Research progress of absolute distance measurement methods based on tunable laser frequency sweeping interference

Luming Song; Fumin Zhang; Dong Sun; Hongyi Lin; Xiaohua Huang; Miao Yu; Qian Zhang

doi:10.3788/IRLA20210406

[1] R Daendliker, K Hug, J Politch, et al. High-accuracy distance measurements with multiple-wavelength interferometry. Optical Engineering, 34, 2407-2412(1995).

[2] A F Fox-Murphy, D F Howell, R B Nickerson, et al. Frequency scanned interferometry (FSI): The basis of a survey system for ATLAS using fast automated remote interferometry. Nucl Instr and Meth in Phys Res A, 383, 229-237(1996).

[3] K Hibino, Y Tani, Y Bitou, et al. Discontinuous surface measurement by wavelengthtuning interferometry with the excess fraction method correcting scanning nonlinearity. Applied Optics, 50, 962-969(2011).

[4] X L Dai, K Seta. High-accuracy absolute distance measurement by means of wavelength scanning heterodyne interferometry. Measurement Science and Technology, 9, 1031-1035(1998).

[5] L Rovati, U Minoni, F Docchio. Dispersive white light combined with a frequency-modulated continuous-wave interferometer for high-resolution absolute measurements of distance. Optics Letters, 22, 850-852(1997).

[6] A Jha, F J Azcona, S Royo. Frequency-modulated optical feedback interferometry for nanometric scale vibrometry. IEEE Photonics Technology Letters, 28, 1217-1220(2016).

[7] H Yoshino, J M Walls, R Smith. Interfacial surface roughness determination by coherence scanning interferometry using noise compensation. Applied Optics, 56, 4757-4765(2017).

[8] K Lau, R Hocken, L Haynes. Robot performance measurements using automatic laser tracking techniques. Robotics and Computer-Integrated Manufacturing, 2, 227-236(1985).

[9] H Kikuta, K Iwata, R Nagata. Distance measurement by the wavelength shift of laser diode light. Applied Optics, 25, 2976-2980(1986).

[10] G Shi, W Wang. Single laser complex method to improve the resolution of FMCW laser ranging. J Infrared Millim Waves, 35, 363-367(2016).

[11] C B Hou, J G Wang, J Yang, et al. Improved path imbalance measurement of a fiber-optic interferometer based on frequency scanning interferometry. Measurement Science and Technology, 28, 085007(2017).

[12] K Iiyama, S Matsui, T Kobayashi, et al. High-resolution FMCW reflectometry using a single-mode vertical-cavity surface-emitting laser. IEEE Photonics Technology Letters, 23, 703-705(2011).

[13] S H Ye, J G Zhu, Z L Zhang, et al. Status and development of large-scale coordinate measurement research. Acta Metrologica Sinica, 29, 1-6(2008).

[14] W T Estler, K L Edmundson, G N Peggs, et al. Large-scale metrology - An update. CIRP Annals, 51, 587-609(2002).

[15] K Zhang, T Lv, D Mo, et al. Double sideband frequency scanning interferometry for distance measurement in the outdoor environment. Optics Communications, 425, 176-179(2018).

[16] T Zhang, F Gao, H Muhamedsalih, et al. Improvement of the fringe analysis algorithm for wavelength scanning interferometry based on filter parameter optimization. Applied Optics, 57, 2227-2234(2018).

[17] X H Qu, G T Zhi, F M Zhang, et al. Improvement of resolution of frequency modulated continuous wave laser ranging system by signal splicing. Optics and Precision Engineering, 23, 40-47(2015).

[18] C R Tilford. Analytical procedure for determining lengths from fractional fringes. Applied Optics, 16, 1857-1860(1977).

[19] A Cabral, o J Rebordã. Accuracy of frequency-sweeping interferometry for absolute distance metrology. Optical Engineering, 46, 073602(2007).

[20] Y Bitou, K Seta. Gauge block measurement using a wavelength scanning interferometer. Japanese Journal of Applied Physics, 39, 6084-6088(2000).

[21] E D Moore, R R McLeod. Correction of sampling errors due to laser tuning rate fluctuations in swept-wavelength interferometry. Optics Express, 16, 13139-13149(2008).

[22] G Shi, F M Zhang, X H Qu, et al. High-resolution frequency-modulated continuous-wave laser ranging for precision distance metrology applications. Optical Engineering, 53, 122402(2014).

[23] G Shi, W Wang. Dual interferometry FMCW laser ranging for high precision absolute distance measurement system. Infrared and Laser Engineering, 45, 0806001(2016).

