality perovskite films can be formed through spin coating.

    Measurement of absorption spectrum

    A thin-film transmittance and reflectance spectrometer (RT1736, Ideaoptics, China) was used to measure the absorption of the sample with an integrating sphere (R7, Ideaoptics, China) to eliminate the influence of scattering, equipped with a visible spectrometer (PG2000-pro, Ideaoptics, China) and a NIR spectrometer (NIR1700, Ideaoptics, China). A halogen lamp and a deuterium lamp were used as visible and infrared light source. The transmittance and reflectance of the sample and the substrate were measured, and then the absorption can be derived by the formula A= 1-T-R. The absorption of substrate was deducted from the whole absorption of the sample to derive the net absorption of the perovskite film.

    Measurement of photoluminescence spectrum

    All pumping wavelengths in the experiment were selected from a Coherent Legend regenerative amplifier (150 fs, 1 kHz, 800 nm) which is seeded by a Coherent Mira 900 oscillator (100 fs, 80 MHz). The Mira is seeded by a Coherent Verdi Laser Generator (continuous wave, 532 nm). A Coherent Opera Solo was used to convert the 800 nm pulse laser to wavelength suitable for the experiment, without changing other parameters. The excitation beam was focused on the sample with the diameter of about 100 micrometers. The output signals were sent into the spectrometer (Horiba, iHR320)) and detected by a charge coupled device (Horiba, Synapse).

    Measurement of angular dependence

    An R1 Angular-Resolved System (R1, Ideaoptics, China) equipped with a visible spectrometer (PG2000, Ideaoptics, China) was used to measure the angular dependence of the emission from the perovskite (MAPbBr3) film. The sample was fixed vertically, and a photodetector was fixed on a mechanical arm which can rotate around a horizontal axis in the film plane. The excitation beam focused perpendicularly on the sample intersecting with the axis by a lens. By rotating the mechanical arm to different position, photoluminescence in different emitting angle can be measured.

    Measurement of magnetic field effects

    An electromagnet was used to generate a constant magnetic field of 1.2 T paralleled to the perovskite (MAPbBr3) film. The constant magnetic field was switched on and off through electrical current during up-conversion ASE measurement to generate magneto-ASE phenomena. Excitation beam was focused on the sample perpendicularly by a lens. The light emission intensity was recorded once per second with 10 average times by a THORLABS PDA36A2 silicon photodetector, with several filters before the detector to eliminate excitation beam. The measurement was started with the electromagnet turned off. After 30 points were collected, the measurement was paused until the electromagnet was switched on and the constant current was kept to generate the magnetic field of 1.2 T. The electromagnet was then switched off to complete the measurement cycle.

    Results and discussion

    The scanning electron microscopy (SEM) image in Fig. 1(a) shows that the perovskite (MAPbBr3) film is formed with large cubic grains in the order of micrometers. The inset shows the image taken by optical microscopy. Figures S1 and Fig. 1(b) displays the optical absorption as well as PL and excitation spectrum. The film demonstrates a relatively strong absorption (about 50 %) from 400 nm to 540 nm. The absorption begins to drop sharply to about 30% at 540 nm, indicating an optical bandgap of 2.23 eV (557 nm). Moreover, the absorption shows an appreciable intensity below the bandgap decreasing slightly from about 20% to 10% with the wavelength changing from 550 nm to 1200 nm. At infrared region between 1200 nm to 1600 nm, the perovskite film still shows an acceptable absorption (about 10 %), corresponding to 1.04 eV to 0.78 eV (much smaller than the bandgap of 2.23 eV). Clearly, the perovskite (MAPbBr3) films with the large cubic grains of ~ micrometers are formed with broad gap states. Here, we suggest that the broad gap states are formed through structural deformation on large grains through fast crystallization. Theoretically, increasing the grain sizes can essentially lower the potential barriers to form structural deformation during crystallization. As shown in Fig. 1(c), at low pumping fluence (< 0.76 mJ/cm2 at 700 nm), a broad PL was observed with the FWHM of ~18.5 nm and the peak position of 546.6 nm. As the pumping fluence was increased from 0.76 mJ/cm2 to 2.27 mJ/cm2, a spectral narrowing phenomenon was observed with the FWHM decreased from 18.6 nm to 4.82 nm, resulting in a sharp peak at 550 nm. Simultaneously, the PL intensity is nonlinearly increasing with pumping fluence, presenting an efficient up-conversion ASE above the pumping threshold of 1.19 mJ/cm2 by directly exciting the gap states. Similar up-conversion ASE with spectral peak at 550 nm can also be observed when the perovskite (MAPbBr3) films were excited by different laser wavelengths from 480 nm to 900 nm (2.59 eV to 1.38 eV), shown as a spectral narrowing phenomenon with nonlinearly increasing intensity above threshold pumping fluences. However, the threshold pumping fluence increases with shifting sub-bandgap excitation to longer wavelength, as shown in Fig. 1(d) (Details for fluence dependent emission spectra can be found in Fig. S2). Clearly, directly exciting broad gap states presents a new approach to develop up-conversion ASE in hybrid perovskite (MAPbBr3) films. To note that the well-defined perovskite cubic grains are relatively good cavities, which can lead to lasing action with the FWHM below 1 nm37, 38. In our perovskite film, the poor quality of cubic shape fails to form cavities for lasing. Moreover, the concentrated microcrystals behave more like a polycrystal film, which shows ASE with FWHM of around 4 nm at high fluences. This light amplification indicates that our film is a good gain medium even under below-bandgap excitation.

