Recent advances, perspectives, and challenges in ferroelectric synapses

Bo-Bo Tian; Ni Zhong; Chun-Gang Duan

doi:10.1088/1674-1056/aba603

[1] B Tian, L Liu, M Yan, J Wang, Q Zhao, N Zhong, P Xiang, L Sun, H Peng, H Shen, T Lin, B Dkhil, X Meng, J Chu, X Tang, C Duan. Adv. Electron. Mater, 5(2019).

[2] S H Lee, X Zhu, W D Lu. Nano Res, 13, 1228(2020).

[3] Z Wang, H Wu, G W Burr, C S Hwang, K L Wang, Q Xia, J J Yang. Nat. Rev. Mater, 5, 173(2020).

[4] Z Zhang, Z Wang, T Shi, C Bi, F Rao, Y Cai, Q Liu, H Wu, P Zhou. InfoMat, 2, 261(2020).

[5] S Liu, I Grinberg, A M Rappe. Nature, 534, 360(2016).

[6] C T Nelson, P Gao, J R Jokisaari, C Heikes, C Adamo, A Melville, S H Baek, C M Folkman, B Winchester, Y Gu, Y Liu, K Zhang, E Wang, J Li, L Q Chen, C B Eom, D G Schlom, X Pan. Science, 334, 968(2011).

[7] M Y Zhuravlev, R F Sabirianov, S S Jaswal, E Y Tsymbal. Phys. Rev. Lett, 94(2005).

[8] L Esaki, R B Laibowitz, P J Stiles. IBM Tech. Discl. Bull, 13, 2161(1971).

[9] H Béa, S Fusil, K Bouzehouane, M Bibes, M Sirena, G Herranz, E Jacquet, J P Contour, A Barthélémy. Jpn. J. Appl. Phys, 45, L187(2006).

[10] D Tenne, A Bruchhausen, N Lanzillotti-Kimura, A Fainstein, R Katiyar, A Cantarero, A Soukiassian, V Vaithyanathan, J Haeni, W Tian. Science, 313, 1614(2006).

[11] D D Fong, G B Stephenson, S K Streiffer, J A Eastman, O Auciello, P H Fuoss, C Thompson. Science, 304, 1650(2004).

[12] V Garcia, S Fusil, K Bouzehouane, S Enouz-Vedrenne, N D Mathur, A Barthelemy, M Bibes. Nature, 460, 81(2009).

[13] P Maksymovych, S Jesse, P Yu, R Ramesh, A P Baddorf, S V Kalinin. Science, 324, 1421(2009).

[14] A Gruverman, D Wu, H Lu, Y Wang, H W Jang, C M Folkman, M Y Zhuravlev, D Felker, M Rzchowski, C B Eom, E Y Tsymbal. Nano Lett, 9, 3539(2009).

[15] D Pantel, S Goetze, D Hesse, M Alexe. ACS Nano, 5, 6032(2011).

[16] A Chanthbouala, A Crassous, V Garcia, K Bouzehouane, S Fusil, X Moya, J Allibe, B Dlubak, J Grollier, S Xavier, C Deranlot, A Moshar, R Proksch, N D Mathur, M Bibes, A Barthelemy. Nat. Nanotech, 7, 101(2012).

[17] Z Wen, C Li, D Wu, A Li, N Ming. Nat. Mater, 12, 617(2013).

[18] Y W Yin, J D Burton, Y M Kim, A Y Borisevich, S J Pennycook, S M Yang, T W Noh, A Gruverman, X G Li, E Y Tsymbal, Q Li. Nat. Mater, 12, 397(2013).

[19] R Soni, A Petraru, P Meuffels, O Vavra, M Ziegler, S K Kim, D S Jeong, N A Pertsev, H Kohlstedt. Nat. Commun, 5, 5414(2014).

[20] C Li, L Huang, T Li, W Lu, X Qiu, Z Huang, Z Liu, S Zeng, R Guo, Y Zhao, K Zeng, M Coey, J Chen, , T Venkatesan. Nano Lett, 15, 2568(2015).

[21] H Yamada, A Tsurumaki-Fukuchi, M Kobayashi, T Nagai, Y Toyosaki, H Kumigashira, A Sawa. Adv. Funct. Mater, 25, 2708(2015).

[22] G Radaelli, D Gutierrez, F Sanchez, R Bertacco, M Stengel, J Fontcuberta. Adv. Mater, 27, 2602(2015).

[23] D Pantel, H Lu, S Goetze, P Werner, D Jik Kim, A Gruverman, D Hesse, M Alexe. Appl. Phys. Lett, 100(2012).

[24] H Yamada, V Garcia, S Fusil, S Boyn, M Marinova, A Gloter, S Xavier, J Grollier, E Jacquet, C Carretero, C Deranlot, M Bibes, A Barthelemy. ACS Nano, 7, 5385(2013).

