• Journal of Infrared and Millimeter Waves
  • Vol. 41, Issue 6, 958 (2022)
Kun ZHOU1、2, Lin-An HE1、2, Yi LI1、2, Yu-Wen HE1、2, Wei-Chuan DU1、2、*, Sheng-Zhe LIU1、2, Liang ZHANG1、2, Yao HU1、2, Liang SONG1、2, Song-Xin GAO1、2, and Chun TANG1、2
Author Affiliations
  • 1Institute of Applied Electronics,CAEP,Mianyang 621900,China
  • 2Key Laboratory of Science and Technology on High Energy Lasers,CAEP,Mianyang 621900,China
  • show less
    DOI: 10.11972/j.issn.1001-9014.2022.06.003 Cite this Article
    Kun ZHOU, Lin-An HE, Yi LI, Yu-Wen HE, Wei-Chuan DU, Sheng-Zhe LIU, Liang ZHANG, Yao HU, Liang SONG, Song-Xin GAO, Chun TANG. Design considerations to increase the power-efficiency of a supper-large-optical-cavity waveguide structure diode laser[J]. Journal of Infrared and Millimeter Waves, 2022, 41(6): 958 Copy Citation Text show less

    Abstract

    The considerations in the epitaxial and longitudinal design of a supper-large-optical-cavity structure diode laser in the 976-nm band are numerically studied and presented here. Mode control layers were designed underneath and up the quantum well layer to suppress the lasing of high-order transverse modes. The electron leakage was suppressed by a band energy engineering, where the electron barrier increases from the p-waveguide layer to the p-cladding layer. The optimized structure has an internal loss of 0.66 cm-1, an internal quantum efficiency of 0.954, and a full width at half maximum vertical far-field angle of 17.4°. For the resonant cavity design, a liner current profile along the cavity was proposed to reduce the longitudinal spatial hole burning effect, where a power penalty of 1.0 W at 20 A is suppressed. The 4-mm-long and 100 μm wide broad-area single emitter with the supper-large-optical-cavity epitaxial structure was designed to have a high power-efficiency of about 71% at an output power of 21 W under continuous current injection at 25°C.

    Introduction

    High-power broad-area(BA)diode lasers have found a wide range of industrial,medical,scientific,space and military applications 1. In the 976-nm region,much attention has been attracted as pump sources for erbium-fiber amplifiers,optical data storage and displays 2-4. A supper-large-optical-cavity(SLOC)waveguide structure 5 has the benefit of lower power density on the facet 6,lower vertical far-field angle,and lower internal loss,thus high-power,high-efficiency and high reliability diode lasers. Furthermore,the lateral beam quality can be greatly improved due to the low differential modal gain of the SLOC structure 7.

    However,the number of higher-order modes increases with the vertical waveguide thickness. Higher-order transverse modes in a SLOC can deteriorate the far-field characteristics 8 and reduce the power efficiency,since the lasing of higher-order modes will introduce a higher internal optical loss. Many reports focused on the design of high-power diode lasers based on the large-optical-cavity(LOC)structure 9-12,and some reports discussed the suppression of higher-order modes 12. However,it is difficult to suppress the lasing of higher-order modes in a SLOC by changing the position of the quantum well(QW)or by the modal loss discrimination13.

    Furthermore,when a thick waveguide is adapted,electrons may accumulate around the p-waveguide,decreasing the injection efficiency of the carriers,which is the main cause of a lower electro-optical efficiency in a SLOC structure device 10-11. B.S.Ryvkin10 found that the broadening of the waveguide leads to a drastic reduction in the internal quantum efficiency due to the increased carrier density in the p-waveguide. Efforts were taken to overcome the decreasing of internal efficiency in the SLOC structure. Pietrzak et al. 14 reported an 8.6 μm thick SLOC with the vertical far-field of 15° and internal loss of 0.68 cm-1 with an injection efficiency of 0.70. Hasler et al. 15 obtained an injection efficiency of 0.91 and internal loss of 0.56 cm-1 using a 2.8 μm SLOC,but the vertical divergence is 50.8°. Andre. M 16-17 obtained an internal efficiency of 0.99 and internal losses of 0.8 cm-1 with a vertical far-field angle of 14.4° at full width at half maximum(FWHM).

