• Journal of Geographical Sciences
  • Vol. 30, Issue 5, 775 (2020)
Zhouying SONG1、2、3、* and Qiaoling ZHU1、2、3
Author Affiliations
  • 1Institute of Geographic Sciences and Natural Resources Research, CAS, Beijing 100101, China
  • 2Key Laboratory of Regional Sustainable Development Modeling of the Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100101, China
  • 3College of Resources and Environment, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, China
  • show less
    DOI: 10.1007/s11442-020-1755-2 Cite this Article
    Zhouying SONG, Qiaoling ZHU. Spatio-temporal pattern and driving forces of urbanization in China’s border areas[J]. Journal of Geographical Sciences, 2020, 30(5): 775 Copy Citation Text show less
    Study area (China’s border areas)
    Fig. 1. Study area (China’s border areas)
    Changes in average urbanization level by region, 2000-2015
    Fig. 2. Changes in average urbanization level by region, 2000-2015
    Spatial characteristics of urbanization in China’s border areas, 2000-2015
    Fig. 3. Spatial characteristics of urbanization in China’s border areas, 2000-2015
    Urbanization growth rate in China’s border areas, 2000-2015
    Fig. 4. Urbanization growth rate in China’s border areas, 2000-2015
    Spatial characteristics of development types for China’s border areas’ urbanization
    Fig. 5. Spatial characteristics of development types for China’s border areas’ urbanization
    Interaction detection results of urbanization drivers in China’s border areas
    Fig. 6. Interaction detection results of urbanization drivers in China’s border areas
    Interaction detection results of urbanization drivers in China’s border areas
    Fig. 7. Interaction detection results of urbanization drivers in China’s border areas
    IndicatorUnitsDescriptionData sourceWeight
    Natural forceAverage annual precipitationmmMeasures the livability of climatic conditions via the average annual precipitation of county-level unitsChina Meteorological Data Service Center (CMDC)0.25
    Average annual temperatureMeasures the livability of climatic conditions via the average annual temperature of county-level unitsChina Meteorological Data Service Center (CMDC)0.25
    Average altitudekmMeasures the topographic conditions in border areas via average elevation of county-level unitsGeospatial Data Cloud0.25
    Arable land areahaMeasures the scale of arable land in border areasChina Economic and Social Development Statistics Database0.25
    Administrative forceLocal fiscal expenditure10,000 RMBMeasures the administrative and regulatory capacity of local governmentsChina Statistical Yearbook (County-Level)0.3
    Public and private fixed-asset investment10,000 RMBMeasures the economic capacity of local governmentsChina Statistical Yearbook (County-Level)0.3
    Preferential policy index/Measures national policy support (at a scale of 0-5 based on the following five policy conditions) 1 = West China Development and Northeast Revitalization programs2 = Pilot for supporting reforms along borders and pilot for supporting reform of modern agriculture3 = Border economic cooperation zone, comprehensive free trade zone or “prosperity to border areas and their residents” pilots4 = Key experimental zones for development and opening up 5 = Cross-border economic cooperation zonesWebsites of Ministry of Commerce and National Development and Reform Commission0.4
    Market forceTotal retail sales of consumer goods10,000 RMBMeasures the size of domestic markets in border areasChina Statistical Yearbook (County-level)0.4
    Bilateral trade10,000 USDMeasures the level of trade development in border areasInternational Trade Centre databases0.2
    Bilateral economic integration/Measures the bilateral trade environment (with integration scores of 0-3)0 = The two countries have no trade agreement1 = Both countries have joined economic organizations or agreements, such as WTO, CAFTA, BRI, etc. 2 = Countries are in bilateral trade negotiations3 = Countries have signed a bilateral free trade agreementWebsites of Ministry of Commerce and National Development and Reform Commission0.2
    Market opportunities/Measures market size, market expectations, etc., of neighboring countries in border areas (expressed as per capita GDP of neighboring country/per capita GDP of border area)China Statistical Yearbook (County-level) & World Bank databases0.2
    Industrial forceIndustrial output10,000 RMBMeasures the level of industrializationChina Statistical Yearbook (County-level)0.4
    Tourism revenueMillion USDMeasures the level of development of tourismChina Statistical Yearbook0.3
    GRP100 million RMBMeasures overall industrial developmentChina Statistical Yearbook (County-level)0.3
    Transportation forceTransport route densitykm/km2Measures level of transportation access to China’s hinterland (the ratio of the length of transport routes to the administrative area, including road and rail routes)China Statistical Yearbook0.4
    Transport status/Determines whether a county is an important transportation node in China’s opening up driveWebsites of Ministry of Commerce and National Development and Reform Commission0.3
    Air transport development/Measures the level of aviation development (0-3 assigned based on airport construction)0 = No airport of category 3C or higher1 = has a 3C airport2 = has a 4C airport3 = has a 4D airportGeneral Aviation Resource Net of China0.3
    Social forceProportion of population made up of ethnic minorities/Measures social and cultural integration with neighboring countriesCensus0.4
    Education levelPeopleNumber of primary and secondary school students and ordinary middle school students per 10,000 peopleChina Statistical Yearbook (County-level)0.3
    Medical care levelBedsNumber of beds in medical institutions per 10,000 peopleChina Statistical Yearbook (County-level)0.3
    Table 1.

    Drivers of urban development in China’s border areas and their weights

    NaturalAdmin.MarketIndust.Transp.Social
    All border areas0.103***0.096***0.058***0.204***0.224***0.166***
    (0.000)(0.000)(0.000)(0.000)(0.000)(0.000)
    Northeast0.248***0.073***0.018*0.0140.133***0.069***
    (0.000)(0.000)(0.068)(0.135)(0.000)(0.000)
    North0.092***0.132***0.199***0.039**0.190***0.151***
    (0.000)(0.000)(0.000)(0.017)(0.000)(0.000)
    Northwest0.063***0.099***0.048***0.232***0.228***0.016*
    (0.000)(0.000)(0.000)(0.000)(0.000)(0.084)
    Tibet0.114***0.036**0.052***0.0170.0400.072***
    (0.000)(0.042)(0.007)(0.324)(0.256)(0.000)
    Southwest0.037***0.173***0.198***0.064***0.138***0.108***
    (0.000)(0.000)(0.000)(0.000)(0.000)(0.000)
    Table 2.

    Factor detection results of urbanization drivers in China’s border areas

    Zhouying SONG, Qiaoling ZHU. Spatio-temporal pattern and driving forces of urbanization in China’s border areas[J]. Journal of Geographical Sciences, 2020, 30(5): 775
    Download Citation