
- Photonics Research
- Vol. 12, Issue 11, 2495 (2024)
Abstract
1. INTRODUCTION
Surface plasmons (SPs) are collective electron oscillations occurring at the interfaces between dielectric and metallic materials [1]. Their unique characteristics, encompassing localized field enhancement and subwavelength confinement, have spurred applications in various fields, including super-resolution imaging [2,3], surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy [4,5], and high-sensitivity chemical and biological sensing [6,7]. As they propagate along the surface, SPs interact robustly over a substantial length and can traverse line-guided metallic structures such as stripes, grooves, and gaps, thus showing significant potential in integrated plasmonic components for signal waveguiding and processing [8–10], especially in the domains of communications and photonic circuits. Consequently, extensive investigation has been undertaken across the visible, infrared, and terahertz (THz) frequency bands due to the critical need for seamlessly coupling free-space propagating waves into SPs. In particular, THz SP couplers, characterized by well-confined fields facilitating efficient interaction with analytes in surface sensing and non-linear modulation applications, also simultaneously permit chip-scale THz wave manipulation, propagation, and processing. However, conventional SP couplers based on prisms or gratings are either bulky or inflexible, hindering the further development of this field [11–16].
In the last two decades, the development of metamaterials and metasurfaces has revolutionized the design concepts of traditional optical devices, offering new opportunities for efficient and flexible coupling of SPs [8,10]. In particular, phase gradient metasurfaces have been proven as efficient SP metacouplers [17], since the momentum difference between free-space light and SPs can be matched by properly arranging the phase gradient at the interface. Such a paradigm was first proposed at microwave frequencies and has been rapidly developed in different frequency regimes, fostering various metacouplers of different configurations and different functions [17–38]. However, due to the non-uniformity of a phase gradient metasurface, unlike SPs that constitute the eigenmode of the system, the driven surface waves in this case suffer from significant scattering loss [20]. In order to solve this problem, a recently reported work was proposed to guide out and support the eigenmode SPs by placing an additional plasmonic layer, achieving efficiencies of up to 94% in simulations and 73% in experiments [33]. However, the strict requirements of the separation and parallel configuration of the SP coupler and the plasmonic layer complicate the fabrication, which makes it difficult to extend this scheme to THz frequencies. Hence, there is a pressing need to explore new design strategies and structures to enhance the performance of THz SP metacouplers and expand their potential applications.
In this paper, we propose and experimentally demonstrate a novel approach that employs bright–dark mode coupling in a microstructure composed of bilayer sandwiched metallic patterns to efficiently excite broadband SPs (see Table 1 in Appendix A for a detailed comparison with other SP couplers). By fine-tuning the near-field coupling strength between adjacent meta-atoms and adjusting the resonance frequencies, we can achieve transmitted cross-polarized components with nearly 100% efficiency. To demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach, a THz metacoupler for SP excitation is designed and simulated. Our proposed structure offers several advantages, including high SP conversion efficiency (approximately 95.01% at 0.73 THz under the ideal conditions of no material absorption), wide bandwidth (0.7–0.76 THz with an efficiency exceeding 80%), and a degree of robustness against changes in vertical and lateral coupling. The compact, cost-effective, and high-coupling performance of our SP excitation scheme holds the promise for advancing integrated plasmonics by enabling high-specificity chip-scale sensing [39] and high-speed communications [40].
Comparison of Key Metrics between Our Metacoupler and Reported Designs
Reference | Mode of | Frequency | Mechanism of Operation | Efficiency |
---|---|---|---|---|
Ref. [ | Trans. | 0.5–1 THz | Resonance phase gradient metasurface | N/A (efficiency of the unit cell limited to 25%) |
Ref. [ | Refl. | Telecom wavelength (around 1500 nm) | Resonance phase gradient metasurface | 25% (Exp) |
Ref. [ | Trans. | 8–11 GHz | Resonance phase gradient metasurface | 94% (Sim) 73% (Exp) |
Ref. [ | Refl. | 9.5–10.5 GHz | Pancharatnam–Berry phase gradient metasurface | 81% (Sim) 78% (Exp) |
Ref. [ | Trans. | 9–11 GHz | Huygens’ metasurface | 92% (Sim) 90.2% (Exp) |
Ref. [ | Trans. | 0.34–0.5 THz | Propagation phase gradient metasurface | 39.5% (Sim) No Exp |
Trans. | 0.2–1.2 THz | Resonance phase gradient metasurface | 95.01% (Sim with ideal condition) |
The reference numbers correspond to those in the reference list. Trans., transmissive; Refl., reflective; Exp, experiment; Sim, simulation.