    Morphological and spectral characterizations. (a) SEM image to show large grains with micrometer sizes. (b) Optical absorption spectrum (inset: band edge with PL). (c) Up-conversion ASE under 700 nm excitation wavelength (threshold pumping fluence: 1.19 mJ/cm2). Inset: spectral narrowing with emission intensity simultaneously increasing phenomena. (d) Threshold dependence on excitation wavelength. Inset: luminescence above (the upper left) and below (the bottom right) threshold.

    Figure 1.Morphological and spectral characterizations. (a) SEM image to show large grains with micrometer sizes. (b) Optical absorption spectrum (inset: band edge with PL). (c) Up-conversion ASE under 700 nm excitation wavelength (threshold pumping fluence: 1.19 mJ/cm2). Inset: spectral narrowing with emission intensity simultaneously increasing phenomena. (d) Threshold dependence on excitation wavelength. Inset: luminescence above (the upper left) and below (the bottom right) threshold.

    The multi-photon absorption process can be categorized into two types: one-step process and multi-step process. For the first type, the absorption process is realized on condition that the multiple photons are coherent and have wavefunctions overlap with the initial and final state of the material. Thus, switching the excitation source from coherent one to non-coherent one will cause largely reduced absorption cross section. This process is irrelevant to the gap states. In contrast, the multi-step process in the multi-photon absorption is influenced by the gap states. The electron in valance band is firstly excited into the gap when one below-bandgap photon is absorbed, followed by latter step(s) to excite the electron into conduction band. In this situation, the gap states play an important role in determining the absorption cross section. Specifically, the magnitude is irrelevant to the excitation source, i.e. coherent and non-coherent excitation sources have the same absorption cross section. In our experiment, we compared the ASE spectra at identical pump fluence excited by coherent and noncoherent light sources ( Fig. S3), which shows no difference. It verifies that the multi-photon absorption process is a multi-step process in our perovskite films with large perovskite grains. Therefore, the broad gap states revealed by absorption data suggest high multi-photon absorption cross section. Besides, we have compared the gap-state absorptions of small grains and the optimized large grains. It shows that the absorption of small crystals is much lower, indicating lower multi-photon absorption. Moreover, no ASE is observed even when the fluence ( Fig. S4) is very high.

    To further explore multi-photon absorption through broad gap states, the infrared excitation wavelength was largely tuned from 900 nm to 1200 nm and 1500 nm to detect up-conversion light emission. The power-law is effective to identify the types of radiative recombination only when we consider the PL intensities at initial time, i.e. PL0 in transient PL measurement39. In this case, the logarithmic slope of 1 or 2 corresponds to excitonic emission ( PL0n0) or bimolecular emission ( PL0n02) for down-conversion condition. Specifically, the integrated PL intensity (IPL) exciting with femtosecond pulse laser is proportional to the integration of recombination, i.e. IPL0+ndt for excitonic emission or IPL0+n2dt for bimolecular emission. When the carrier density increases to high value, the bimolecular recombination or Auger recombination will dominate, leading to the decrease of logarithmic slop40, 41. In Fig. S5, the logarithmic slope at excitation of 400 nm (one-photon absorption) is 1.31, indicating the dominance of high-order recombination(s) (bimolecular and/or Auger). When the excitation wavelength is 900 nm, the emission spectra for spontaneous emission are the same (Fig. 2(a)) while the logarithmic slope increases to 2.46 ((Fig. 2(d)). This value is close to the twice of the slope excited by 400 nm, implying that 900 nm excitation leads to two-photon absorption process in our perovskite film. When the excitation wavelength is 1200 nm or 1500 nm (Fig. 2(b, c, e, f)), the logarithmic slope tends to be closer to 3 or 4. We should note that, the absorption coefficient decreases significantly with the increasing excitation wavelength, resulting in very low carrier density. Although bimolecular recombination is the main radiative recombination in 3D perovskite film, the “excitonic-like” emission ( IPLn0) appears at very low carrier density n, which is attributed to a pseudo-first-order process (e.g. ninjected << nintrinsic)39. Therefore, the logarithmic slope of 3 and 4 correspond to the three-photon and four-photon process. This observation indicates that broad gaps states possess strong multi-photon absorption characteristics towards developing multi-photon up-conversion PL in hybrid halide perovskites. We should note that multi-photon up-conversion probability is directly related to the correlation between gap states during multi-photon absorption. Here, we can see that the large grains with the sizes in micrometers can demonstrate the high probabilities to enable multi-photon up-conversion PL in hybrid perovskite films. This indicates that the gap states possess spatially extended wavefunctions to increase multi-photon absorption probability in large grains.