[24] N K Ji, F M Zhang, X H Qu, et al. Ranging technology for frequency modulated continuous wave laser based on phase difference frequency measurement. Chinese Journal of Lasers, 45, 1104002(2018).

[25] Z Liu, Z G Liu, Z W Deng, et al. Suppression of nonlinear frequency sweep in frequency sweeping interferometer based on order tracking technique. Acta Optica Sinica, 36, 140-148(2016).

[26] Z W Deng, Z G Liu, X Y Jia, et al. Dynamic cascade-model-based frequency-scanning interferometry for real-time and rapid absolute optical ranging. Optics Express, 27, 21929-21945(2019).

[27] W Deng, Z G Liu, Z W Deng, et al. Extraction of interference phase in frequencyscanning interferometry based on empirical mode decomposition and Hilbert transform. Applied Optics, 57, 2299-2305(2018).

[28] C Greiner, B Boggs, T Wang, et al. Laser frequency stabilization by means of optical self-heterodyne beat-frequency control. Optics Letters, 23, 1280-1282(1998).

[29] K Iiyama, L T Wang, K I Hayashi. Linearizing optical frequency-sweep of a laser diode for FMCW reflectometry. Journal of Lightwave Technology, 14, 173-178(1996).

[30] T J Ahn, D Y Kim. Analysis of nonlinear frequency sweep in high-speed tunable laser sources using a self-homodyne measurement and Hilbert transformation. Applied Optics, 46, 2394-2400(2007).

[31] P A Roos, R R Reibel, T Berg, et al. Ultrabroadband optical chirp linearization for precision metrology applications. Optics Letters, 34, 3692-3694(2009).

[32] S Kakuma, Y Katase. Resolution improvement in vertical-cavity-surface-emitting-laser diode interferometry based on linear least-squares estimation of phase gradients of phase-locked fringes. Optical Review, 17, 481-485(2010).

[33] S Kakuma. Frequency scanning interferometry with nanometer precision using a vertical-cavity surface-emitting laser diode under scanning speed control. Optical Review, 22, 869-874(2015).

[34] M Medhat, M Sobee, H M Hussein, et al. Distance measurement using frequency scanning interferometry with mode-hoped laser. Optics and Laser Technology, 80, 209-213(2016).

[35] Z W Deng, Z G Liu, B Li, et al. Precision improvement in frequency-scanning interferometry based on suppressing nonlinear optical frequency sweeping. Optical Review, 22, 724-730(2015).

[36] Y Zhu, Z G Liu, Wen Deng, et al. Input signal shaping based on harmonic frequency response function for suppressing nonlinear optical frequency in frequency-scanning interferometry. Review of Scientific Instruments, 89, 053109(2018).

[37] T J Ahn, J Y Lee, D Y Kim. Suppression of nonlinear frequency sweep in an optical frequency-domain reflectometer by use of Hilbert transformation. Applied Optics, 44, 7630-7634(2005).

[38] K Yüksel, M Wuilpart, P Mégret. Analysis and suppression of nonlinear frequency modulation in an optical frequency-domain reflectometer. Optics Express, 17, 5845-5851(2009).

[39] X S Meng, F M Zhang, X H Qu. High precision and fast method for absolute distance measurement based on resampling technique used in FM continuous wave laser ranging. Acta Physica Sinica, 64, 230601(2015).

[40] Y N Yao, F M Zhang, X H Qu. Hardware-based equispaced-phase resampling nonlinearity correction algorithm and spectral analysis method. Acta Optica Sinica, 36, 1212003(2016).

[41] S Jiang, B Liu, H C Wang, et al. Absolute distance measurement using frequency-scanning interferometry based on Hilbert phase subdivision. Sensors, 19, 5132(2019).

[42] Z Liu, Z G Liu, Z W Deng, et al. Interference signal frequency tracking for extracting phase in frequency scanning interferometry using an extended Kalman filter. Applied Optics, 55, 2985-2992(2016).

[43] Z Y Wang, Z G Liu, Z W Deng, et al. Phase extraction of non-stationary interference signal in frequency scanning interferometry using complex shifted Morlet wavelets. Optics Communications, 420, 26-33(2018).

[44] Z W Deng, Z G Liu, S W Gu, et al. Frequency-scanning interferometry for depth mapping using the Fabry–Perot cavity as a reference with compensation for nonlinear optical frequency scanning. Optics Communications, 455, 124556(2020).

[45] R Ohna, I Uehira, S I Kakuma. Interferometric determination of a static optical path difference using a frequency swept laser diode. Measurement Science and Technology, 1, 500-504(1990).

