• Matter and Radiation at Extremes
  • Vol. 4, Issue 6, 064402 (2019)
E. D. Filippov1、a), I. Yu. Skobelev1、2, G. Revet3, S. N. Chen4, B. Khiar5、6, A. Ciardi5, D. Khaghani7, D. P. Higginson3、8, S. A. Pikuz1、2, and J. Fuchs3
Author Affiliations
  • 1Joint Institute for High Temperatures, RAS, 125412 Moscow, Russia
  • 2National Research Nuclear University, “MEPHI,” 115409 Moscow, Russia
  • 3LULI-CNRS, École Polytechnique, CEA: Université Paris-Saclay, UPMC Univ Paris 06: Sorbonne Université, F-91128 Palaiseau Cedex, France
  • 4ELI-NP, “Horia Hulubei” National Institute for Physics and Nuclear Engineering, 30 Reactorului Street, RO-077125 Bucharest-Magurele, Romania
  • 5Sorbonne Université, Observatoire de Paris, Université PSL, CNRS, LERMA, F-75005 Paris, France
  • 6Flash Center for Computational Science, University of Chicago, 5640 S. Ellis Avenue, Chicago, Illinois 60637, USA
  • 7University of Bordeaux, CEA, CNRS, Centre Lasers Intenses et Applications, UMR 5107, 33405 Talence Cedex, France
  • 8Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, Livermore, California 94551, USA
  • show less
    DOI: 10.1063/1.5124350 Cite this Article
    E. D. Filippov, I. Yu. Skobelev, G. Revet, S. N. Chen, B. Khiar, A. Ciardi, D. Khaghani, D. P. Higginson, S. A. Pikuz, J. Fuchs. X-ray spectroscopy evidence for plasma shell formation in experiments modeling accretion columns in young stars[J]. Matter and Radiation at Extremes, 2019, 4(6): 064402 Copy Citation Text show less
    Scheme (top view) of the creation of a collimated plasma stream in the laboratory (on the left) that is used to simulate the formation of an accretion column (on the right). Here, the main target is irradiated by a pulsed laser (0.6 ns/1054 nm/40 J), and then, the created plasma jet hits the solid obstacle that is used to generate accretion shocks. A magnetic field, generated by a Helmholtz coil,6 is applied uniformly everywhere to collimate the plasma flow.4,6 The targets could be shifted relative to the central transverse observation hole managed in the middle of the coil system in order to observe all the expansion dynamics of the jet.4,6 Optical and x-ray measurements (the Focusing Spectrometer with Spectral Resolution, or FSSR) are provided in the transverse direction using the observation hole. The FSSR provides spatial resolution along the whole plasma expansion axis, as well as spectral resolution in the 13–16 Å range.
    Fig. 1. Scheme (top view) of the creation of a collimated plasma stream in the laboratory (on the left) that is used to simulate the formation of an accretion column (on the right). Here, the main target is irradiated by a pulsed laser (0.6 ns/1054 nm/40 J), and then, the created plasma jet hits the solid obstacle that is used to generate accretion shocks. A magnetic field, generated by a Helmholtz coil,6 is applied uniformly everywhere to collimate the plasma flow.4,6 The targets could be shifted relative to the central transverse observation hole managed in the middle of the coil system in order to observe all the expansion dynamics of the jet.4,6 Optical and x-ray measurements (the Focusing Spectrometer with Spectral Resolution, or FSSR) are provided in the transverse direction using the observation hole. The FSSR provides spatial resolution along the whole plasma expansion axis, as well as spectral resolution in the 13–16 Å range.
    Top images: measured raw data close to the main and obstacle targets; the horizontal axis is the spectral, while the vertical axis is the one along which the main plasma expansion occurs. Also shown are the spectra of fluorine lines at different distances from the laser-irradiated surface of the main target, using the FSSR spectrometer. The observed spectral components that can be used for simulating the plasma parameters are the He-series (starting with the transition 3p-1s, as highlighted in the blue box) and the Lyα line of fluorine, with its dielectronic satellites (highlighted in the pink box).
    Fig. 2. Top images: measured raw data close to the main and obstacle targets; the horizontal axis is the spectral, while the vertical axis is the one along which the main plasma expansion occurs. Also shown are the spectra of fluorine lines at different distances from the laser-irradiated surface of the main target, using the FSSR spectrometer. The observed spectral components that can be used for simulating the plasma parameters are the He-series (starting with the transition 3p-1s, as highlighted in the blue box) and the Lyα line of fluorine, with its dielectronic satellites (highlighted in the pink box).
