• Infrared and Laser Engineering
  • Vol. 54, Issue 5, 20240492 (2025)
Yuanrui CAO1, Lishuan WANG1, Huasong LIU1, Shiqi YANG1..., Peng SUN1 and Xinshang NIU2|Show fewer author(s)
Author Affiliations
  • 1Tianjin Key Laboratory of Optical Thin Film, Tianjin Jinhang Institute of Technical Physics, Tianjin 300308, China
  • 2Key Laboratory of Advanced Micro-Structure Materials, Tongji University, Shanghai 200092, China
  • show less
    DOI: 10.3788/IRLA20240492 Cite this Article
    Yuanrui CAO, Lishuan WANG, Huasong LIU, Shiqi YANG, Peng SUN, Xinshang NIU. Photothermal simulation of laser protective/mid-infrared antireflective multilayer on ZnS window[J]. Infrared and Laser Engineering, 2025, 54(5): 20240492 Copy Citation Text show less

    Abstract

    Objective Infrared optical system is vital for aircraft in the terminal stage. As a fragile part of optical system, optical windows are under the threat of external environment, which could bring interference and damage to the windows. With the development of laser theory and technology, laser protection becomes more and more important for infrared optical windows. Laser protection can be sorted as linear protection, nonlinear protection, phase transition protection and so on. Among those protection methods, linear protection has the characteristic of low-cost and high performance on small angles incident, which is suitable for optical windows in the terminal stage. Linear protection method usually includes multilayers which have high reflectivity during the wave band of laser. Due to the small scale, high reflective films have lower laser damage endurance. Thus the laser induced damage theory of thin film is widely discussed around world. The relevant study about high laser induced damage threshold thin film is usually on single layer and double layers, also the film material is in visible band. It’s important to know the laser damage of laser protective multilayer for infrared optical window. Therefore, the laser thermal effect and optical characteristic of a laser protective/mid infrared anti-reflective multilayer is studied.Method A model of laser damage on laser protective/mid infrared anti-reflective multilayer is establish (Fig.1) with the help of finite element analysis method. Using two couples of material HfO2/SiO2 and ZnS/YbF3, two types of multilayers are designed on ZnS optical window substrate. By comparing the optical performance and laser thermal effect(Fig.3-Fig.4), the multilayer structure of HfO2/SiO2 is used for further study. Single variable method is chosen and the effect of thickness, reflective index and extinction coefficient of layer material on multilayer is studied.Results and Discussions By comparing infrared window without protection, infrared window with single layer coating and infrared window with laser protective/mid infrared anti-reflective multilayer coating, the result shows that laser protective/mid infrared antireflective multilayer can reduce the temperature of optical window when laser incident. The analysis of HfO2/SiO2 multilayer concludes three parts: thickness of top three layers, reflective index of HfO2 and SiO2, extinction coefficient of HfO2 and SiO2. All three variables can influence the temperature of multilayer, reflectance at 1.06 μm and average transmittance during 3-5 μm. When the error of thickness of top three layers goes to 10% larger than the ideal value, temperature of multilayer grows to 88% higher, reflectance at 1.06 μm becomes 0.5% lower and average transmittance during 3-5 μm becomes 0.2% lower. When the error of reflective index of HfO2 goes to 10% smaller than the ideal value, temperature of multilayer grows to 55% higher, reflectance at 1.06 μm becomes 14.4% lower and average transmittance during 3-5 μm becomes 1.7% lower. The result shows that film/substrate temperature grows one order of magnitude higher when extinction coefficient kL grows two orders of magnitude higher. When the extinction coefficient of SiO2 grows 1×10-5 larger, the temperature becomes 93 degrees larger, meanwhile the temperature becomes 25 degrees larger for HfO2 at the same condition.Conclusions When preparing optical multilayers, there always have error on structure and material properties. By establishing finite element analysis model about laser protective/mid infrared anti-reflective multilayer on ZnS substrate, thickness, reflective index and extinction coefficient are studied to confirm the relationship with multilayer laser thermal effect and optical properties. At the range of -3%-3%, influence of thickness and reflective index error on temperature and optical properties can be ignored. By comparing two materials, the change of temperature caused by extinction coefficient of SiO2 is much stronger than HfO2, which mean that reducing the extinction coefficient of SiO2 is a good way to reduce laser thermal effect and advance the ability to endure laser attack. The study can provide an idea for designing laser protective and mid infrared antireflective multilayer with high induced laser damage threshold.
    Yuanrui CAO, Lishuan WANG, Huasong LIU, Shiqi YANG, Peng SUN, Xinshang NIU. Photothermal simulation of laser protective/mid-infrared antireflective multilayer on ZnS window[J]. Infrared and Laser Engineering, 2025, 54(5): 20240492
    Download Citation