[25] Z Wen, D Wu. Adv. Mater(2019).

[26] J Li, N Li, C Ge, H Huang, Y Sun, P Gao, M He, C Wang, G Yang, K Jin. IScience, 16, 368(2019).

[27] J P Velev, C G Duan, J Burton, A Smogunov, M K Niranjan, E Tosatti, S Jaswal, E Y Tsymbal. Nano Lett, 9, 427(2009).

[28] V Garcia, M Bibes, L Bocher, S Valencia, F Kronast, A Crassous, X Moya, S Enouz-Vedrenne, A Gloter, D Imhoff. Science, 327, 1106(2010).

[29] D Pantel, S Goetze, D Hesse, M Alexe. Nat. Mater, 11, 289(2012).

[30] M Gajek, M Bibes, S Fusil, K Bouzehouane, J Fontcuberta, A Barthélémy, A Fert. Nat. Mater, 6, 296(2007).

[31] W Huang, W Zhao, Z Luo, Y Yin, Y Lin, C Hou, B Tian, C G Duan, X G Li. Adv. Electron. Mater, 4(2018).

[32] Y Goh, S Jeon. Appl. Phys. Lett, 113(2018).

[33] M Kobayashi, Y Tagawa, F Mo, T Saraya, T Hiramoto. IEEE J. Electron. Devi, 7, 134(2019).

[34] F Ambriz-Vargas, G Kolhatkar, M Broyer, A Hadj-Youssef, R Nouar, A Sarkissian, R Thomas, C Gomez-Yanez, M A Gauthier, A Ruediger. ACS Appl. Mater. Inter, 9(2017).

[35] Y Wei, S Matzen, T Maroutian, G Agnus, M Salverda, P Nukala, Q Chen, J Ye, P Lecoeur, B Noheda. Phys. Rev. Appl, 12(2019).

[36] L Chen, T Y Wang, Y W Dai, M Y Cha, H Zhu, Q Q Sun, S J Ding, P Zhou, L Chua, D W Zhang. Nanoscale, 10(2018).

[37] B Tian, J Wang, S Fusil, Y Liu, X Zhao, S Sun, H Shen, T Lin, J Sun, C Duan, M Bibes, A Barthelemy, B Dkhil, V Garcia, X Meng, J Chu. Nat. Commun, 7(2016).

[38] A Chanthbouala, V Garcia, R O Cherifi, K Bouzehouane, S Fusil, X Moya, S Xavier, H Yamada, C Deranlot, N D Mathur, M Bibes, A Barthelemy, J Grollier. Nat. Mater, 11, 860(2012).

[39] D J Kim, H Lu, S Ryu, C W Bark, C B Eom, E Y Tsymbal, A Gruverman. Nano Lett, 12, 5697(2012).

[40] S Majumdar, H Tan, Q H Qin, S van Dijken. Adv. Electron. Mater, 5(2019).

[41] Z H Wang, W Zhao, W Kang, Y G Zhang, J O Klein, C Chappert. Int. Joint Conf. Neural Networks (IJCNN), 29-34(2014).

[42] C Yoon, J H Lee, S Lee, J H Jeon, J T Jang, D H Kim, Y H Kim, B H Park. Nano Lett, 17, 1949(2017).

[43] S Boyn, J Grollier, G Lecerf, B Xu, N Locatelli, S Fusil, S Girod, C Carretero, K Garcia, S Xavier, J Tomas, L Bellaiche, M Bibes, A Barthelemy, S Saighi, V Garcia. Nat. Commun, 8(2017).

[44] W Huang, Y W Fang, Y Yin, B Tian, W Zhao, C Hou, C Ma, Q Li, E Y Tsymbal, C G Duan, X Li. ACS Appl. Mater. Inter, 10, 5649(2018).

[45] J Li, C Ge, J Du, C Wang, G Yang, K Jin. Adv. Mater(2019).

[46] A Thomas, S Niehorster, S Fabretti, N Shepheard, O Kuschel, K Kupper, J Wollschlager, P Krzysteczko, E Chicca. Front. Neurosci, 9, 241(2015).

[47] C Zamarreno-Ramos, L A Camunas-Mesa, J A Perez-Carrasco, T Masquelier, T Serrano-Gotarredona, B Linares-Barranco. Front. Neurosci, 5, 26(2011).

[48] H Markram, J Lübke, M Frotscher, B Sakmann. Science, 275, 213(1997).

[49] C Ma, Z Luo, W Huang, L Zhao, Q Chen, Y Lin, X Liu, Z Chen, C Liu, H Sun, X Jin, Y Yin, X Li. Nat. Commun, 11, 1439(2020).