    The output power is also limited by mechanisms such as longitudinal spatial hole burning(LSHB)18,which has been experimentally proved through the non-pinning of the carriers and spontaneous emission above lasing threshold in both GaAs-based19-20 and InP-based21 diode lasers. Narrow-stripe InP lasers showed around 25% improvement of rollover power using flared designs attributed to reduction of the LSHB effect 21. There have been theoretical studies 22 showing the effect of LSHB on the output power in GaAs-based laser diodes. Reducing the cavity length can suppress the LSHB effect but the increase of thermal resistance degrades the output power at high injected currents. R. B. Swertfeger23 recently found that higher current densities(and hence higher local recombination rates and higher losses)arise near the front facet due to spatial hole burning and that the non-uniformity is strongly affected by laser geometry,which is more severe for longer resonators and less severe for higher front facet reflectivity. Abdullah D. 24 reported an unfolded cavity,where the reflectivity of the rear and front facets were set equivalent with R=10%,to decrease the LSHB effect. It was reported that the unfolded cavity decreases the LSHB penalty by 10 times. However,the coupling or shaping of the laser beam might be complicated since the unfolded cavity has two equivalent output facets.

    The goal of this paper is to design a SLOC structure diode laser with low vertical divergence angle and high power-efficiency. The refractive index,band energy,and thickness of the epitaxial layers were carefully optimized to effectively suppress the lasing of higher-order modes and carrier leakage. Taking into account the LSHB effect,the carrier density,gain profile and power along the cavity were calculated and analyzed based on the diode laser rate equations. The 4-mm-long and 100 μm wide broad-area single emitter with the SLOC waveguide structure was designed to obtain a high power-efficiency of about 71% at an output power of 21 W.

    1 Calculation method

    For the vertical waveguide simulation,the band,carrier concentration,gain,index profile,mode intensity,confinement factor,mode power,voltage,external efficiency,and far-field patterns were calculated. The 2D laser diode model was built with infinite lateral boundary condition. The cross sections due to the absorption by free electrons and holes in the materials were set to αn=4×1017 cm2 and αp=12×1017 cm2,respectively 5. The calculation of the LSHB effect was based on the carrier and photon rate equations with the basic material and device parameters obtained from the results. The cavity length and emitter width were set to 4 mm and 100 μm in all the calculations. In the vertical waveguide model,the calculations were done under fixed lattice temperatures,while in the longitudinal calculations thermal heating effect was considered with a thermal resistance of 2.0 K/W,which is a typical value with p-down package on submount5.

    2 Vertical structure design

    2.1 Reference structure

    The vertical structure starts from a reference structure as shown in Table 1 The total wavegueide thickness is 3 500 nm with asymmetric n-type and p-type cladding layers. The single QW is set at the vertical position of around 4 000 nm with a p-waveguide thickness of 1 500 nm,where the confinement factor of mode0 is higher than all the higher-order modes,to ensure single transverse mode lasing 25. The confinement factors of mode0,mode1 and mode2 are 0.43%,0.10% and 0.08%,respectively. However,the relative thick p-waveguide leads to strong electron leakage,with a maximum concentration of about 4×1017 cm-3 as Fig. 1(b)shows. It is obvious that the leakage will decrease the carrier injection efficiency and increase the optical loss due to free carrier absorption. The leakage can be suppressed by increasing the p-type doping level,as shown in Fig. 1(b). A p-type doping concentration of 4×1017 cm-3 reduces the maximum electron concentration to about 1×1016 cm-3. However,high-level p-type doping in the waveguide introduces large optical loss which degrades the power efficiency as the data decipited in Fig. 2.