2. RESULTS
A. Design of Meta-Atoms with Bright–Dark Mode Coupling and Far-Field Experiment
A coupled system for cross-polarization conversion should have a broken mirror symmetry along the incident polarization and the axis perpendicular to the incident polarization. Moreover, for multilayer metallic thin-film metamaterials, near-field intercoupling can be tuned not only by the relative positions of the bright and dark resonances but also by the thickness of the dielectric spacer, which means more design freedoms and high flexibility for applications in subwavelength optics. With these conditions taken into consideration, a unit cell composed of a bilayer coupled split-ring slit (SRS) and a cut-wire slit (CWS) is chosen as the metal pattern and illustrated in Fig. 1(a). The CWS and SRS at the top and bottom layers with orthogonal polarization-selection properties act as the bright and dark modes, respectively. Polyimide (PI) film has a relatively low loss at THz frequencies and therefore is particularly suitable to serve as a spacer in the THz regime. Moreover, the PI was chosen due to its good mechanical stability, which can protect the structural completeness of the processing. Thus, a 22-μm-thick PI film is sandwiched between two 200-nm-thick metal structures. The periods of the meta-atoms are 200 μm along the
Figure 1.Bilayer meta-atom design and its optical properties under ideal conditions. (a) Schematic of the designed meta-atom structure. (b) Two different configurations of the meta-atom. (c) Simulated cross-polarization amplitudes for configurations 1 and 2 within the frequency range from 0.4 to 1.0 THz. (d) Simulated cross-polarization phase distributions for configurations 1 and 2 within the frequency range from 0.66 to 0.8 THz. (e), (f) Simulated cross-polarization amplitudes for different scales of the dark and bright modes within the frequency range from 0.4 to 1.0 THz, respectively.
Similar to common subwavelength slit resonators, the SRS and CWS can be excited by an electric component perpendicular to their base arms and then produce an electric resonance. The resonance frequency and coupling strength are mainly determined by the overall slit length and the relative in-plane and inter-plane spacings. Thus, by changing the above geometric parameters, we can obtain the desired transmission performance at specific frequencies. To materialize the realistic meta-atom design, the spectral response was simulated with the commercial software CST Microwave Studio. By means of numerical optimization, we fix the structural parameters of the meta-atom as follows (see Appendix B for the parameter settings in the simulation):
By systematically scaling the geometric parameters of the dark and bright mode resonators, as depicted respectively in Figs. 1(e) and 1(f), it is observed that the collective response of the dual-layer bright–dark mode resonator system undergoes substantial frequency shifts and amplitude reductions. The optimal system response is achieved only when the scale factor is set to 1, representing the adoption of the original optimized geometric parameters. To gain further insight into the performance of the polarization conversion and bright–dark resonance mode interaction, we have simulated the cross-polarized electric field distributions (see Appendix D for the results and detailed discussion).
Before fabrication and measurement of the meta-atom samples, we take into account the loss of the actual materials. Consequently, the geometric parameters of the structure are re-optimized, incorporating the imaginary parts of the dielectric constants and the finite conductivity of metal Al:
To experimentally validate the accuracy of numerical simulations, we characterized the fabricated sample using far-field THz-TDS to measure the transmittance of the unit cells under normal incidence. During the experiment, the chamber was purged with dry nitrogen to avoid noise from water vapor absorption. Since both the incident and detection modules of our THz-TDS system were sensitive to the
Figure 2.Far-field measurement system and results of the unit cells. (a) Schematic diagram of the THz-TDS system and microscopy images of the fabricated metasurface. (b) Experimental cross-polarization amplitudes for configurations 1 and 2 within the frequency range from 0.2 to 1.2 THz. (c) Experimental cross-polarization phase distributions for configurations 1 and 2 within the frequency range from 0.6 to 0.78 THz.
