• Acta Physica Sinica
  • Vol. 68, Issue 22, 227101-1 (2019)
Shan-Shan Wang1、*, Wei-Kang Wu2, and Sheng-Yuan Yang2
Author Affiliations
  • 1School of Physics, Southeast University, Nanjing 211189, China
  • 2Research Laboratory for Quantum Materials, Singapore University of Technology and Design, Singapore 487372, Singapore
  • show less
    DOI: 10.7498/aps.68.20191538 Cite this Article
    Shan-Shan Wang, Wei-Kang Wu, Sheng-Yuan Yang. Progress on topological nodal line and nodal surface[J]. Acta Physica Sinica, 2019, 68(22): 227101-1 Copy Citation Text show less
    A schematic figure for the topological boundary state in a topological insulator.关于拓扑绝缘体中拓扑边缘态的简单图像
    Fig. 1. A schematic figure for the topological boundary state in a topological insulator.关于拓扑绝缘体中拓扑边缘态的简单图像
    Schematic figure of a nodal loop: (a) Nodal loop formed by two crossing bands; (b) the Berry phase of a closed path circling the nodal loop (green circle) is π[61].节线的示意图 (a)由两条能带交叉所形成的节线; (b)绿色的环代表节线, 是环绕节线一个路径, 沿着走一圈的贝利相为π[61]
    Fig. 2. Schematic figure of a nodal loop: (a) Nodal loop formed by two crossing bands; (b) the Berry phase of a closed path circling the nodal loop (green circle) is π[61]. 节线的示意图 (a)由两条能带交叉所形成的节线; (b)绿色的环代表节线, 是环绕节线一个路径, 沿着 走一圈的贝利相为π[61]
    Chiral symmetry protected nodal line in a Dirac superconductor: (a) A Dirac node can evolve into a nodal ring or two Weyl nodes under different symmetry breaking; (b)−(d) illustrate the different topological protection for the degeneracies in (a). Here, the nodal ring is protected by the winding number[51].在狄拉克超导体中出现的由手征对称性保护的节线 (a)当空间反演或者时间反演破坏时, 一个狄拉克点会变为一个节环或两个外尔点; (b)−(d)刻画了(a)中几种简并点的拓扑保护机制, 其中节环是由拓扑绕数所保护[51]
    Fig. 3. Chiral symmetry protected nodal line in a Dirac superconductor: (a) A Dirac node can evolve into a nodal ring or two Weyl nodes under different symmetry breaking; (b)−(d) illustrate the different topological protection for the degeneracies in (a). Here, the nodal ring is protected by the winding number[51]. 在狄拉克超导体中出现的由手征对称性保护的节线 (a)当空间反演或者时间反演破坏时, 一个狄拉克点会变为一个节环或两个外尔点; (b)−(d)刻画了(a)中几种简并点的拓扑保护机制, 其中节环是由拓扑绕数所保护[51]
    Nodal lines found in three carbon allotropes: (a) 3D carbon with Mackay-Terrones crystal structur[52]; (b) 3D hyperhoneycomb carbon[53]; (c) 3D graphene network structure[56].在三种碳材料中发现的节线 (a) Mackay-Terrones结构的三维碳和节线在动量空间的表示[52]; (b) hyperhoneycomb结构的三维碳和节线在动量空间的表示[53]; (c)三维的石墨烯网络结构和节线在动量空间的表示[56]
    Fig. 4. Nodal lines found in three carbon allotropes: (a) 3D carbon with Mackay-Terrones crystal structur[52]; (b) 3D hyperhoneycomb carbon[53]; (c) 3D graphene network structure[56]. 在三种碳材料中发现的节线 (a) Mackay-Terrones结构的三维碳和节线在动量空间的表示[52]; (b) hyperhoneycomb结构的三维碳和节线在动量空间的表示[53]; (c)三维的石墨烯网络结构和节线在动量空间的表示[56]