[46] L Q Jing, G Zheng, B Sun, et al. Measurement of distance to moving target using frequency-modulated continuous-wave interference technique. Chinese Journal of Lasers, 46, 1204001(2019).

[47] Y T Li, F M Zhang, H Pan, et al. Simulation of vibration compensation in frequency-modulated continuous-wave laser ranging system. Chinese Journal of Lasers, 46, 0104001(2019).

[48] Cabral A, Rebdão J M, Abreu M. Dual frequency sweeping interferometry with rangeinvariant accuracy f absolute distance metrology [C]Proceedings of the SPIE, 2008, 7063: 70630T.

[49] A Cabral, M Abreu, J M Rebordão. Dual-frequency sweeping interferometry for absolute metrology of long distances. Optical Engineering, 49, 085601(2010).

[50] R Schneider, P Thürmel, M Stockmann. Distance measurement of moving objects by frequency modulated laser radar. Optical Engineering, 40, 33-37(2001).

[51] P A Coe, D F Howell, R B Nickerson. Frequency scanning interferometry in ATLAS: Remote, multiple, simultaneous and precise distance measurements in a hostile environment. Measurement Science and Technology, 15, 2175-2187(2004).

[52] H J Yang, J Deibel, S Nyberg, et al. High-precision absolute distance and vibration measurement with frequency scanned interferometry. Applied Optics, 44, 3937-3944(2005).

[53] B L Swinkels, N Bhattacharya, J J M Braat. Correcting movement errors in frequency-sweeping interferometry. Optics Letters, 30, 2242-2244(2005).

[54] Cabral A, Rebdão J. Absolute distance metrology with frequency sweeping interferometry [C]Proceedings of SPIE, 2005, 5879: 58790L.

[55] Floch S Le, Y Salvadé, R Mitouassiwou, et al. Radio frequency controlled synthetic wavelength sweep for absolute distance measurement by optical interferometry. Applied Optics, 47, 3027-3031(2008).

[56] Floch S Le, Y Salvadé, N Droz, et al. Superheterodyne configuration for two-wavelength interferometry applied to absolute distance measurement. Applied Optics, 49, 714-717(2010).

[57] F Pollinger, K Meiners-Hagen, M Wedde, et al. Diode-laser-based high-precision absolute distance interferometer of 20 m range. Applied Optics, 48, 6188-6194(2009).

[58] Z D Li, Y S Jiang, F Sang, et al. Movement error compensation in frequency scanning interferometry for absolute distance measurement. Acta Optica Sinica, 31, 0314001(2011).

[59] S Kakuma, Y Katase. Frequency scanning interferometry immune to length drift using a pair of vertical-cavity surface-emitting laser diodes. Optical Review, 19, 376-380(2012).

[60] J Dale, B Hughes, A J Lancaster, et al. Multi-channel absolute distance measurement system with subppm-accuracy and 20 m range using frequency scanning interferometry and gas absorption cells. Optics Express, 22, 24869-24893(2014).

[61] L Tao, Z G Liu, W B Zhang, et al. Frequency-scanning interferometry for dynamic absolute distance measurement using Kalman filter. Optics Letters, 39, 6997-7000(2014).

[62] L Tao, Z G Liu, T Lv, et al. Drift error compensation method of frequency sweeping interferometer by consecutive forward and reverse optical frequency scanning. Acta Optica Sinica, 34, 0212002(2014).

[63] J J Martinez, M A Campbell, M S Warden, et al. Dual-sweep frequency scanning interferometry using four wave mixing. IEEE Photonics Technology Letters, 27, 733-736(2015).

[64] G Prellinger, K Meiners-Hagen, F Pollinger. Spectroscopically in situ traceable heterodyne frequency-scanning interferometry for distances up to 50m. Measurement Science and Technology, 26, 084003(2015).

[65] G Prellinger, K Meiners-Hagen, F Pollinger. Dynamic high-resolution spectroscopic frequency referencing for frequency sweeping interferometry. Surface Topography: Metrology and Properties, 4, 024012(2016).

[66] C Lu, G D Liu, B G Liu, et al. Absolute distance measurement system with micron-grade measurement uncertainty and 24 m range using frequency scanning interferometry with compensation of environmental vibration. Optics Express, 24, 30215-30224(2016).

[67] G D Liu, X K Xu, B G Liu, et al. A method of suppressing vibration for high precision broadband laser frequency scanning interferometry. Acta Physica Sinica, 65, 209501(2016).

[68] X L Chen, X C Wang, S L Pan. Accuracy enhanced distance measurement system using doublesideband modulated frequency scanning interferometry. Optical Engineering, 56, 036114(2017).

