
- Photonics Research
- Vol. 13, Issue 5, 1428 (2025)
Abstract
1. INTRODUCTION
Holographic optical elements have emerged as an important technology in modern photonics, significantly advancing various fields through their versatile applications [1,2]. Holographic optical element (HOE) waveguides are integral components in the development of augmented and virtual reality devices, facilitating the redirection of light to produce immersive, high-quality visual experiences [3–5]. Notably, products such as the Microsoft HoloLens [6] and Magic Leap One [7] utilize HOE waveguides to enhance user experiences. Additionally, HOE waveguides are under development for solar energy harvesting [8], aiming to improve the performance of photovoltaic cells through efficient sunlight guidance. Furthermore, in biomedical imaging, HOE waveguides can enhance the precision and clarity of diagnostic techniques by directing light within compact [9,10] intricate devices.
These applications illustrate the versatility of HOE waveguides in managing optical signals. Leveraging holographic principles, the design and fabrication of HOE waveguides allow for precise and diverse redirection of light, facilitating their integration into complex systems.
The capability of HOE waveguides to guide light effectively is well-documented [11–15], underscoring their importance. This proficient management of optical signals highlights their critical role in optimizing signal handling and system design across a wide range of advanced technological applications.
Sign up for Photonics Research TOC. Get the latest issue of Photonics Research delivered right to you!Sign up now
Research into HOE waveguides is driven not only by their diverse functionalities but also by their effective modeling and efficient fabrication [13,14,16]. Holography involves two main processes: recording and reconstruction. The recording process employs a photosensitive material with properties that can be photochemically altered under light exposure. Reconstruction occurs when the recorded HOE structure is illuminated with a light beam having a wavefront similar to the one used during recording. In the case of HOE waveguides, the reconstructed beam is produced at an angle that ensures it meets the material-air interface at or above the critical angle, causing the diffracted beam to undergo total internal reflection (TIR). By carefully selecting the reconstruction wavelength and considering the desired input and output angles, the characteristic spacing and orientation of the fringes for a waveguide can be determined.
These parameters, once established, allow for the determination of the recording conditions for an HOE waveguide, as detailed in Section 2.
Reports detailing a flexible recording process demonstrate how a grating can be recorded using one wavelength and operate as a coupler at a different wavelength, eliminating the need for complex and bulky optical alignments. This flexible recording process has been demonstrated using a 532 nm wavelength to identify the Bragg angles necessary for fabricating volume phase transmission holographic gratings. The gratings operate as waveguides in either the in-coupler or out-coupler regime when probed with a 632.8 nm wavelength [16]. Additionally, a detailed model for determining the recording angles required for the fabrication of HOE waveguides across a range of recording wavelengths was reported. This model has highlighted the potential of transmission gratings recorded at 532 nm for waveguiding at 632.8 nm, and reflection gratings recorded at 532 nm for waveguiding at 405 nm, with experimental verifications [13,17,18].
A similar approach to HOE waveguide design has been utilized in Refs. [19–21], where signal delivery and extraction from devices such as fluorescence-based sensing systems were investigated. In such systems, the delivery of an excitation signal and the extraction of subsequent fluorescence are critical. For instance, luminescence-based sensors use specific dyes that emit light when excited by a particular wavelength [19,20]. The intensity and wavelength of the emitted light can provide information about the environment or analyte being studied.
This study presents a design concept aligned with the demonstration in Fig. 1, representing a configuration that progresses toward wearable applications. The light from the LED source is directed by the HOE-guided signal to a photoluminescence sensor embedded in a culture chamber, positioned in direct contact with the sensing region, such as a wound site. The photoluminescent signal is then guided out of the system for characterization by a photon detector, facilitating the monitoring of quenched fluorescence, indicative of relevant parameters, such as oxygen levels.
Figure 1.Schematic of the wearable sensing system. LED light is directed into the photoluminescence sensor within the culture chamber (CC) that is in contact with the wound site. The photoluminescence signal is directed onto a photon detector (PD) for characterization.