B. Efficient Bidirectional Symmetric Excitation of SPs and Near-Field Experiment
The supercell of the metacoupler in the horizontal direction is constituted by two meta-atoms featuring the two different configurations shown in Fig. 1(b) with a supercell period
Figure 3.Excitation properties of the bilayer metacoupler. (a) Three-dimensional diagram of the overall metasurface design. The incident wave is a transverse electric mode, a TM mode of the orthogonal polarization is obtained through bright–dark mode coupling, and a TM SP mode is then excited. (b) Dispersion relations of the coated metal surface and the free-space wave. (c) Simulated distribution of the real part of the
SPs arise from the interaction between the incident electromagnetic field and the free electrons on a metal surface. This interaction leads to the formation of a rapidly decaying field within the metal, enabling the propagation of SPs along the metallic plate as an eigen transverse magnetic (TM) mode. Concentrated primarily at the interface, the electric field of the SPs gradually diminishes along the propagation direction due to the absorption of the metal and the inherent loss within the spin-coated PI confinement layer. To ensure that the emergent waves are confined to propagate at the interface, where almost all the emergent electric fields exist as
Figure 3(d) illustrates the
To confirm the numerically simulated results discussed earlier, we performed experiments employing scanning near-field THz microscopy to measure the SP electric field of the metacoupler under linearly polarized normal incidence, as depicted in Fig. 4(a). The fabrication process was similar to the case for the meta-atom samples. This measurement was achieved by employing a pair of electrodes sensitive to the
Figure 4.Near-field measurement system and results of the bilayer metacoupler and slit coupler. (a) Schematic of the scanning near-field THz microscopy system and microscopy images of the fabricated metacoupler and slit coupler. (b) Experimental distribution of the real part of the
Figure 4(c) illustrates the
It is almost impossible to collect all the near-field energy in the experiment. Therefore, we will indirectly quantify the efficiency by comparing the intensity of the SPs excited by our metacoupler with that of an optimized slit coupler with the same excitation region. Additionally, their average intensity values were obtained at the same position in the propagation region. The experimental results in Fig. 4(d) show that the average strength of the metacoupler at 0.73 THz is 5.6 times that of the slit coupler, which indirectly proves the higher efficiency of our design.
C. Discussions on SP Excitation and Propagation
Having demonstrated the capability of our metacoupler, we quantitatively evaluated the working efficiency of our scheme. In our calculations, we numerically integrate the total powers carried by the excited SP beam and the linearly polarized input beam and then define the ratio between them as the working efficiency of our metacoupler. As the schematic diagram in Fig. 5(a) and the results for ideal parameters in Fig. 5(b) show, the efficiency of a sample with 10 supercells reaches 95.01% at 0.73 THz. It is slightly lower than the polarization conversion efficiency of the meta-atoms and maintains a high level of over 80% within the frequency range from 0.7 to 0.76 THz. Such a high performance for SP excitation in the THz regime is rarely reported in previous literature.
Figure 5.Efficiencies of the bilayer metacoupler and another two SP couplers. (a) Schematic of the designed bilayer metacoupler. (b) Simulated SP excitation efficiency of the metacoupler with ideal parameters within the frequency range from 0.55 to 0.95 THz. (c) Schematic of the designed reflectarray coupler. (d) Comparison of simulated SP excitation efficiencies of the bilayer metacoupler and reflectarray coupler (both with ideal parameters) as a function of supercell number. (e) Schematic of the designed slit coupler. (f) Comparison of simulated SP excitation efficiencies of the metacoupler and slit coupler (both with non-ideal parameters) within the frequency range from 0.55 to 0.9 THz.