    LayerMaterialThickness/nmDoping
    p++-contactGaAs200C:2E19
    p-claddingAl0.6Ga0.4As400C:2E18
    p-waveguideAl0.15Ga0.85As1 500C:1E17
    QWIn0.2Ga0.8As8.6undoped
    n-waveguideAl0.15Ga0.85As1 600undoped
    n-waveguideAl0.15Ga0.85As400Si:5E17
    n-claddingAl0.25Ga0.75As1 500Si:2E18 graded to 5E17
    n-bufferGaAs500Si:2E18

    Table 1. Reference structure

    Transverse modes (a) and electron leakage (b) in the reference structure

    Figure 1.Transverse modes (a) and electron leakage (b) in the reference structure

    Power efficiency of the reference structure with different p-waveguide doping

    Figure 2.Power efficiency of the reference structure with different p-waveguide doping

    2.2 Mode control

    A decreased thickness of the p-waveguide can suppress the carrier leakage but high-order mode will lase. Mode control layers were designed underneath and up the QW layer to maintain a fundamental mode with thinner p-waveguide 26. As shown in Fig. 3,50 nm Al0.08Ga0.92As layers were designed as the mode control layers,with which the thickness of the p-waveguide can be reduced to about 900 nm. The confinement factors of mode 0,mode1 and mode2 are 0.69%,0.22% and 0.08%,respectively. However,high-order modes can lase if the p-waveguide thickness was further reduced according to the calculations.

    Transverse modes in the SLOC with mode control layers

    Figure 3.Transverse modes in the SLOC with mode control layers

    2.3 Suppression of carrier leakage by grading waveguide

    The carrier leakage can be further suppressed by a grading p-waveguide which increases the potential energy of the electrons,as the structure shown in Table 2. As plotted in Fig. 4(a),the Al content grades from 0.15 to 0.6 in the p-waveguide within a thickness of 600 nm. Single transverse mode lasing is achieved,where the confinement factors of mode0,mode1 and mode2 are 0.52%,0.39% and 0.28%,respectively. The electron concentration in the grading and without grading p-waveguide structure were compared and plotted in Fig. 4(b). The electron concentration was reduced to 5×1015 cm-3 at 20 A,about two orders lower compared to 4×1017 cm-3 in the reference structure.

    LayerMaterialThickness/nmDoping
    p++-contactGaAs200C:2E19
    p-claddingAl0.6Ga0.4As200C:2E18
    p-waveguide

    Al0.15Ga0.85As graded to

    Al0.6Ga0.4As

    600C:2E17graded to 2E18
    p-waveguideAl0.15Ga0.85As300C:2E17
    mode controlAl0.08Ga0.92As50Undoped
    QWIn0.2Ga0.8As8.6Undoped
    mode controlAl0.08Ga0.92As50Undoped
    n-waveguideAl0.15Ga0.85As1 600Undoped
    n-waveguideAl0.15Ga0.85As1 000Si:5E17
    n-claddingAl0.25Ga0.75As1 500Si:2E18 graded to 5E17
    n-bufferGaAs500Si:2E18

    Table 2. Grading structure

    (a) Transverse modes in the SLOC with grading p- waveguide, (b) electron concentration comparision with and without grading-waveguide

    Figure 4.(a) Transverse modes in the SLOC with grading p- waveguide, (b) electron concentration comparision with and without grading-waveguide

    The suppression of electron leakage in the p-waveguide improves the slope efficiency,especially in the current range of above 4 A,as shown in Fig. 5(a). The slope efficiency decreases from 1.095 W/A around 1 A to 0.886 W/A around 20 A in the reference structure,while it is 1.100 W/A to 1.039 W/A in the grading structure. From the slope efficiency,an internal quantum efficiency of 0.954 at 1 A and 0.917 at 20 A can be deduced. Since the mode overlap with the p-doped layers is reduced in the grading structure,the doping level of the grading p-waveguide layer can be designed much higher. As shown in Table 2,a graded doping profile from 2×1017 cm-3 to 2×1018 cm-3 is used in the grading p-waveguide layer,which reduces the voltage by 0.142 V at 20 A compared to the reference structure as decipited in Fig. 5(b). The power efficiency is thus improved from 61% to 71.6% at 20 A as plotted in Fig. 6(a),due to the improvement of output power and the decrease of voltage. The vertical far-field pattern is plotted in Fig. 6(b). The full width at half maximum(FWHM)vertical far-field angle is about 17.4° for both structures.