    Multi-photon up-conversion PL and intensity dependence. (a, d) 2-photon process under 900 nm excitation wavelength. (b),(e) 3-photon process under 1200 nm excitation wavelength. (c, f) 4-photon process under 1500 nm excitation wavelength.

    Figure 2.Multi-photon up-conversion PL and intensity dependence. (a, d) 2-photon process under 900 nm excitation wavelength. (b),(e) 3-photon process under 1200 nm excitation wavelength. (c, f) 4-photon process under 1500 nm excitation wavelength.

    As up-conversion ASE occurred in the perovskite (MAPbBr3) films, the light-emitting states become strongly coupled with each other, which is supposed to provide large response to magnetic field. Therefore, we explore the magnetic field effects of light-emitting states responsible for up-conversion ASE. As reported, magnetic field effects can be observed when an external magnetic field is able to disturb the conversion between different states42-46. Here, Fig. 3(a) shows the magneto-ASE, where the ASE intensity is plotted with and without the magnetic field of 1.2 T under two-photon excitation (800 nm). Interestingly, applying a static magnetic field of 1.2 T can significantly increase the up-conversion ASE intensity by about 150% at the pumping fluence (> 1.91 mJ/cm2) above the threshold intensity, leading to a giant magneto-ASE in up-conversion regime. It should be pointed out that the value (150%) in ASE region is much higher than the commonly reported value (less than 1%) in spontaneous emission for hybrid perovskite32. This observation provides a strong evidence that spatially extended states are essentially formed when directly exciting gap states with the two-photon pumping fluence above ASE threshold.

    ASE measured with and without magnetic field in both up- and down-conversion regions. Magnetic field: 1.2 T. (a) Up-conversion ASE under 800 nm excitation wavelength. (b) Down-conversion ASE under 480 nm excitation wavelength. (c) Orbital order: orbitals are aligned through magnetic dipoles to form cooperative light-emitting states towards developing an ASE.

    Figure 3.ASE measured with and without magnetic field in both up- and down-conversion regions. Magnetic field: 1.2 T. (a) Up-conversion ASE under 800 nm excitation wavelength. (b) Down-conversion ASE under 480 nm excitation wavelength. (c) Orbital order: orbitals are aligned through magnetic dipoles to form cooperative light-emitting states towards developing an ASE.

    We should note that the spatially extended states are the states with delocalized wavefunctions, which are supposed to be realized through orbital order interaction. When an orbital order is established between spatially extended states, the light-emitting states can develop a cooperative interaction, providing the necessary condition to realize an ASE. Dynamically, this requires that the orbital order needs to be at least partially conserved during ASE. More importantly, when an external magnetic field suppresses the relaxation of orbital order to enhance the cooperative interaction between light-emitting states, ASE intensity can be largely increased, leading to magnetic field effects with the magnitude larger than 100%. Essentially, the orbital order leads to cooperative light-emitting states towards realizing up-conversion ASE. To verify the spatially extended states with cooperative order, magnetic field effects in down-conversion ASE were measured. Figure 3(b) shows the magneto-ASE in down-conversion condition under the pulse excitation of 480 nm with the pumping energy of > 1.27 mJ/cm 2. Obviously, applying the static magnetic field of 1.2 T can also significantly increase the down-conversion ASE intensity, giving rise to a giant magneto-ASE of 120% in down conversion regime when the 480 nm pumping fluence exceeding the ASE threshold intensity, while the down-conversion PL shows negligible response to the static magnetic field (< 1%) below ASE threshold. Clearly, the giant magneto-ASE provides the direct evidence that the orbital order is established between spatially extended states are formed, providing the necessary condition to generate cooperative interaction between light-emitting states towards developing an ASE, when the pumping intensity exceeds the threshold fluence in hybrid perovskites, as schematically shown inFig. 3(c). The orbital order refers to the alignment of orbital-magnetic dipoles in order to develop coherent light-emitting states towards ASE. The giant magneto-ASE implies that a magnetic field can further increase the alignment of orbital-magnetic dipoles, significantly increasing ASE. Therefore, the orbital order plays an important role to develop cooperative light-emitting states towards ASE in hybrid perovskites. For higher-quality crystals like perfect perovskite cuboids47, the recombination loss would be reduced, which in principle leads to lower lasing threshold. In this situation, charged defects would be reduced, which minimizes the screening effect on light emitting states toward increased delocalization. Therefore, the orbital order interaction between the excited states is supposed to be enhanced. As a result, higher magneto-ASE signal is expected.