The key factors responsible for the low SP excitation efficiencies of previous THz couplers are the inherent loss of materials, the normal-mode reflection at the surface, and the decoupling of SPs back into propagating waves. A thorough analysis of our scheme indicates that it has successfully resolved most of the previously identified issues. The material of our metacoupler is assumed to be lossless in the simulation, without considering the ohmic loss of the metal and the non-radiative loss of the dielectrics. In the experiment, we also selected COC film with minimal loss to act as a spacer layer. In addition, using a bright–dark mode coupling-based bilayer metasurface instead of a single-layer metallic resonance can easily break through the theoretical limitation of 25% in polarization conversion because this design significantly suppresses the channels other than cross-polarization transmission. The high transmission of the meta-atoms forms the basis for efficient SP conversion. Additionally, through the optimization of the geometric parameters, a reasonable phase gradient is provided to compensate for the impedance and momentum mismatches between the SPs and the free-space wave. Consequently, the excited SPs can penetrate the materials to the maximum extent, minimizing specular reflection and backscattering of the electromagnetic waves and thereby achieving efficient excitation. Moreover, by properly designing the thickness of the coated PI layers, the wave vector of the driven surface waves generated in the structural region matches that of the eigen SPs propagating in the guide-out region, preventing the SPs from leaving the interface.
We further compared the SP excitation efficiencies as a function of the number of supercells
Increasing the number of the excitation region structures yields a concurrent rise in the cross-coupling effects among them, which results in partial dissipation of SP energy, thereby diminishing the excitation efficiency. Moreover, scattering loss includes two types: one due to the inhomogeneity of the microstructure, and the other due to the decoupling caused by reciprocity. Both our design and the reflectarray metasurface exhibit the second type of scattering loss, which is why the SP coupling efficiency of the two couplers decreases after saturation as the excitation area further increases. However, regarding the first type, the non-uniformity of the metallic structure in the reflectarray metasurface is significantly greater than that of our metacoupler, resulting in a more severe scattering loss. This also explains why the SP coupling efficiency of the reflectarray metasurface declines more rapidly and noticeably when the number of supercells increases.
Finally, we compared a traditional transmissive slit coupler with our metacoupler by considering material losses. The diagram of the optimized slit coupler is shown in Fig. 5(e). The width of the slit is
This difference between the two couplers can also be attributed to the scattering losses as discussed above. However, the excitation efficiency of our metacoupler with material losses considered [53.02% in Fig. 5(f)] is lower than that of lossless materials [95.01% in Fig. 5(b)]. This is because the operation mechanism of our design utilizes localized SP resonances and strong near-field coupling between the two modes. When material losses are considered, the interaction process will amplify the impact of metal and dielectric medium absorption on the SP coupling efficiency, preventing it from exceeding 60% at the working frequency. Admittedly, the control principle of the slit coupler is similar to a single-layer hole array [46], exhibiting extraordinary optical transmission. By comparison, our design leverages the near-field coupling between the bilayer bright and dark resonators to achieve orthogonal polarization conversion and generate an additional
3. CONCLUSION
In summary, our study introduced and experimentally demonstrated a bilayer metacoupler with a phase gradient enabled by bright–dark mode coupling. This design effectively connects SPs and free-space propagating waves in the THz frequency range, yielding exceptionally high efficiency. The high efficiency of this SP metacoupler stems from its ability to circumvent such issues as initial reflection and the decoupling effect, which have plagued previous THz SP couplers and diminished their performance. Model simulations in our study predict an optimal excitation efficiency of 95% under ideal conditions. This marks a substantial improvement over existing designs. To validate the effectiveness of our approach, we fabricated a sample and conducted tests on bidirectional symmetric SP excitation. Our metacoupler maintains consistently high efficiency levels, surpassing 80% over the frequency range from 0.7 to 0.76 THz in the simulation. Importantly, the performance of our metacoupler exhibits minimal susceptibility to variations in the number of supercells and a degree of robustness against vertical and lateral coupling changes. Surface wave launchers with bidirectional excitation are convenient and compact for applications such as real-time online spectral analysis that require reserved reference light. Our approach paves the way toward high-specificity chip-scale sensing and high-speed communication applications in the field of THz science.