    (a) Simulation of the intensity ratio for the lines Heβ and Heγ using our recombination model, for different values of plasma density and temperature, compared with the experimental value of the same ratio recorded for the plasma jet stemming from the main target, i.e., the part of the plasma recorded at Z = 1 mm from a laser-irradiated target. Notably there can be, for a given plasma electron temperature, two sets of solutions: one at low density (18 cm−3) and one at high density. The solutions at low density are discarded since they are not consistent with either the density retrieved from the optical interferometric measurement, or with the hydrodynamic simulations.4,6 (b) Solution curves in a Te/Ne map for experimentally observed values of Heγ/Heβ = 0.78, Heδ/Heβ = 0.44, and Heε/Heβ = 0.16 (i.e., corresponding to the same plasma conditions at d = 1 mm from the main target), as obtained through similar calculations as those shown in (a). One can observe that using these three ratios allows a narrowing of the retrieved plasma parameters to a single solution in electron density and temperature. Here, this solution corresponds to ∼ Te = 50 eV and Ne = 6.5 × 1018 cm−3. (c) and (d) Applying the same procedure at all points in the plasma along its expansion, spatial profiles of electron temperature (Te) and density (Ne) can thus be retrieved for the case of free propagation (no obstacle and magnetic field, blue dots), for the case of jet expansion within the poloidal magnetic field of 20 T strength, with the magnetic field lines parallel to the plasma expansion (black squares), and finally, for the case of the impact on the obstacle surface, still magnetized using a 20 T magnetic field (green squares). Additionally, we give here the MHD simulation values for the electron density (green crosses), performed by the GORGON code20 for the core plasma component (see below). For the shell plasma, GORGON gives Ne = 1–5 × 1018 cm−3 near the obstacle.
    Fig. 3. (a) Simulation of the intensity ratio for the lines Heβ and Heγ using our recombination model, for different values of plasma density and temperature, compared with the experimental value of the same ratio recorded for the plasma jet stemming from the main target, i.e., the part of the plasma recorded at Z = 1 mm from a laser-irradiated target. Notably there can be, for a given plasma electron temperature, two sets of solutions: one at low density (<1018 cm−3) and one at high density. The solutions at low density are discarded since they are not consistent with either the density retrieved from the optical interferometric measurement, or with the hydrodynamic simulations.4,6 (b) Solution curves in a Te/Ne map for experimentally observed values of Heγ/Heβ = 0.78, Heδ/Heβ = 0.44, and Heε/Heβ = 0.16 (i.e., corresponding to the same plasma conditions at d = 1 mm from the main target), as obtained through similar calculations as those shown in (a). One can observe that using these three ratios allows a narrowing of the retrieved plasma parameters to a single solution in electron density and temperature. Here, this solution corresponds to ∼ Te = 50 eV and Ne = 6.5 × 1018 cm−3. (c) and (d) Applying the same procedure at all points in the plasma along its expansion, spatial profiles of electron temperature (Te) and density (Ne) can thus be retrieved for the case of free propagation (no obstacle and magnetic field, blue dots), for the case of jet expansion within the poloidal magnetic field of 20 T strength, with the magnetic field lines parallel to the plasma expansion (black squares), and finally, for the case of the impact on the obstacle surface, still magnetized using a 20 T magnetic field (green squares). Additionally, we give here the MHD simulation values for the electron density (green crosses), performed by the GORGON code20 for the core plasma component (see below). For the shell plasma, GORGON gives Ne = 1–5 × 1018 cm−3 near the obstacle.
    Ratio of the spectral intensities of the Heγ/Heβ lines for fluorine vs plasma size in the radiative-collisional code FLYCHK at 100 eV and three different electron densities (1018, 5 × 1018, 1019 cm−3, respectively) for optically thin and optically thick plasmas. Overlaid is the experimentally measured (using optical interferometry) range of plasma size for the considered ratios.
    Fig. 4. Ratio of the spectral intensities of the Heγ/Heβ lines for fluorine vs plasma size in the radiative-collisional code FLYCHK at 100 eV and three different electron densities (1018, 5 × 1018, 1019 cm−3, respectively) for optically thin and optically thick plasmas. Overlaid is the experimentally measured (using optical interferometry) range of plasma size for the considered ratios.