    Slope efficiency (a) and voltage (b) comparison of the grading and reference structures

    Figure 5.Slope efficiency (a) and voltage (b) comparison of the grading and reference structures

    Power efficiency (a) and vertical far-field (b) of the grading and reference structures

    Figure 6.Power efficiency (a) and vertical far-field (b) of the grading and reference structures

    2.4 Characteristic temperature

    Typically,the junction temperature of the laser diode will increase with the injected current. The temperature dependence of threshold,Ith,and slope efficiency S,are calculated as a function of lattice temperature T,using the simple empirical expressions with

    IthT=IrefexpTT0,

    and

    ST=Srefexp-TT1,

    where T0=300 K,Iref and Sref is the threshold current and slope efficiency at 300 K,respectively. In the temperature range of 300 K to 360 K,the extracted T0 values are 174 K and 194 K for the reference and grading structure with relatively small difference. However,the extracted T1 values are 228 K and 483K for the reference and grading structure. The improved T1 value in the grading structure results from the suppression of carrier leakage.

    Calculated temperature dependence of slope efficiency and threshold comparison of the grading and reference structures,the slope efficiency values are extracted from the output power at 10 A to 20 A

    Figure 7.Calculated temperature dependence of slope efficiency and threshold comparison of the grading and reference structures,the slope efficiency values are extracted from the output power at 10 A to 20 A

    Table 3 summarized the main parameters of the reference and grading structures. The key point is that the increase of modal loss and the decrease of internal quantum efficiency were suppressed in the grading structure.

    ParametersReferenceGrading
    Modal loss at 1 A0.494 cm-10.554 cm-1
    Modal loss at 20 A0.846 cm-10.668 cm-1
    Internal efficiency at 1 A0.9460.954
    Internal efficiency at 20 A0.8040.917
    Confinement factor of QW0.432%0.517%
    Characteristic temperature T0174 K194 K
    Characteristic temperature T1228 K483 K
    Power at 20 A20.3 W21.42 W
    Voltage at 20 A1.642 V1.495 V
    Efficiency at 20 A~61%~71.6%

    Table 3. Parameters comparison of the reference and grading structures at 300 K

    3 Longitudinal design

    Rate equations for diode lasers describe the relation of the density of photons and carriers(electrons)with injection current and optical gain. General rate equations assume uniform longitudinal photon density,carrier density and optical gain. However,under the effect of LSHB,rate equations must be modified 27,with local carrier density Nz),local photon density Npz),and local gain gz)varying with longitudinal position z. The detailed calculation processes of the power,gain and carrier profile was referenced from Ting Hao 28,with the material and device parameters in Table 4.

    The output powers of the chips with and without the LSHB effect were compared in Fig. 8(a). The output power degraded with the LSHB effect with the increase of injected current. Figure 8(b)shows the power and gain profile in the chip at 20A. It is obvious that carriers accumulated on the high-reflection(HR)side because of lower optical power density. The accumulation of carriers leads to strong leakage and spontaneous emission resulting in a lower output laser power.

    Calculated power (a) and gain (b) distribution in the cavity with uniform current injection

    Figure 8.Calculated power (a) and gain (b) distribution in the cavity with uniform current injection

    Cavity length /μm4 000Internal quantum efficiency ηi0.954
    QW thickness /nm8.6Optical mode Г0.517%
    Emitter width /μm100Internal loss αi/(1/cm)0.668
    HR99%Refractive index3.44
    AR0.01%∼30%g0(1/cm)4 000
    Jtr/(A/cm270Thermal resistance Rth/(K/W)2.0
    Ntr/(1/cm31.0×1018T1/K483
    T0/K194Temperature/K300
    Spontaneous coefficient B /(cm6/s)1×10-9

    Auger coefficient

    C/(cm9/s)

    1×10-30

    Table 4. Material and device parameters for the modeling lasers

    To suppress the LSHB effect,a linear current profile was proposed,as shown in Fig. 9(a). The current density was linearly increased from the HR facet to the anti-reflection(AR)facet,while keeping the total injected current as the same with a uniform current density. A linear current profile can be realized by a tapered electrode contact along the cavity or a patterned ohmic contact 29. The corresponding power and gain distribution in the chips were plotted in Fig. 9(b). The gain was much lower at the HR side since the injection current density was low. The maximum modal gain reduced from 39 cm-1 to 16 cm-1 compared to the uniform current injection,since the maximum carrier density was reduced from 6.4×1018 cm-3 to 2×1018 cm-3,as shown in Fig. 10(a).