    Nodal line protected by the glide mirror symmetry: (a) Shows the glide-mirror-invariant plane in Brillouin zone, O and X are two TRIM points with different glide mirror eigenvalues; (b) shows the band structure along a path L connecting O and X (as in (a)); it displays an hourglass shaped spectrum. The degeneracy point P in the hourglass traces out a nodal loop in the glide mirror plane.滑移镜面所保护的节线 (a) O和X是滑移镜面上对应两个不同配对类型的TRIM点; (b)展示了沿着连接O和X的一条路径L上的能带特征, 这里每四条能带都会形成一种沙漏形的结构; 沙漏脖子处的交叉点P在滑移镜面上会形成一条节线
    Fig. 5. Nodal line protected by the glide mirror symmetry: (a) Shows the glide-mirror-invariant plane in Brillouin zone, O and X are two TRIM points with different glide mirror eigenvalues; (b) shows the band structure along a path L connecting O and X (as in (a)); it displays an hourglass shaped spectrum. The degeneracy point P in the hourglass traces out a nodal loop in the glide mirror plane. 滑移镜面所保护的节线 (a) OX是滑移镜面上对应两个不同配对类型的TRIM点; (b)展示了沿着连接OX的一条路径L上的能带特征, 这里每四条能带都会形成一种沙漏形的结构; 沙漏脖子处的交叉点P在滑移镜面上会形成一条节线
    Material examples with glide-mirror-protected nodal rings: (a) ReO2[73]; (b) X3SiTe6(X = Ta, Nb)[74], the hourglass dispersions can be observed in their band structures.具有滑移镜面所保护的节线的例子 (a) ReO2的晶体结构和能带结构, 可以看到高对称线上的沙漏型色散[73]; (b) X3SiTe6(X = Ta, Nb)的晶体结构和能带结构, 以及在高对称线上的沙漏型能量色散[74]
    Fig. 6. Material examples with glide-mirror-protected nodal rings: (a) ReO2[73]; (b) X3SiTe6(X = Ta, Nb)[74], the hourglass dispersions can be observed in their band structures. 具有滑移镜面所保护的节线的例子 (a) ReO2的晶体结构和能带结构, 可以看到高对称线上的沙漏型色散[73]; (b) X3SiTe6(X = Ta, Nb)的晶体结构和能带结构, 以及在高对称线上的沙漏型能量色散[74]
    Three types of nodal lines classified by the energy dispersion: (a) Type-I nodal line; (b) type-II nodal lines; (c) hybrid nodal lines; (d)−(f) show the typical shapes of the constant energy surface for the three types[64].三种不同色散类型的节线 (a) type-I节线; (b) type-II节线; (c) hybird节线; (d)−(f)三种节线的等能面[64]
    Fig. 7. Three types of nodal lines classified by the energy dispersion: (a) Type-I nodal line; (b) type-II nodal lines; (c) hybrid nodal lines; (d)−(f) show the typical shapes of the constant energy surface for the three types[64]. 三种不同色散类型的节线 (a) type-I节线; (b) type-II节线; (c) hybird节线; (d)−(f)三种节线的等能面[64]
    Unique properties of type-II and hybrid nodal lines: (a) Comparison between type-I and type-II nodal lines in terms of JDOS and optical absorption rate[61]; (b) the magnetic breakdown and its feature in anisotropic magnetic oscillation for a hybrid nodal loop[64].Type-II节线和hybrid节线的特殊物理性质 (a) Type-II节线和type-I节线的光学性质的比较[61]; (b) hybrid节线导致的磁坍塌效应和磁振荡中的各向异性[64]