APPENDIX A: COMPARISON BETWEEN OUR METACOUPLER AND OTHER REPORTED DESIGNS
By comparing the performances of the above SP metacouplers with other designs (Table
APPENDIX B: PARAMETER SETTINGS FOR META-ATOM SIMULATION
In the simulations, we set periodic boundary conditions along the
APPENDIX C: RELATIVE PERMITTIVITIES OF DIELECTRIC MATERIALS
The time-domain transmission signal of a thin-film sample with a specific thickness and the time-domain reference signal can be measured by THz-TDS. By performing the Fourier transforms of the two signals and then dividing the sample signal by the reference signal in the frequency domain, the transmission coefficient can be obtained. Once we get the magnitude and phase of the transmission coefficient, we can obtain the relative permittivity of the thin-film material using Fresnel’s equations. The relative permittivities of PI obtained in this way are illustrated in Fig.
Figure 6.Relative permittivities of dielectric materials of PI.
APPENDIX D: ELECTRIC FIELD DISTRIBUTIONS BASED ON MODE RESONANCES
The cross-polarized electric field (
Figure 7.Cross-polarized electric field distributions of the top and bottom layers at the working frequency of 0.73 THz.
APPENDIX E: SIMULATION OF META-ATOM UNDER NON-IDEAL CONDITIONS
Before the fabrication of the sample, we took into account the loss of the actual materials, so the geometric parameters of the structure based on non-ideal conditions were re-optimized as follows:
Figure 8.Transmission spectra of bilayer meta-atoms under non-ideal conditions. (a) Simulated transmission amplitudes for configurations 1 and 2 within the frequency range from 0.2 to 1.2 THz. (b) Simulated transmission phases for configurations 1 and 2 within the frequency range from 0.6 to 0.78 THz.
APPENDIX F: STEPS OF METACOUPLER SAMPLE FABRICATION
Given that the metacoupler is a bilayer metallic structure, the top layer was processed initially. The fabrication process of the samples included several steps. Initially, a 40 μm-thick PI substrate was spin-coated and thermally cured onto the 1 mm-thick silicon wafer, functioning as a rigid holder. Subsequently, a 200 nm-thick layer of Al was thermally evaporated onto the top layer of the substrate. Following this, a thin layer of approximately 3 μm-thick photoresist (PR4000) was spin-coated onto the Al film. UV lithography and image development were utilized to pattern the photoresist through the use of a pre-prepared photomask and a developing solution (RZX3038). Afterward, a plasma degluing machine was employed to uniformly eliminate a thin layer of photoresist from the sample surface. This ensured the complete removal of the photoresist in the structural area while preserving the sharp gradient of the photoresist at the edge between the structural and non-structural areas. After this step, the Al layer was selectively removed using an etching solution with strong acids, weak acids, and deionized water, leading to the formation of patterned structures. Moreover, acetone was used to remove residual photoresist from the sample surface. Then, a 20 μm-thick PI layer was spin-coated as a spacer, and the aforementioned steps were iterated to achieve the metallic structure of the bottom layer. In the processing of nested lithography, alignment marks were used to ensure the alignment of the two metallic layers. Last, the 40 μm-thick PI film was fabricated and the metasurface was completely removed from the silicon wafer.
APPENDIX G: PARAMETER SETTING FOR DISPERSION RELATION SIMULATION
The calculation of dispersion relation was performed using the eigenmode solver of the CST software. The inset of Fig.
APPENDIX H: MECHANISM OF SP GENERATION BASED ON PHASE DISCONTINUITIES
A spatial distribution of phase discontinuities at the interface between two media can be constructed freely, where the refraction can be expressed by the following generalized Snell’s law:
APPENDIX I: SENSITIVITY OF METACOUPLER PERFORMANCE TO VERTICAL AND LATERAL COUPLING
In order to explore the influence of the lateral and vertical coupling on the SP excitation performance, the two resonators are moved along the
Figure 9.Simulated SP excitation intensities obtained with different vertical and lateral coupling. (a) Schematic of the designed supercell structure. (b) Vertical change between two resonators. (c)
APPENDIX J: SIMULATED ELECTRIC FIELD DISTRIBUTIONS OF GENERATED SPS UNDER NON-IDEAL CONDITIONS
The simulated SP electric fields and performance of the metacoupler under non-ideal conditions are illustrated in Fig.
Figure 10.Excitation properties of the bilayer metacoupler under non-ideal conditions. (a) Dispersion relation of the coated metal surface and the free-space wave. (b), (d) Simulated distributions of the real part of the
References

Set citation alerts for the article
Please enter your email address