    Conception of linear current (a), and calculated power and gain distribution (b) in the cavity with linear current injection

    Figure 9.Conception of linear current (a), and calculated power and gain distribution (b) in the cavity with linear current injection

    Carrier density (a) and output power at 20 A (b) comparison of linear and uniform current injection

    Figure 10.Carrier density (a) and output power at 20 A (b) comparison of linear and uniform current injection

    The suppression of the LSHB effect improves the output power,as plotted in Fig. 10(b). The maximum output power increased by 1.0 W at 20 A when linear current profile was used. Concerning the thermal effect with a thermal resistance of 2.0 K/W,the 4-mm-long and 100 μm wide broad-area single emitter with the SLOC waveguide structure was designed to have a high power-efficiency of about 71% at an output power of 21 W under continuous current injection at 25°C,as shown in Fig. 11.

    Designed output power and efficiency of the 4-mm-long and 100 μm wide broad-area laser diode

    Figure 11.Designed output power and efficiency of the 4-mm-long and 100 μm wide broad-area laser diode

    4 Conclusions

    Numerical study of the epitaxial and longitudinal design of a SLOC structure diode laser is presented in this paper. Mode control layers were used to maintain a single transverse mode with reduced p-waveguide thickness. A graded p-waveguide layer can effectively suppress the leakage of electrons and reduce the voltage. The optimized SLOC structure has an internal loss of 0.66 cm-1,a confinement factor of 0.517%,an internal quantum efficiency of 0.954,a character temperature of T0=194 K and T1=483 K in temperature range of 300∼360 K,respectively,and a full width at half maximum vertical far-field angle of 17.4°. A liner current profile along the cavity can suppress the LSHB effect,which increases the output power by 1.0 W at 20 A concerning the thermal effect with a thermal resistance of 2.0 K/W. As a result,4-mm-long and 100 μm wide broad-area single emitter with the SLOC waveguide structure was designed to have a high power-efficiency of about 71% at an output power of 21 W under continuous current injection at 25 °C.

    References

    [1] R Diehl. High-power diode lasers. Fundamentals, technology, applications: With contributions by numerous experts. Topics in Applied Physics, 8, 69(2000).

    [2] D Jedrzejczyk, P Asbahr, M Pulka et al. High-power single-mode fiber coupling of a laterally tapered single-frequency diode laser. IEEE Photonics Technology Letters, 26, 845-847(2014).

    [3] F Feng, H Page, R V Penty et al. Free space optical wireless communications using directly modulated two-electrode high brightness tapered laser diode. Electronics Letters, 48, 281-283(2012).

    [4] O B Jensen, P M Petersen. Single-frequency blue light generation by single-pass sum-frequency generation in a coupled ring cavity tapered laser. Applied Physics Letters, 103, 141107(2013).

    [5] P Crump, G Blume, K Paschke et al. 20 W continuous wave reliable operation of 980nm broad-area single emitter diode lasers with an aperture of 96μm. High-Power Diode Laser Technology and Applications VII. SPIE, 7198, 315-323(2009).

    [6] M Wilkens, H Wenzel, J Fricke et al. High-efficiency broad-ridge waveguide lasers. IEEE Photonics Technology Letters, 30, 545-548(2018).

    [7] M Mikulla, P Chazan. High-brightness tapered semiconductor laser oscillators and amplifiers with low-modal gain epilayer-structures. IEEE Photonics Technology Letters, 10, 654-656(1998).

    [8] N Y Gordeev, A S Payusov, Y M Shernyakov et al. Transverse single-mode edge-emitting lasers based on coupled waveguides. Optics Letters, 40, 2150-2(2015).

    [9] D Botez. Design considerations and analytical approximations for high continuous-wave power, broad-waveguide diode lasers. Applied Physics Letters, 74, 3102-3104(1999).

    [10] B S Ryvkin, E A Avrutin. Effect of carrier loss through waveguide layer recombination on the internal quantum efficiency in large-optical-cavity laser diodes. Journal of Applied Physics, 97, 113106-113106(2005).

    [11] B Ryvkin, E Avrutin. Non-uniform carrier accumulation in optical confinement layer as ultimate power limitation in ultra-high-power broad-waveguide pulsed InGaAs/GaAs/AlGaAs laser diodes. Electronics Letters, 42, 1283-1284(2006).