To achieve this, a prototype sensing system was fabricated to evaluate the feasibility of the operational design. It comprises photopolymerizable hybrid sol-gel (PHSG)-based HOE slanted gratings serving as couplers and a sensing chamber embedded in a polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) layer. PDMS was selected for its compatibility with microfluidic system integration and its suitability for photoluminescence-based sensing within the embedded chamber. Additionally, its widespread use in microfluidic devices [22,23] and prominence in wearable applications made it a practical and accessible choice for this study, combining functional advantages with ease of implementation. The HOE couplers were recorded using a 476.5 nm laser, with the inter-beam angle set to achieve a spatial frequency of 1720 lines/mm. The sensor chamber was filled with a 630–660 nm absorbing methylene blue solution that is characterized by a peak fluorescence signal at 700 nm. An HOE, functioning as an in-coupler at 632.8 nm, guided the excitation signal into the sample chamber, while another HOE, operating as an out-coupler at 700 nm, extracted the fluorescence signal.
This is the first instance, to the authors’ knowledge, of fabricating couplers in the water- and thermally resistant, holographically capable PHSG material for photoluminescence-based sensing [21,24,25]. Compared to other holographic materials, PHSG provides a unique balance of optical performance and robustness. Most photopolymers offer flexibility and ease of processing but are often susceptible to moisture-induced degradation and lower long-term stability. Dichromated gelatin provides high diffraction efficiency but lacks environmental resilience. Silver halides exhibit excellent diffraction efficiency and long-term stability but require complex chemical processing. To ensure efficient performance of the HOE waveguiding system, several strategies were employed. Firstly, various recording energies (
2. MODEL AND DESIGN OF THE HOE WAVEGUIDE
A. Determination of the Waveguide Parameters
HOE coupler operation is defined by the gratings fringe orientation and fringe spacing. The fringe orientation should enable beam reconstruction in a direction at an angle equal to or greater than the angle required for TIR between two material boundaries, such as air and the photosensitive material. This angle,
Figure 2.Schematic of (a) an HOE waveguide designed to operate at 632.8 nm wavelength and (b) the model used for the determination of the recording angles in the optical setup using
These parameters are used to calculate the spatial frequency [Eq. (1)], defining the precise grating configuration necessary for the HOE to function optimally at the designated wavelength, input angle, and TIR angle, suited for the targeted application.
B. Determination of the Recording Geometry
Recording a transmission mode volume coupler at the operational wavelength of 632.8 nm is not feasible because interference cannot occur within the material’s volume. This is because a beam undergoing total internal reflection, when incident at an angle of 42° or greater, cannot penetrate the material boundary, as shown by the dotted
This approach enables the design of an HOE structure with the same fringe orientation and spacing as the one needed for the operational wavelength, while recording at a different wavelength, as demonstrated in Fig. 2(b). Finally, to adapt the model for practical use in an optical setup, Snell’s law was applied to determine the recording angles in air.
C. Modeling the Number of TIR Bounces
In applications where the incoming signal (1) experiences TIR at normal incidence, (2) propagates efficiently through the system, and ultimately (3) strikes the center of a light-interrogated region, the HOE design is important to overall system functionality. Understanding the optical path of the coupled signal within the material is important for optimizing the system operation. The number of reflections within the medium is directly influenced by the angle at which the light enters the layer and the mutual position of the HOE and the interrogated region.
This research focuses on a waveguide-assisted approach to photoluminescence-based sensing. For waveguide integration into a microfluidic chamber embedded into PDMS, device dimensions and grating parameters are critical for system operation. Compact dimensions are essential for device portability, packaging, and broader applicability. In this model, where the HOE substrate is a microscopic glass slide (1 mm thick) positioned atop the PDMS system (5 mm thick), a total height of 6 mm is considered. Both the HOE coupler and sensing chamber have a diameter of 10 mm. To evaluate the required system dimensions for accurate central illumination of the interrogated chamber, with minimal signal losses, a range of
In one version of the device, the culture chamber is placed in direct contact with the sensing site (wound), while the HOE is positioned on the opposite plane, enabling direct illumination without the need for any reflections. This configuration, however, limits the possibility of parallel interrogation by other techniques (e.g., phase contrast or fluorescence microscopy), as the HOE would need to be in close proximity to the interrogated region, thereby obstructing direct access to it. To avoid this limitation, we propose the HOE to be located at some distance from the sensing chamber. This distance will depend on whether the HOE and the sensing chamber are positioned on opposite sides of the PDMS layer (Fig. 1) or on the same side of the PDMS layer [Fig. 3(a)]. In the following analysis, both the HOE and the sensing chamber are placed on the same surface side. This arrangement was selected as proof-of-concept and for the ease of preparation in our lab. Consequently, only an odd number of total internal reflection (TIR) events occur before the excitation beam interacts with the sensor chamber.
