• Chinese Optics Letters
  • Vol. 19, Issue 2, 021101 (2021)
Wei Fang1、*, Kui Yang2, and Haiyuan Li1
Author Affiliations
  • 1School of Automation, Beijing University of Posts and Telecommunications, Beijing 100876, China
  • 2School of Instrumentation Science and Opto-electronics Engineering, Beihang University, Beijing 100191, China
  • show less
    DOI: 10.3788/COL202119.021101 Cite this Article Set citation alerts
    Wei Fang, Kui Yang, Haiyuan Li. Propagation-based incremental triangulation for multiple views 3D reconstruction[J]. Chinese Optics Letters, 2021, 19(2): 021101 Copy Citation Text show less
    Geometric indication of multi-view triangulation.
    Fig. 1. Geometric indication of multi-view triangulation.
    Four types of synthetic triangulation instances. (a) Type A: cameras and 3D points are randomly distributed; (b) Type B: the camera moves along a curved trajectory around 3D points; (c) Type C: the camera moves on a circle while 3D points are located at the center; (d) Type D: the camera moves along a curved trajectory towards the 3D scene.
    Fig. 2. Four types of synthetic triangulation instances. (a) Type A: cameras and 3D points are randomly distributed; (b) Type B: the camera moves along a curved trajectory around 3D points; (c) Type C: the camera moves on a circle while 3D points are located at the center; (d) Type D: the camera moves along a curved trajectory towards the 3D scene.
    Time and accuracy analysis with different noise levels on Type D synthetic data. (a), (b), and (c) are the results of the time, 3D error, and 2D error when the Gaussian covariance is set as 2 pixels; (d), (e), and (f) are the results of the time, 3D error, and 2D error when the Gaussian covariance is set as 5 pixels; (g), (h), and (i) are the results of the time, 3D error, and 2D error when the Gaussian covariance is set as 8 pixels.
    Fig. 3. Time and accuracy analysis with different noise levels on Type D synthetic data. (a), (b), and (c) are the results of the time, 3D error, and 2D error when the Gaussian covariance is set as 2 pixels; (d), (e), and (f) are the results of the time, 3D error, and 2D error when the Gaussian covariance is set as 5 pixels; (g), (h), and (i) are the results of the time, 3D error, and 2D error when the Gaussian covariance is set as 8 pixels.
    Overall convergence of INT with different datasets. (a) Convergence curve of Type A dataset; (b) convergence curve of Type B dataset; (c) convergence curve of Type C dataset; (d) convergence curve of Type D dataset.
    Fig. 4. Overall convergence of INT with different datasets. (a) Convergence curve of Type A dataset; (b) convergence curve of Type B dataset; (c) convergence curve of Type C dataset; (d) convergence curve of Type D dataset.
    INT based on real datasets. (a) Lund Cathedral, (b) Orebro Castle, (c) Ystad Monestary, and (d) Skansen Kronan.
    Fig. 5. INT based on real datasets. (a) Lund Cathedral, (b) Orebro Castle, (c) Ystad Monestary, and (d) Skansen Kronan.
    MethodType AType BType C
    Time (s)3D Error (m)2D Error (pixels)Time (s)3D Error (m)2D Error (pixels)Time (s)3D Error (m)2D Error (pixels)
    MVMP1.060.01925.11152.450.03525.04932.140.02924.9511
    IRMP4.010.01394.769811.760.03034.96358.410.02514.8888
    INT0.680.01464.79550.910.03124.96491.080.02584.8901
    ININT0.980.01454.79361.450.03074.95371.620.02524.8895
    NN6.510.01394.769822.600.03034.963514.070.02514.8888
    GMRE7.080.01244.705922.100.02724.962115.610.02374.8680
    Table 1. Comparisons between Different Incremental Triangulation Performances
    DataTotal Runtime (s)Last Mean 3D Error
    MVMPIRMPINTININTNNGMREMVMPIRMPINTININTNNGMRE
    E113.40941.01125.16204.961477.411386.460.01480.01310.01390.01340.01310.0124
    F110.15749.1663.84110.931187.041195.770.00200.00100.00140.00110.00100.0002
    G97.99469.1183.55138.63797.93665.380.00770.00720.00750.00720.00720.0067
    H23.29206.4021.2435.97295.81246.670.00180.00090.00120.00100.00090.0004
    Table 2. Runtime Comparisons of Different Methods with Real Datasetsa
    Wei Fang, Kui Yang, Haiyuan Li. Propagation-based incremental triangulation for multiple views 3D reconstruction[J]. Chinese Optics Letters, 2021, 19(2): 021101
    Download Citation