• Laser & Optoelectronics Progress
  • Vol. 60, Issue 18, 1811014 (2023)
Meng Liu, Teng Li, Xudong Liu, and Yiwen Sun*
Author Affiliations
  • School of Biomedical Engineering, Health Science Center, Shenzhen University, Shenzhen 518000, Guangdong , China
  • show less
    DOI: 10.3788/LOP231372 Cite this Article Set citation alerts
    Meng Liu, Teng Li, Xudong Liu, Yiwen Sun. Terahertz Time-Domain Spectral Hierarchical Detection Algorithm Based on Sparse Representation[J]. Laser & Optoelectronics Progress, 2023, 60(18): 1811014 Copy Citation Text show less
    Sparse representation method based on LASSO
    Fig. 1. Sparse representation method based on LASSO
    Schematic of some atoms in the dictionary. (a) Some atoms in non-dispersive dictionary A; (b) some atoms in dispersion dictionary D
    Fig. 2. Schematic of some atoms in the dictionary. (a) Some atoms in non-dispersive dictionary A; (b) some atoms in dispersion dictionary D
    Terahertz wave reflection model
    Fig. 3. Terahertz wave reflection model
    THz reference signal generated by DGMM for 3000 data points with a sampling period of 0.0333 ps
    Fig. 4. THz reference signal generated by DGMM for 3000 data points with a sampling period of 0.0333 ps
    L-curve diagrams and their values for regularization problems under different noise levels. (a) LASSO; (b) BPDN
    Fig. 5. L-curve diagrams and their values for regularization problems under different noise levels. (a) LASSO; (b) BPDN
    Reconstruction results of pulse response function for non overlapping echo signals using three methods. (a) Absence of noise; (b) RSN=40 dB; (c) RSN=20 dB; (d) RSN=10 dB
    Fig. 6. Reconstruction results of pulse response function for non overlapping echo signals using three methods. (a) Absence of noise; (b) RSN=40 dB; (c) RSN=20 dB; (d) RSN=10 dB
    Reconstruction results of pulse response function for overlapping echo signals using three methods. (a) Absence of noise; (b) RSN=40 dB; (c) RSN=20 dB; (d) RSN=10 dB
    Fig. 7. Reconstruction results of pulse response function for overlapping echo signals using three methods. (a) Absence of noise; (b) RSN=40 dB; (c) RSN=20 dB; (d) RSN=10 dB
    Variation of the minimum TOF with noise level distinguishable by different algorithms
    Fig. 8. Variation of the minimum TOF with noise level distinguishable by different algorithms
    Effect of dispersion on the reflected THz echo signal
    Fig. 9. Effect of dispersion on the reflected THz echo signal
    Comparison between the reconstruction results of three methods and the preset value. (a) Absence of noise; (b) RSN=40 dB; (c) RSN=20 dB; (d) RSN=10 dB
    Fig. 10. Comparison between the reconstruction results of three methods and the preset value. (a) Absence of noise; (b) RSN=40 dB; (c) RSN=20 dB; (d) RSN=10 dB
    THz-TDS system. (a) Physical image of the THz system and sample placement window; (b) switch for displacement table; (c) display interface of the software program for controlling data collection, display, and storage written through LabVIEW, the first part includes control buttons related to system initialization, start/stop operation, and data storage, the second part is about setting and displaying the spectral range, the third part is to control the displacement table for displacement or imaging scanning, the fourth part is the display of scanning results
    Fig. 11. THz-TDS system. (a) Physical image of the THz system and sample placement window; (b) switch for displacement table; (c) display interface of the software program for controlling data collection, display, and storage written through LabVIEW, the first part includes control buttons related to system initialization, start/stop operation, and data storage, the second part is about setting and displaying the spectral range, the third part is to control the displacement table for displacement or imaging scanning, the fourth part is the display of scanning results
    Experimental spectrograms and pulse response functions reconstructed using three algorithms. (a) THz time-domain spectra of PTFE films with different thicknesses; (b) PTFE200; (c) PTFE100; (d) PTFE50
    Fig. 12. Experimental spectrograms and pulse response functions reconstructed using three algorithms. (a) THz time-domain spectra of PTFE films with different thicknesses; (b) PTFE200; (c) PTFE100; (d) PTFE50
    Physical diagram of GFRP model and schematic of THz detection principle. (a) Physical image; (b) schematic of detection principle