    [12] N A Pikhtin, S O Slipchenko, Z N Sokolova et al. 16W continuous-wave output power from 100 m-aperture laser with quantum well asymmetric heterostructure. Electronics Letters, 40, 1413-1414(2004).

    [13] J M G Tijero, H Odriozola, L Borruel et al. Enhanced brightness of tapered laser diodes based on an asymmetric epitaxial design. IEEE Photonics Technology Letters, 19, 1640-1642(2007).

    [14] A Pietrzak, P Crump, H Wenzel et al. Combination of low-index quantum barrier and super large optical cavity designs for ultranarrow vertical far-fields from high-power broad-area lasers. IEEE Journal of Selected Topics in Quantum Electronics, 17, 1715-1722(2011).

    [15] K H Hasler, H Wenzel, P Crump et al. Comparative theoretical and experimental studies of two designs of high-power diode lasers. Semiconductor Science & Technology, 29, 45010-45015(2014).

    [16] Bugge , Frank , Erbert et al. DBR tapered diode laser with 12.7 W output power and nearly diffraction-limited, narrowband emission at 1030 nm. Applied physics, B. Lasers and optics, B122, 87.1(2016).

    [17] A Muller, C Zink, J Fricke et al. Efficient, high brightness 1030 nm dbr tapered diode lasers with optimized lateral layout. IEEE Journal of Selected Topics in Quantum Electronics, 23, 1-1(2017).

    [18] Z Chen, B Ling, J Bai et al. Performance limitation and mitigation of longitudinal spatial hole burning in high-power diode lasers. Proceedings of Spie the International Society for Optical Engineering, 8277, 245-252(2012).

    [19] A J Bennett, R D Clayton, J M Xu. Above-threshold longitudinal profiling of carrier nonpinning and spatial modulation in asymmetric cavity lasers. Journal of Applied Physics, 83, 3784-3788(1998).

    [20] T Hao, J Song, R Liptak et al. Experimental verification of longitudinal spatial hole burning in high-power diode lasers. SPIE, 9081, 117-125(2014).

    [21] A Guermache, V Voiriot, D Locatelli et al. Experimental demonstration of spatial hole burning reduction leading to 1480-nm pump lasers output power improvement. IEEE Photonics Technology Letters, 17, 2023-2025(2005).

    [22] H Wenzel. Basic aspects of high-power semiconductor laser simulation. IEEE Journal of Selected Topics in Quantum Electronics, 19, 1-13(2013).

    [23] R B Swertfeger, S K Patra, R J Deri et al. Longitudinal current crowding as power limit in high power 975 nm diode lasers, 1-2(2020).

    [24] A Demir, M Peters, R Duesterberg et al. 29.5W continuous wave output from 100 µm wide laser diode. SPIE, 9348, 129-134(2015).

    [25] K Zhou, W Du, Y Li et al. Suppression of higher-order modes in a large-optical-cavity waveguide structure for high-power high-efficiency 976-nm diode lasers. Superlattices and Microstructures, 129, 40-46(2019).

    [26] P Crump, A Pietrzak, F Bugge et al. 975 nm high power diode lasers with high efficiency and narrow vertical far field enabled by low index quantum barriers. Applied Physics Letters, 96, 719803(2010).

    [27] E A Avrutin, B S Ryvkin. Effect of spatial hole burning on output characteristics of high power edge emitting semiconductor lasers: A universal analytical estimate and numerical analysis. Journal of Applied Physics, 125, 023108.1-023108.8(2019).

    [28] T Hao, J Song, P O Leisher. Rate equation analysis of longitudinal spatial hole burning in high-power semiconductor lasers. SPIE, 9134, 155-161(2014).

    [29] L J Wang, C Z Tong, S L Shu et al. Loss tailoring of high-power broad-area diode lasers.. Optics letters, 44, 3562-3565(2019).

    Kun ZHOU, Lin-An HE, Yi LI, Yu-Wen HE, Wei-Chuan DU, Sheng-Zhe LIU, Liang ZHANG, Yao HU, Liang SONG, Song-Xin GAO, Chun TANG. Design considerations to increase the power-efficiency of a supper-large-optical-cavity waveguide structure diode laser[J]. Journal of Infrared and Millimeter Waves, 2022, 41(6): 958
    Download Citation