    To further understand the characteristics of spatially extended states by directly exciting broad gap states, we investigate the spatial distribution of up-conversion ASE by monitoring the angle-resolved emission intensity. The angle-resolved experimental system was used to measure PL intensity at variable angles ranging from 0° to 90° relative to the film plane, with the excitation beam (700 nm) perpendicularly focused on the film plane, as depicted in Fig. 4(a). Figure 4(b) demonstrated that at pumping fluence (0.68 mJ/cm2) below the threshold intensity, the up-conversion PL (fluorescence) shows a very limited elliptical spatial distribution. Interestingly, when the pumping fluence is increased to 1.70 mJ/cm2 (above the threshold), the up-conversion ASE demonstrates a clear asymmetric spatial distribution with the emission intensity sharply decreased at 90° direction. According to the more elliptical spatial distribution of ASE intensity than spontaneous emission in Fig. 4(b), the transition dipoles responsible for ASE tend to be vertically aligned35. In order to realize collective emission, linearly polarized ASE emission with the direction parallel to the transition dipoles is suggested. Thus, the output should be linearly polarized perpendicularly to the film plane. This implies that the spatially extended states are orientated towards the direction perpendicular to film plane. Similar results can be observed when we change the excitation wavelength to 480 nm (down-conversion) and 800 nm (up-conversion) in Fig. S6, verifying that the collective emission is universal for ASE in our perovskite film. Essentially, this collective emission is further confirmed by measuring the polarization of ASE output as illustrated in Fig. 4(c). The result shown in Fig. 4(d) demonstrates that, when up-conversion ASE occurred, the output is linearly polarized with the direction perpendicular to the film plane, where the degree of polarization (DOP) reaches 11.1%. For other excitation wavelengths (480 nm and 800 nm in Fig. S7), polarized ASE emission can always be characterized. This result verifies that spatially extended states with cooperative order are indeed orientated, providing the necessary condition to develop coherent interaction towards developing an ASE.

    Angle and polarization dependences for ASE and PL. (a) Setup for angle dependence measurement. (b) Spatial distributions of ASE and PL outputs. (c) Setup for polarization measurement. (d) Polarizations of ASE and PL outputs.

    Figure 4.Angle and polarization dependences for ASE and PL. (a) Setup for angle dependence measurement. (b) Spatial distributions of ASE and PL outputs. (c) Setup for polarization measurement. (d) Polarizations of ASE and PL outputs.

    Conclusion

    In summary, up-conversion ASE is realized by directly exciting the broad gap states in hybrid perovskite (MAPbBr3) films prepared with large cubic grains in the order of micrometers. The 2-photon, 3-photon, and 4-photon PL indicates that the broad gap states possess strong multi-photon absorption characteristics, providing the necessary condition to generate up-conversion light emission. By directly exciting broad gap states with NIR pumping fluence exceeding threshold intensity, a spectral narrowing phenomenon in up-conversion light emission was observed, showing as an up-conversion ASE in perovskite (MAPbBr3) films prepared with large grains. Importantly, a static magnetic field of 1.2 T can significantly increase the ASE intensity by more than 150%, leading to giant magnetic field effects in up-conversion ASE regime. The observed giant magnetic field effects provide an evidence to show that the orbital order is established between spatially extended states in the hybrid perovskite (MAPbBr3) films. Essentially, the orbital order between spatially extended states provides the necessary condition to generate a cooperative interaction between light-emitting states towards realizing up-conversion ASE. This is verified by similar phenomenon in down-conversion ASE: giant magnetic field effects (120%) are also observed in down-conversion ASE. Clearly, with broad gap states, establishing the orbital order between spatially extended states presents a new mechanism to realize up-conversion ASE in hybrid halide perovskites. This creates new opportunities to use hybrid halide perovskites in infrared sensing, biological detection, and lasing technologies. Moreover, the giant magnetic field effects observed in ASE regime provides the promise to utilize hybrid halide perovskites in spintronics and biological magnetic probing.

    References

    Tangyao Shen, Jiajun Qin, Yujie Bai, Jia Zhang, Lei Shi, Xiaoyuan Hou, Jian Zi, Bin Hu. Giant magneto field effect in up-conversion amplified spontaneous emission via spatially extended states in organic-inorganic hybrid perovskites[J]. Opto-Electronic Advances, 2022, 5(2): 200051
    Download Citation