[50] M Coll, J Fontcuberta, M Althammer et al. Appl. Surf. Sci, 482, 1(2019).

[51] J Wang, B Liu, X Zhao, B Tian, Y Zou, S Sun, H Shen, J Sun, X Meng, J Chu. Appl. Phys. Lett, 104(2014).

[52] B Tian, Y Liu, L Chen, J Wang, S Sun, H Shen, J Sun, G Yuan, S Fusil, V Garcia, B Dkhil, X Meng, J Chu. Sci. Rep, 5(2016).

[53] B Tian, L Chen, Y Liu, X Bai, J Wang, S Sun, G Yuan, J Sun, B Dkhil, X Meng, J Chu. Phys. Rev. B, 92(2015).

[54] B Tian, Z Chen, A Jiang, X Zhao, B Liu, J Wang, L Han, S Sun, J Sun, X Meng, J Chu. Appl. Phys. Lett, 103(2013).

[55] B Tian, X Zhao, B Liu, J Wang, L Han, J Sun, X Meng, J Chu. Appl. Phys. Lett, 102(2013).

[56] B Tian, X Bai, Y Liu, P Gemeiner, X Zhao, B Liu, Y Zou, X Wang, H Huang, J Wang, S Sun, J Sun, B Dkhil, X Meng, J Chu. Appl. Phys. Lett, 106(2015).

[57] Z Yin, B Tian, Q Zhu, C Duan. Polymers, 11, 2033(2019).

[58] S Majumdar, B Chen, Q H Qin, H S Majumdar, S van Dijken. Adv. Funct. Mater, 28(2018).

[59] L Shi, G Zheng, B Tian, B Dkhil, C Duan. Nanoscale Adv, 2, 1811(2020).

[60] P Chen, X Peng, S Yu. IEEE Int. Electron. Devices Meeting (IEDM), 6.1.1-6.1.4(2017).

[61] S S Cheema, D Kwon, N Shanker, R Dos Reis, S L Hsu, J Xiao, H Zhang, R Wagner, A Datar, M R McCarter, C R Serrao, A K Yadav, G Karbasian, C H Hsu, A J Tan, L C Wang, V Thakare, X Zhang, A Mehta, E Karapetrova, R V Chopdekar, P Shafer, E Arenholz, C Hu, R Proksch, R Ramesh, J Ciston, S Salahuddin. Nature, 580, 478(2020).

[62] T S Böscke, J Müller, D Bräuhaus, U Schröder, U Böttger. Appl. Phys. Lett, 99(2011).

[63] S J Kim, D Narayan, J G Lee, J Mohan, J S Lee, J Lee, H S Kim, Y C Byun, A T Lucero, C D Young, S R Summerfelt, T San, L Colombo, J Kim. Appl. Phys. Lett, 111(2017).

[64] U Schroeder, M Materano, T Mittmann, P D Lomenzo, T Mikolajick, A Toriumi. Jpn. J. Appl. Phys, 58(2019).

[65] H Y Yoong, H Wu, J Zhao, H Wang, R Guo, J Xiao, B Zhang, P Yang, S J Pennycook, N Deng, X Yan, J Chen. Adv. Funct. Mater, 28(2018).

[66] B Mittermeier, A Dörfler, A Horoschenkoff, R Katoch, C Schindler, A Ruediger, G Kolhatkar. Adv. Intel. Syst, 1(2019).

[67] P W Blom, R M Wolf, J F Cillessen, M P Krijn. Phys. Rev. Lett, 73, 2107(1994).

[68] Z Hu, Q Li, M Li, Q Wang, Y Zhu, X Liu, X Zhao, Y Liu, S Dong. Appl. Phys. Lett, 102(2013).

[69] N Yang, Z Q Ren, C Z Hu, Z Guan, B B Tian, N Zhong, P H Xiang, C G Duan, J H Chu. Nanotechnology, 30(2019).

[70] S Wu, L Ren, F Yu, K Yang, M Yang, Y Wang, M Meng, W Zhou, S Li. Appl. Phys. A, 116, 1741(2014).

[71] A Q Jiang, C Wang, K J Jin, X B Liu, J F Scott, C S Hwang, T A Tang, H B Lu, G Z Yang. Adv. Mater, 23, 1277(2011).

[72] Z Chen, L He, F Zhang, J Jiang, J Meng, B Zhao, A Jiang. J. Appl. Phys, 113(2013).

[73] H Zhu, Y Zhang, A Jiang, Z Bai, S Feng, P Wang, X Meng, Q Qi. Appl. Phys. Lett, 109(2016).

[74] C Ge, K J Jin, C Wang, H B Lu, C Wang, G Z Yang. Appl. Phys. Lett, 99(2011).