    Fig. 8. Unique properties of type-II and hybrid nodal lines: (a) Comparison between type-I and type-II nodal lines in terms of JDOS and optical absorption rate[61]; (b) the magnetic breakdown and its feature in anisotropic magnetic oscillation for a hybrid nodal loop[64]. Type-II节线和hybrid节线的特殊物理性质 (a) Type-II节线和type-I节线的光学性质的比较[61]; (b) hybrid节线导致的磁坍塌效应和磁振荡中的各向异性[64]
    (a) Schematic figure for the higher order nodal lines; (b)−(d) show the quadratic nodal line in ZrPtGa: (c) the band structure of ZrPtGa, the blue solid curve indicates the quadratic nodal line; (d) shows the band dispersion in the plane perpendicular toΓ-A, which clearly demonstrates a quadratic dispersion[83].(a)按照节线的色散次数进行分类的示意图; (b)−(d)展示了一个具有二次节线的材料ZrPtGa, (c)是ZrPtGa的能带结构, 蓝色实线标记了二次节线, (d)是这个节线在垂直于Γ-A的平面上的色散, 可以清楚地看到是二次色散[83]
    Fig. 9. (a) Schematic figure for the higher order nodal lines; (b)−(d) show the quadratic nodal line in ZrPtGa: (c) the band structure of ZrPtGa, the blue solid curve indicates the quadratic nodal line; (d) shows the band dispersion in the plane perpendicular toΓ-A, which clearly demonstrates a quadratic dispersion[83]. (a)按照节线的色散次数进行分类的示意图; (b)−(d)展示了一个具有二次节线的材料ZrPtGa, (c)是ZrPtGa的能带结构, 蓝色实线标记了二次节线, (d)是这个节线在垂直于Γ-A的平面上的色散, 可以清楚地看到是二次色散[83]
    Nodal lines with different kinds of distribution in Brillouin zone: (a) Nodal lines in a carbon allotrope, which traverse the Brillouin zone[56]; (b) nodal line in CuTeO3, which is located around a point in Brillouin zone[69].具有不同形态的节线 (a)穿越布里渊区的一对节线[56]; (b)局域在布里渊区某个点周围的节线[69]
    Fig. 10. Nodal lines with different kinds of distribution in Brillouin zone: (a) Nodal lines in a carbon allotrope, which traverse the Brillouin zone[56]; (b) nodal line in CuTeO3, which is located around a point in Brillouin zone[69]. 具有不同形态的节线 (a)穿越布里渊区的一对节线[56]; (b)局域在布里渊区某个点周围的节线[69]
    Different structures formed by nodal lines: (a) Crossed nodal rings[38]; (b) nodal box[89]; (c) inter-connected nodal loops[90]; (d) nodal Hopf link[91]; (e) weyl chain; (f) dirac chain[73].节环可以形成的一些复杂结构 (a)笼子状的结构[38]; (b)骨架状的结构[89];(c)三能带形成的结状节线[90]; (d) Hopf链环[91]; (e)外尔链; (f)狄拉克链[73]
    Fig. 11. Different structures formed by nodal lines: (a) Crossed nodal rings[38]; (b) nodal box[89]; (c) inter-connected nodal loops[90]; (d) nodal Hopf link[91]; (e) weyl chain; (f) dirac chain[73]. 节环可以形成的一些复杂结构 (a)笼子状的结构[38]; (b)骨架状的结构[89];(c)三能带形成的结状节线[90]; (d) Hopf链环[91]; (e)外尔链; (f)狄拉克链[73]
    Stable nodal lines under SOC in 2D: (a)−(c) GaTeI family materials[94]; (d)−(f) MnN monolayer, here MnN is a half metal, so the nodal loops are fully spin[85].二维材料中在SOC作用下仍然稳定的节线 (a)−(c)二维GaTeI中的节线[94]; (d)−(f)单层MnN中的节线, 单层MnN是一个铁磁材料, 在费米面处只存在一个自旋通道, 因此这里的节线是完全自旋极化的[85]
    Fig. 12. Stable nodal lines under SOC in 2D: (a)−(c) GaTeI family materials[94]; (d)−(f) MnN monolayer, here MnN is a half metal, so the nodal loops are fully spin[85]. 二维材料中在SOC作用下仍然稳定的节线 (a)−(c)二维GaTeI中的节线[94]; (d)−(f)单层MnN中的节线, 单层MnN是一个铁磁材料, 在费米面处只存在一个自旋通道, 因此这里的节线是完全自旋极化的[85]