    (a) Simulation (red lines) of the experimental spectrum (black curve) using a quasi-stationary recombining model with parameters Te = 50 eV and Ne = 2 × 1019 cm−3. (b) Simulation (blue lines) of the experimental spectrum (black curve) using a collisional-radiative, one-temperature model in the FLYCHK code. Note that in the model, the intensities of He-like transitions are clearly underestimated compared with what the measurements show. The experimental spectrum is recorded at the surface of the obstacle and corresponds to the configuration in which the setup is magnetized at 20 T. Please note that the spectral lines in the simulation are specially shifted in wavelength for a more convenient comparison with the experimental data.
    Fig. 5. (a) Simulation (red lines) of the experimental spectrum (black curve) using a quasi-stationary recombining model with parameters Te = 50 eV and Ne = 2 × 1019 cm−3. (b) Simulation (blue lines) of the experimental spectrum (black curve) using a collisional-radiative, one-temperature model in the FLYCHK code. Note that in the model, the intensities of He-like transitions are clearly underestimated compared with what the measurements show. The experimental spectrum is recorded at the surface of the obstacle and corresponds to the configuration in which the setup is magnetized at 20 T. Please note that the spectral lines in the simulation are specially shifted in wavelength for a more convenient comparison with the experimental data.
    Simulation of the experimental Lyα-to-satellites ratio for multicharged ions of fluorine as a function of electron plasma temperature. Note that the sensitivity to the density is quite low in the range of electron densities 1017–1020 cm−3. The dielectronic satellites are located in the spectral range 15.159–15.291 Å, of which the most intense (right one inset) is F VII (2p2) 1D2 − (1s2p) 1P1. For the simulation of the Lyα/satellites ratio, the averaged profile of all three satellites was used.
    Fig. 6. Simulation of the experimental Lyα-to-satellites ratio for multicharged ions of fluorine as a function of electron plasma temperature. Note that the sensitivity to the density is quite low in the range of electron densities 1017–1020 cm−3. The dielectronic satellites are located in the spectral range 15.159–15.291 Å, of which the most intense (right one inset) is F VII (2p2) 1D2 − (1s2p) 1P1. For the simulation of the Lyα/satellites ratio, the averaged profile of all three satellites was used.
    Color map of electron temperature, derived by computer simulation using the GORGON code. This corresponds to the plasma near the obstacle surface (located at Z = 0), as recorded 12 ns after the incoming jet impact and for a magnetic field of 20 T. Overlaid is the comparison with x-ray data derived by the FSSR spectrometer (blue curve), following the assumption that the hotter plasma is the one in the shell. Note that the right axis pertains only to the blue curve.
    Fig. 7. Color map of electron temperature, derived by computer simulation using the GORGON code. This corresponds to the plasma near the obstacle surface (located at Z = 0), as recorded 12 ns after the incoming jet impact and for a magnetic field of 20 T. Overlaid is the comparison with x-ray data derived by the FSSR spectrometer (blue curve), following the assumption that the hotter plasma is the one in the shell. Note that the right axis pertains only to the blue curve.
    Simulation of the emissivity of the Lyα line for a hot plasma component for a wide range of ion density (in units of cm−3) and temperature, as calculated using the FLYCHK code. The electron density is calculated each time for a given ion density and a given temperature using kinetic equations.
    Fig. 8. Simulation of the emissivity of the Lyα line for a hot plasma component for a wide range of ion density (in units of cm−3) and temperature, as calculated using the FLYCHK code. The electron density is calculated each time for a given ion density and a given temperature using kinetic equations.
    B field (T)Tcore (eV)Ncore (cm−3)Tshell (eV)Nshell (cm−3)
    20502.3 × 1019320–6003.8–4.9 × 1018
    6403.3 × 1018320–6003.7–4.6 × 1017
    Table 1. X-ray spectroscopy-retrieved parameters of the two plasma components that could be identified in the experiment, simulating accretion phenomena of young stars for strengths 20 T and 6 T of the externally applied magnetic field. Here Tcore and Tshell correspond to electron temperature, and Ncore and Nshell to electron density, for both core and shell plasmas.
    E. D. Filippov, I. Yu. Skobelev, G. Revet, S. N. Chen, B. Khiar, A. Ciardi, D. Khaghani, D. P. Higginson, S. A. Pikuz, J. Fuchs. X-ray spectroscopy evidence for plasma shell formation in experiments modeling accretion columns in young stars[J]. Matter and Radiation at Extremes, 2019, 4(6): 064402
    Download Citation