Figure 3.(a) Diagram showing the relative positions of the HOE and sensor chamber; and (b) plot of the relationship of HOE in-coupler location, angles of incidence within the substrate at/or exceeding the critical angle for TIR (TIR angles), and
Even though PDMS is transparent in the visible range and losses from TIR are expected to be minimal, with increased propagation path of the beam an increased optical loss can be expected. This is mainly due to Rayleigh scattering, caused by any fluctuations of the density and the refractive index in the polymer material. Other sources that can be responsible for optical loss can be traced back to contaminating dust and pores from the fabrication process. Minimizing the number of TIR bounces reduces the propagation length and thus the optical losses and supports a more compact sensor design, which is particularly beneficial for integration into a patch-based framework. To balance these considerations, the modeling focused on configurations with either one or three TIR events, ensuring sufficient chamber excitation. The following equation was used to determine the required distance (
As shown in Fig. 3(b), angles of incidence within the substrate where
The distance between the HOE and the sensing region center can range from 1.18 to 3.27 cm for
In systems with an optical path of 1.18 cm (one TIR event), losses per bounce can be considered negligible. For longer optical paths and larger devices, modeling of these losses will include considering the sum of the absorption coefficient of the material and the scattering, which will increase with the number of TIR events occurring in the PDMS layer.
D. Design of HOE Waveguide Couplers
It has been demonstrated that HOE waveguides can be used for both in-coupling [13–17] and out-coupling signals [14,15] in an optical device as shown in Fig. 2(a). HOE couplers, like all volume phase transmission holographic structures, can reconstruct either of the light wavefronts used during the recording process. Generally, for in-coupling, the light beam with a predetermined wavelength is incident on the coupler at the operational input angle,
Figure 4.Schematic of (a) the HOE waveguide system, which provides double functionality as in- and out-coupling for the same
This section evaluates the feasibility of integrating an HOE for out-coupling to characterize a fluorescent signal in a PDMS system. Fluorescence emitted from the sensing chamber can be modeled as a point source signal. Our model shows that a point source, which emits light uniformly in all directions, naturally directs 27% of the light horizontally (left or right) based on TIR conditions and 23% vertically (upward or downward), as seen in Table 1. Assuming an intensity of
Area, Area Percentage, and Power for Light Traveling in Two Directions
Percentage of | Power | ||
---|---|---|---|
Total semi-circle | 180 | 50 | 0.39 |
TIR | 84 | 23 | 0.18 |
Without TIR | 96 | 27 | 0.21 |
Therefore, selecting the direction for light collection, whether from the top or side of the point source, does not differ significantly in efficiency. However, to enable future diagnostics of the chamber area, such as microscopic imaging, the top central region of the device is not preferred for out-coupling. To facilitate such signal collection, this study designs a waveguide to out-couple the incoming fluorescent wavelength at a known
The out-coupling waveguide can be fabricated by employing the method described in Section 2. For minimum disturbance of the recording setup the out-coupler has the same spatial frequency but a different slant angle. This is to ensure that the fluorescence signal at peak wavelength is incident to the out-coupler at the Bragg angle.