    Fig. 13. Physical diagram of GFRP model and schematic of THz detection principle. (a) Physical image; (b) schematic of detection principle
    Experimental spectrograms and pulse response functions reconstructed using three algorithms. (a) THz time-domain spectrograms of three sets of models; (b) GFRP1; (c) GFRP2; (d) GFRP3
    Fig. 14. Experimental spectrograms and pulse response functions reconstructed using three algorithms. (a) THz time-domain spectrograms of three sets of models; (b) GFRP1; (c) GFRP2; (d) GFRP3
    Physical image of composite material model, schematic of imaging area, and diagram of terahertz detection principle. (a) Physical image; (b) schematic of the imaging area, triangulation dots represent random sampling points in defect‑free areas, round dots represent random sampling points in the defect area; (c) schematic of terahertz detection
    Fig. 15. Physical image of composite material model, schematic of imaging area, and diagram of terahertz detection principle. (a) Physical image; (b) schematic of the imaging area, triangulation dots represent random sampling points in defect‑free areas, round dots represent random sampling points in the defect area; (c) schematic of terahertz detection
    Original data graph and B-scan imaging graph of the model before and after processing for two groups of sampling points. (a) Terahertz time-domain spectrogram before processing; (b) terahertz time-domain spectrogram after processing; (c) B-scan imaging image before processing; (d) B-scan imaging image after processing
    Fig. 16. Original data graph and B-scan imaging graph of the model before and after processing for two groups of sampling points. (a) Terahertz time-domain spectrogram before processing; (b) terahertz time-domain spectrogram after processing; (c) B-scan imaging image before processing; (d) B-scan imaging image after processing
    Imaging pseudo color images of GFRP samples with mixed defects before and after processing. (a) Original imaging result; (b) imaging result without amplitude correction; (c) terahertz time-domain spectrogram before and after correcting the amplitude of sampling points in the defect area; (d) imaging result after amplitude correction
    Fig. 17. Imaging pseudo color images of GFRP samples with mixed defects before and after processing. (a) Original imaging result; (b) imaging result without amplitude correction; (c) terahertz time-domain spectrogram before and after correcting the amplitude of sampling points in the defect area; (d) imaging result after amplitude correction
    Signalβ1t1α1β2t2α2
    Echo11.510.450.2-0.5100.7
    Echo20.913.70.3-0.37513.10.9
    Echo30.615.550.5-0.2514.91.1
    Echo40.318.20.8-0.12517.21.4
    Table 1. DGMM preset values for different echoes in THz signals
    MethodPTFE200PTFE100PTFE50
    t1t2Δtt1t2Δtt1t2Δt
    FWDD62.533364.36671.833361.866762.66670.861.561.96670.4667
    BPDN62.533364.36671.833361.866762.66670.861.561.90.4
    LASSO62.533364.36671.833361.866762.66670.861.561.93330.4333
    Table 2. Localization of TOF of PTFE films with different thicknesses by three algorithms
    MethodPTFE200ErrorPTFE100ErrorPTFE50Error
    Actual value20010050
    FWDD208.44.2%94.85.2%53.16.2%
    BPDN208.44.2%94.85.2%45.59.0%
    LASSO208.44.2%94.85.2%49.31.4%
    Table 3. Actual thickness of three sets of PTFE films and detected thicknesses obtained by different algorithms respectively
    MethodGFRP1GFRP2GFRP3
    t1t2Δtt1t2Δtt1t2Δt
    FWDD74.533377.12.566774.733376.23331.574.366775.66671.3
    BPDN74.866776.71.833374.975.91.074.675.20.6
    LASSO74.766776.61.833374.966775.86670.974.733375.20.4667
    Table 4. Localization of TOF of PTFE thin film in detection layer by three algorithms
    MethodGFRP1ErrorGFRP2ErrorGFRP3Error
    Actual value20010050
    FWDD291.845.9%170.570.5%147.8195.6%
    BPDN208.44.2%113.713.7%68.260.4%
    LASSO208.44.2%102.32.3%53.16.2%
    Table 5. Actual thickness of three sets of GFRP models and detected thicknesses obtained by different algorithms respectively
    ParameterFig.16(a)Fig.16(b)Fig.16(d)
    Cw0.10210.67560.8985
    Table 6. Weber contrast of images
    Meng Liu, Teng Li, Xudong Liu, Yiwen Sun. Terahertz Time-Domain Spectral Hierarchical Detection Algorithm Based on Sparse Representation[J]. Laser & Optoelectronics Progress, 2023, 60(18): 1811014
    Download Citation