• Laser & Optoelectronics Progress
  • Vol. 60, Issue 24, 2410011 (2023)
Hao Wang*, Dongmei Song, Bin Wang, and Song Dai
Author Affiliations
  • College of Ocean and Space Information, China University of Petroleum (East China), Qingdao 266580, Shandong, China
  • show less
    DOI: 10.3788/LOP230737 Cite this Article Set citation alerts
    Hao Wang, Dongmei Song, Bin Wang, Song Dai. Fracture Zone Extraction Method Based on Three-Dimensional Convolutional Neural Network Combined with PointSIFT[J]. Laser & Optoelectronics Progress, 2023, 60(24): 2410011 Copy Citation Text show less
    Flow chart of LiDAR point cloud fracture zone extraction method
    Fig. 1. Flow chart of LiDAR point cloud fracture zone extraction method
    Schematic diagram of OE convolution unit. (a) Point cloud in 3D space (the input point is at origin); (b) nearest neighbour search in eight octants; (c) convolution along X, Y, Z axis
    Fig. 2. Schematic diagram of OE convolution unit. (a) Point cloud in 3D space (the input point is at origin); (b) nearest neighbour search in eight octants; (c) convolution along X, Y, Z axis
    PointSIFT module
    Fig. 3. PointSIFT module
    Schematic diagram of three-dimensional convolution module framework
    Fig. 4. Schematic diagram of three-dimensional convolution module framework
    Schematic diagram of PS-CNN point cloud fracture zone extraction framework
    Fig. 5. Schematic diagram of PS-CNN point cloud fracture zone extraction framework
    Sample display diagrams of ISPRS point cloud datasets. (a); Samp51; (b) Samp53
    Fig. 6. Sample display diagrams of ISPRS point cloud datasets. (a); Samp51; (b) Samp53
    Sample display diagrams of Chuandian point cloud datasets. (a) CD_1; (b) CD_2
    Fig. 7. Sample display diagrams of Chuandian point cloud datasets. (a) CD_1; (b) CD_2
    Results of three fracture zone extraction methods on Samp51. (a) Label; (b) TD; (c) DNN; (d) PS-CNN
    Fig. 8. Results of three fracture zone extraction methods on Samp51. (a) Label; (b) TD; (c) DNN; (d) PS-CNN
    Results of three fracture zone extraction methods on Samp53. (a) Label; (b) TD; (c) DNN; (d) PS-CNN
    Fig. 9. Results of three fracture zone extraction methods on Samp53. (a) Label; (b) TD; (c) DNN; (d) PS-CNN
    Results of three fracture zone extraction methods on CD_1. (a) Label; (b) TD; (c) DNN; (d) PS-CNN
    Fig. 10. Results of three fracture zone extraction methods on CD_1. (a) Label; (b) TD; (c) DNN; (d) PS-CNN
    Results of three fracture zone extraction methods on CD_2. (a) Label; (b) TD; (c) DNN; (d) PS-CNN
    Fig. 11. Results of three fracture zone extraction methods on CD_2. (a) Label; (b) TD; (c) DNN; (d) PS-CNN
    ErrorCalculation method
    T.Ic/(c+d
    T.IIb/(a+b
    T.E.b+c)/(a+b+c+d
    Table 1. Confusion matrix of classification results and evaluation errors calculation method
    DatasetMethodT.Ⅰ/%T.Ⅱ/%T.E./%Accuracy /%Time /s
    Samp51TD1.229.312.8297.1816
    DNN0.464.951.3598.6532
    PS-CNN0.402.430.7999.2151
    Samp53TD2.4317.373.8396.1799
    DNN1.0711.392.0397.97136
    PS-CNN0.1810.161.1198.89193
    Table 2. Performance comparison of three fracture zone extraction methods on ISPRS dataset
    DatasetMethodT.Ⅰ/%T.Ⅱ/%T.E./%Accuracy /%Time /s
    CD_1TD1.151.471.3298.68238
    DNN0.770.970.8899.12342
    PS-CNN0.290.490.4099.60424
    CD_2TD1.391.311.3698.64273
    DNN0.632.011.2898.72364
    PS-CNN0.210.500.3599.65473
    Table 3. Performance comparison of three fracture zone extraction methods on Chuandian dataset
    DatasetPointSIFTT.Ⅰ /%T.Ⅱ /%T.E. /%Aaccuracy /%
    Samp510.442.480.8399.17
    0.402.430.7999.21
    Samp530.2310.271.1798.83
    0.1810.161.1198.89
    Table 4. Performance comparison of three fracture zone extraction methods on ISPRS dataset
    DatasetMethodDilution ratePointAaccuracy /%Time /s
    CD_1PS-CNN0.36581799.58370
    0.27536399.60424
    0.18467099.63476
    CD_2PS-CNN0.37235799.64412
    0.28305999.65473
    0.19343499.67532
    Table 5. Performance comparison of the proposed method on point cloud samples with different dilution rate
    Hao Wang, Dongmei Song, Bin Wang, Song Dai. Fracture Zone Extraction Method Based on Three-Dimensional Convolutional Neural Network Combined with PointSIFT[J]. Laser & Optoelectronics Progress, 2023, 60(24): 2410011
    Download Citation