E. HOE Waveguide for Simultaneous Signal Guidance
To study the versatility of the HOEs as in- or out-couplers, waveguide multiplexing was employed, using both angular and peristrophic multiplexing to enable simultaneous signal guidance and detection. Multiplexing can provide HOE waveguide fabrication operating at the same
Peristrophic multiplexing was implemented by rotating the PHSG layer 90° around its normal. The already angularly multiplexed PHSG layer was rotated and again angularly multiplexed, resulting in four 632.8 nm waveguides stored in the material. Illuminating the multiplexed structure with a 632.8 nm beam at 90° incidence would achieve
3. MATERIALS AND METHODS
A. Photopolymerizable Glass Synthesis and Layer Preparation
The development process of the PHSG, as reported in previous research [15,28,29], is employed in this study. The four-stage process involves synthesizing the sol base and then adding modifiers to promote its transformation into the PHSG gel. The process initiates with (1) the complexation of zirconium (IV) propoxide (ZPO, 0.727 g) to zirconium complex (ZCO) in the presence of methacrylic acid (MAA, 0.135 g), and (2) the generation of a hybrid silicate matrix via the hydrolysis of 3-trimethoxysilylpropyl methacrylate (MAPTMS, 15 g) with 0.1 mol/L nitric acid (
In the subsequent step, this matrix is combined with the ZCO, which forms the sol base. The third step involves the dropwise addition of deionized water (1.088 g), facilitating further hydrolysis. In the final stage, gelation proceeds following the addition of photosensitizer bis(eta.5-2,4-cylcopentadien-1-yl)-bis(2,6-difluoro-3-(1H-pyrrol-1-yl)-phenyl) titanium (Omnirad 784, 0.05 g), a modifier (3-aminopropyl)triethoxysilane (APTES, 0.450 g), and solvent isopropanol (4 mL) into 10 g of the sol base. Following 10 h of stirring the photosensitive hybrid sol-gel synthesis is completed.
Fresh (0-day) PHSG sol was drop-casted onto a leveled glass slide (
B. PDMS Sensing Chamber Preparation
PDMS was prepared by combining a silicone elastomer base with a silicone elastomer curing agent in a ratio of 10:1. The mixture was then transferred into two 3D-printed molds and allowed to degas for 30 min. The PDMS filled molds, consisting of a lid with an input channel and a base with a chamber, were cured in the oven at 60°C for 1 h. After cooling, the PDMS lid and base were bonded together using liquid PDMS and returned to the oven for an additional 10 min. Following this step, the PDMS-embedded chamber was fully enclosed, with access available only through the channel [see Fig. 9(a) shown later]. The PDMS system dimensions are
0.013 mmol/L solution of methylene blue in deionized water was used. This solution filled the PDMS chamber. The optical density and relative fluorescence of the solution were characterized using the SpectraMax M3 multi-mode microplate reader. Finally, a 3D-printed attachment was used to clamp the filled chamber to the glass slide.
C. Recording Setup
Figure 5.Experimental setup for holographic recording of slanted transmission gratings using a 476.5 nm wavelength laser. S, sample holder; M, mirror; BS, beam splitter; VA, variable aperture; SF, spatial filter; and SH, shutter.
Development of the 632.8 nm waveguide also employed angular multiplexing, which involved two subsequent recordings of HOEs with
The optimum recording conditions for HOE coupler fabrication in PHSG were evaluated by recording at intensities of 2.5, 3, 5, 10, and
D. Layer Characterization
Real-time growth curves and Bragg selectivity curves were measured with an in-house-built computer supported setup and software (Pantera). The setup consisted of a rotational stage and an Arduino board (Arduino Nano Every) linked photodiode (SLCD-61N5) measuring the intensity of a 632.8 nm transmitted beam. For Bragg selectivity curves the transmitted intensity was measured as the grating rotated through the Bragg angle. The Pantera software displays the transmitted intensity, which is then used to calculate the DE using the following equation:
The spectral characterization of the waveguides was performed by probing with a halogen light (AvaLight-HAL-S) and fiber-coupling the signal into the FLAMT-T-VIS-NIS- ES USB powered spectrometer for real-time visualization with the OceanView software.
4. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
A. Recording Conditions
Firstly, the impact of recording exposure energy on the DE of slanted volume transmission gratings for use as holographic couplers was examined. Figure 6 demonstrates the average DE achieved at each recording condition for gratings recorded using two different exposure times (20 and 60 s) and varying intensities (2.5, 3, 5, 10, and 12.5 mW/cm). Under the studied recording conditions (
Figure 6.Average DE versus intensity for varying recording energies (
B. Holographic Waveguides in Fluorescence Excitation and Detection
The absorbance and fluorescence of the 0.013 mmol/L methylene blue water-based solution have been characterized as described in Section 3.B. Figure 7(a) reveals that the dye solution exhibits two absorption peaks at 633 nm and 660 nm. Upon excitation at 633 nm, the subsequent fluorescence observed at 700 nm is depicted in Fig. 7(b).