[75] C Wang, K-j Jin, Z-t Xu, L Wang, C Ge, H-b Lu, H-z Guo, M He, G-z Yang. Appl. Phys. Lett, 98(2011).

[76] M X Jia, Z Q Ren, Y D Liu, Y Cheng, R Huang, P H Xiang, X D Tang, B B Tian, N Zhong, C G Duan. Appl. Phys. Lett, 114(2019).

[77] Z J Wang, Y Bai. Small, 15(2019).

[78] S M Yoon, E Tokumitsu, H Ishiwara. IEEE Electr. Device L, 20, 229(1999).

[79] Y Kaneko, Y Nishitani, M Ueda. IEEE T. Electr. Dev, 61, 2827(2014).

[80] M Jerry, P Chen, J Zhang, P Sharma, K Ni, S Yu, S Datta. IEEE International Electron Devices Meeting (IEDM), 6.2.1-6.2.4(2017).

[81] H Mulaosmanovic, J Ocker, S Müller, M Noack, J Müller, P Polakowski, T Mikolajick, S Slesazeck. Symposium on VLSI Technology, T176-T177(2017).

[82] M Seo, M H Kang, S B Jeon, H Bae, J Hur, B C Jang, S Yun, S Cho, W K Kim, M S Kim, K M Hwang, S Hong, S Y Choi, Y K Choi. IEEE Electr. Device Lett, 39, 1445(2018).

[83] M K Kim, J S Lee. Nano Lett, 19, 2044(2019).

[84] H Wang, Q Zhao, Z Ni, Q Li, H Liu, Y Yang, L Wang, Y Ran, Y Guo, W Hu, Y Liu. Adv. Mater, 30(2018).

[85] Y Chen, Y Zhou, F Zhuge, B Tian, M Yan, Y Li, Y He, X S Miao. npj 2D Mater. Appl, 3, 31(2019).

[86] L Xiong, Y Chen, J Yu, W Xiong, X Zhang, Y Zheng. Appl. Phys. Lett, 115(2019).

[87] Y Choi, J H Kim, C Qian, J Kang, M C Hersam, J H Park, J H Cho. ACS Appl. Mater. Inter, 12, 4707(2020).

[88] H Ishiwara. Jpn. J. Appl. Phys, 32, 442(1993).

[89] G Wu, B Tian, L Liu, W Lv, S Wu, X Wang, Y Chen, J Li, Z Wang, S Wu, H Shen, T Lin, P Zhou, Q Liu, C Duan, S Zhang, X Meng, S Wu, W Hu, X Wang, J Chu, J Wang. Nat. Electron, 3, 43(2020).

[90] X Wang, Y Chen, G Wu, J Wang, B Tian, S Sun, H Shen, T Lin, W Hu, T Kang, M Tang, Y Xiao, J Sun, X Meng, J Chu. Nanotechnology, 29(2018).

[91] N Tsutsumi, R Kosugi, K Kinashi, W Sakai. ACS Appl. Mater. Inter, 8(2016).

[92] Y Bai, Z J Wang, B He, J Z Cui, Z D Zhang. ACS Omega, 2, 9067(2017).

[93] X Liu, H Fan, J Shi, L Wang, H Du. RSC Adv, 6(2016).

[94] T Ali, P Polakowski, S Riedel, T Buttner, T Kampfe, M Rudolph, B Patzold, K Seidel, D Lohr, R Hoffmann, M Czernohorsky, K Kuhnel, P Steinke, J Calvo, K Zimmermann, J Muller. IEEE T. Electr. Dev, 65, 3769(2018).

[95] M J Highland, T T Fister, M I Richard, D D Fong, P H Fuoss, C Thompson, J A Eastman, S K Streiffer, G B Stephenson. Phys. Rev. Lett, 105(2010).

[96] H Mulaosmanovic, T Mikolajick, S Slesazeck. ACS Appl. Mater. Inter, 10(2018).

[97] M Kumar, D G Georgiadou, A Seitkhan, K Loganathan, E Yengel, H Faber, D Naphade, A Basu, T D Anthopoulos, K Asadi. Adv. Electron. Mater, 6(2020).

[98] X W Shen, Y W Fang, B B Tian, C G Duan. ACS Appl. Electron. Mater, 1, 1133(2019).

[99] H Shen, J Liu, K Chang, L Fu. Phys. Rev. Appl, 11(2019).

[100] F Xue, X He, J R D Retamal, A Han, J Zhang, Z Liu, J K Huang, W Hu, V Tung, J H He, L J Li, X Zhang. Adv. Mater, 31(2019).

[101] A Q Jiang, Y Zhang. NPG Asia Mater, 11(2019).

[102] P P Lu, J X Shen, D S Shang, Y Sun. ACS Appl. Mater. Inter, 12, 4673(2020).