[69] X L Chen, X C Wang, S L Pan. Laser ranging of frequency scanning interferometry system based on double-sideband modulation. Acta Photonica Sinica, 46, 0612005(2017).

[70] D Mo, R Wang, G Z Li, et al. Double-sideband frequency scanning interferometry for long-distance dynamic absolute measurement. Applied Physics B, 123, 272(2017).

[71] X Y Jia, Z G Liu, L Tao, et al. Frequency-scanning interferometry using a time-varying Kalman filter for dynamic tracking measurements. Optics Express, 25, 25782-25796(2017).

[72] X Y Jia, Z G Liu, Z W Deng, et al. Dynamic absolute distance measurement by frequency sweeping interferometry based Doppler beat frequency tracking model. Optics Communications, 430, 163-169(2019).

[73] S H Zhang, Z Y Xu, B Y Chen, et al. Sinusoidal phase modulating absolute distance measurement interferometer combining frequency-sweeping and multiwavelength interferometry. Optics Express, 26, 9273-9284(2018).

[74] G P Barwood, P Gill, W R C Rowley. High-accuracy length metrology using multiple-stage swept-frequency interferometry with laser diodes. Measurement Science and Technology, 9, 1036-1041(1998).

[75] F M Zhang, Y T Li, H Pan, et al. Vibration compensation of the frequency-scanning-interferometry-based absolute ranging system. Applied Sciences, 9, 147(2019).

[76] B Shao, W Zhang, P Zhang, et al. Dynamic clearance measurement using fiber-optic frequency-swept and frequency-fixed interferometry. IEEE Photonics Technology Letters, 32, 1331-1334(2020).

[77] Y Shang, J R Lin, L H Yang, et al. Precision improvement in frequency scanning interferometry based on suppression of the magnification effect. Optics Express, 28, 5822-5834(2020).

[78] Y Koshikiya, X Y Fan, F Ito, et al. High resolution PNC-OFDR with suppressed fading noise for dispersive media measurement. Journal of Lightwave Technology, 31, 866-873(2013).

[79] M Wojtkowski, V J Srinivasan, Ko, H T, et al. Ultrahigh-resolution, high-speed, Fourier domain optical coherence tomography and methods for dispersion compensation. Optics Express, 12, 2404-2422(2004).

[80] Z W Barber, W R Babbitt, B Kaylor, et al. Accuracy of active chirp linearization for broadband frequency modulated continuous wave ladar. Applied Optics, 49, 213-219(2010).

[81] Z W Barber, F R Giorgetta, P A Roos, et al. Characterization of an actively linearized ultrabroadband chirped laser with a fiber-laser optical frequency comb. Optics Letters, 36, 1152-1154(2011).

[82] X K Xu, G D Liu, F D Chen, et al. Research on the fiber dispersion and compensation in large-scale highresolution broadband frequencymodulated continuous wave laser measurement system. Optical Engineering, 54, 074102(2015).

[83] X K Xu, G D Liu, B G Liu, et al. High-resolution laser frequency scanning interferometer based on fiber dispersion phase compensation. Acta Physica Sinica, 64, 219501(2015).

[84] H Pan, X H Qu, C Z Shi, et al. Resolution-enhancement and sampling error correction based on molecular absorption line in frequency scanning interferometry. Optics Communications, 416, 214-220(2018).

[85] G Shi, K Hei, W Wang, et al. High precision FSI for absolute distance measurement using a tunable laser with sweeping range of 88 GHz. Measurement Science and Technology, 31, 109293(2019).

[86] S M Gibson, P A Coe, A Mitra, et al. Coordinate measurement in 2-D and 3-D geometries using frequency scanning interferometry. Optics and Lasers in Engineering, 43, 815-831(2005).

[87] F Gao, H Muhamedsalih, X Q Jiang. Surface and thickness measurement of a transparent film using wavelength scanning interferometry. Optics Express, 20, 21450-21456(2012).

[88] T X Chen, H J Yang, K Riles, et al. High-precision absolute coordinate measurement using frequency scanned interferometry. Journal of Instrumentation, 9, P03001(2014).

[89] H Gabai, I Steinberg, A Eyal. Multiplexing of fiber-optic ultrasound sensors via swept frequency interferometry. Optics Express, 23, 18915-18924(2015).

[90] S Ohno, D Iida, K Toge, et al. High-resolution measurement of differential mode delay of few-mode fiber using phase reference technique for swept-frequency interferometry. Optical Fiber Technology, 40, 56-61(2018).

[91] I Kim, R J Martins, J Jang, et al. Nanophotonics for light detection and ranging technology. Nature Nanotechnology, 16, 508-524(2021).