Figure 7.(a) Optical density spectrum of the 0.013 mmol/L methylene blue solution and (b) relative fluorescence spectrum of the excited solution.
This data was used to design the 632.8 nm in-coupler and the 700 nm out-coupler as detailed in Table 2. Consequently, the in-coupling HOE was designed to operate at 632.8 nm, at normal incidence and
The conditions employed allow the recording of a 632.8 nm waveguide and a 700 nm waveguide, both satisfying approximately 56° angle difference between interfering beams. This arrangement allows to produce gratings of the same spatial frequency. Fringe orientation as shown in Fig. 4(a) and an increased slant angle (Table 2) will result in the structure operating as a 700 nm out-coupler.
Bragg selectivity curves of the couplers were obtained using a 405 nm laser probe to verify the recorded structures. As shown in Fig. 8, the 632.8 nm coupler, when probed with a 632.8 nm beam at normal incidence, exhibits coupling with a single peak in the transmitted order. When probed with a 405 nm laser, the grating reconstructs two diffraction orders at
Figure 8.Bragg selectivity curves of the 632.8 nm and 700 nm couplers obtained with a 632.8 nm and 405 nm probe.
Figure 9(a) shows the integration of the PDMS fluorescence chamber onto a glass substrate. Due to the refractive index mismatch between glass (
Figure 9(b) demonstrates the performance of the system developed. The 632.8 nm laser beam is incident on the in-coupler, which excites the methylene blue in the chamber, and its fluorescence is guided out of the system by the out-coupler.
By situating an optical fiber attached to a spectrometer perpendicular (90°) to the 700 nm out-coupler, the signal was detected and characterized. The successful guidance of the 632.8 nm signal into the chamber and the extraction of the fluorescent signal are evidenced by the intensity versus wavelength graph shown in Fig. 9(c). This system showcases the capability of the PHSG HOE in- and out-couplers to guide a sufficient signal for the device operation and its characterization.
To evaluate the feasibility of using a flexible substrate for in-contact wearable sensing applications, such as a patch-based framework, a polycarbonate film (Bayer Makrofol DE 1-1 CC, 500 μm) was employed. Similar to the glass substrate samples, 0.50 mL of the PHSG solution was drop-cast onto the polycarbonate film and then dried in the oven. The preliminary results, as shown in Fig. 10(a), demonstrate the samples’ functionality in combination with a PDMS film, highlighting the PHSG coupler’s ability to reliably operate even when slightly deformed or curved, thus showcasing its potential for flexible and wearable sensor applications. Future work will explore the direct deposition of sol-gel onto PDMS, eliminating the use of an intermediate glass substrate and streamlining the fabrication process.
Figure 9.(a) PDMS microfluidic system with methylene blue dye solution attached to glass; (b) excitation of the dye chamber with a 632.8 nm in-coupler and 700 nm out-coupler; (c) spectrum of the in-coupled (excitation) signal and the out-coupled (fluorescent dye solution) signal from the system.
Figure 10.(a) Image of the PHSG polycarbonate waveguide coupling a 632.8 nm signal while in a slightly curved configuration; (b) Bragg selectivity curve of a sample with two multiplexed 632.8 nm couplers and the multiplexed sample probed at normal incidence with (c) a 632.8 nm beam and (d) a white light source.
C. Holographic Waveguide Multiplexing
For simultaneous signal delivery and extraction, such as measuring analyte concentration at multiple sites, PHSG waveguide multiplexing can be employed. This sensing system would be capable of sensing a larger area, enabling more comprehensive and accurate monitoring of a region. Additionally, it could enable real-time mapping of analyte concentrations at specific sites, thereby enhancing the precision and effectiveness of a sensing system. The possibility of waveguide PHSG multiplexing for the same operational wavelength and input angle was investigated. Angular multiplexing was employed to change the fringe orientation while maintaining the same spatial frequency and slant angle.
Two couplers were multiplexed, with one HOE recorded at a
Figure 10(c) visualizes the simultaneous coupling of a 632.8 nm beam incident at 90° by the two multiplexed waveguides. Similarly, optical filtering capabilities of the HOE waveguide system for operation with a 632.8 nm beam at normal incidence are demonstrated in Fig. 10(d) where the incident beam is a broad-spectrum white light.
Additionally, the HOE structure was tested using two approaches. In Fig. 11(a), white light was coupled along the sample axis, with the 632.8 nm wavelength out-coupled at 90°. In Figs. 11(b) and 11(c), the white light illuminated the HOE externally, demonstrating its function as a classical transmissive element. Adjusting the input angle allowed different wavelengths to satisfy the Bragg condition.
Figure 11.(a)–(c) Meeting the Bragg condition for different wavelengths (1) to (3) for the same multiplexed sample and (d) verifying the output wavelengths by spectral measurements.
The spectrum of the out-coupled signal, detailing the specific wavelengths achieved at different incidence angles, was obtained, and is presented in Fig. 11(d). It is worth noting that a very narrow part of the spectrum is selected, with an average full width at half maximum of 1.46 nm. If a highly divergent light source was employed, the need to satisfy the Bragg condition and a range of
The study also explored peristrophic multiplexing within the PHSG layer. Initially, angular multiplexing was employed to record two 632.8 nm waveguides, functioning as both in- and out-couplers within a single plane. The layer was then rotated by 90°, and the same angular separation was used to record an additional set of two 632.8 nm waveguides (in- and out-couplers). This process effectively resulted in the development of four operational 632.8 nm waveguides within the same PHSG layer, currently achieving diffraction efficiency of 20% per grating.
Upon illumination, for the same incidence angle,
Figure 12.HOE waveguide system of four waveguides is probed with a 632.8 nm beam at normal incidence and achieving
5. CONCLUSION
This study demonstrated for the first time the effective design, fabrication, and integration of HOE waveguides in a photopolymerizable hybrid sol-gel matrix. The successful recording of 632.8 nm and 700 nm in- and out-coupler regime waveguides using a single 476.5 nm optical arrangement further highlights the robustness and versatility of the HOE waveguide model employed.
The integration of these waveguides into a PDMS microfluidic system for the first time effectively guided excitation light at 632.8 nm and extracted fluorescence signal with a peak wavelength at 700 nm, showcasing their potential for application in wearable fluorescence-based sensing and diagnostics. Additionally, the study’s exploration of waveguide multiplexing in PHSG enabled simultaneous management of multiple optical signals operating at the same wavelength and incident angle. These advancements in efficient fabrication, high and reliable DE, and versatile signal management underscore the potential of PHSG-based HOE waveguides to enhance photonic device performance across a spectrum of applications.
Future work focuses on validating this system under application-relevant conditions, such as wound-like environments that simulate analyte concentration gradients and temperature variations at the sensing site for photoluminescence-based sensing. The studies will evaluate the device’s robustness, response time, and accuracy, offering critical insights into its performance for wearable sensing applications and will be published elsewhere. To further enhance functionality, multiplexing strategies will be explored, including the integration of HOE waveguides operating at different wavelengths for a fixed incident angle, as well as the combination of waveguides functioning in both transmission and reflection modes under the same incidence. These advancements aim to improve sensitivity, selectivity, and adaptability, supporting the development of a more versatile sensing platform.
Acknowledgment
Acknowledgment. The authors gratefully acknowledge the FOCAS Research Institute for providing access to facilities, equipment, and technical assistance. Additionally, they extend their appreciation to colleagues at TU Dublin for their valuable discussions and insights. Javier Arguelles Lopez is acknowledged for the design and development of the data acquisition system and Pantera software used in this study.
References
[1] J. T. Sheridan, R. K. Kostuk, A. F. Gil. Roadmap on holography. J. Opt., 22, 123002(2020).
[15] P. Stoeva, T. Mikulchyk, B. Rogers. Development of holographic optical elements for use in wound monitoring. Proc. SPIE, 12574, 1257406(2023).

Set citation alerts for the article
Please enter your email address