    Surface states of nodal line metals: (a) Drumhead surface states for nodal rings in superconductors[51]; (b) drumhead surface states in a 3D carbon allotrope[52]; (c), (d) show the double drumhead surface states in ReO2[73]and Ta3SiTe6[74]; (e) surface states of cubic nodal line, which spreads over the whole BZ[83].节线对应的拓扑表面态 (a)狄拉克超导体中节线导致的鼓膜态[51]; (b)碳的同素异形体中的鼓膜态[52]; (c), (d) ReO2[73]和Ta3SiTe6[74]中的双鼓膜态; (e)对应着三次节线的遍布布里渊区的环面表面态[83]
    Fig. 13. Surface states of nodal line metals: (a) Drumhead surface states for nodal rings in superconductors[51]; (b) drumhead surface states in a 3D carbon allotrope[52]; (c), (d) show the double drumhead surface states in ReO2[73]and Ta3SiTe6[74]; (e) surface states of cubic nodal line, which spreads over the whole BZ[83]. 节线对应的拓扑表面态 (a)狄拉克超导体中节线导致的鼓膜态[51]; (b)碳的同素异形体中的鼓膜态[52]; (c), (d) ReO2[73]和Ta3SiTe6[74]中的双鼓膜态; (e)对应着三次节线的遍布布里渊区的环面表面态[83]
    Two kinds of nodal surfaces: (a) Nodal surfaces in a 3D carbon allotrope[63]; (b) nodal surface in BaMX3[60].两种不同的节面 (a)三维碳材料中的节面[63]; (b) BaMX3中的节面[60]
    Fig. 14. Two kinds of nodal surfaces: (a) Nodal surfaces in a 3D carbon allotrope[63]; (b) nodal surface in BaMX3[60]. 两种不同的节面 (a)三维碳材料中的节面[63]; (b) BaMX3中的节面[60]
    Materials with Class-II nodal surfaces: (a) K6YO4; (b) TlMo3Te3[63].具有第二类节面的材料 (a) K6YO4; (b) TlMo3Te3[63]
    Fig. 15. Materials with Class-II nodal surfaces: (a) K6YO4; (b) TlMo3Te3[63]. 具有第二类节面的材料 (a) K6YO4; (b) TlMo3Te3[63]
    Nodal surface robust against SOC: (a) Crystal structure of Ta3TeI7; (b) is the band structure of Ta3TeI7 in the presence of SOC with no gap opening[63].SOC作用下稳定的节面 (a)展示了Ta3TeI7晶体结构; (b)是Ta3TeI7在考虑SOC时的能带结构; 能带在考虑SOC时没有打开能隙[63]
    Fig. 16. Nodal surface robust against SOC: (a) Crystal structure of Ta3TeI7; (b) is the band structure of Ta3TeI7 in the presence of SOC with no gap opening[63]. SOC作用下稳定的节面 (a)展示了Ta3TeI7晶体结构; (b)是Ta3TeI7在考虑SOC时的能带结构; 能带在考虑SOC时没有打开能隙[63]
    Nodal surface in magnetic materials: (a) The crystal structure of CsCrI3; (b) the band structure of CsCrI3 without SOC; (c) and (d) band structures with magnetic moment along x and z directions respectively[63].磁性材料中的节面 (a) CsCrI3晶体结构; (b)不考虑SOC时的能带结构; (c), (d)考虑SOC时, 磁矩分别沿面内和面外时的能带结构[63]
    Fig. 17. Nodal surface in magnetic materials: (a) The crystal structure of CsCrI3; (b) the band structure of CsCrI3 without SOC; (c) and (d) band structures with magnetic moment along x and z directions respectively[63]. 磁性材料中的节面 (a) CsCrI3晶体结构; (b)不考虑SOC时的能带结构; (c), (d)考虑SOC时, 磁矩分别沿面内和面外时的能带结构[63]
    Materials with multiple nodal surfaces: (a) Cu3Se2; (b) Rb2Se5. The location of the nodal surfaces is indicated by the orange color[63].存在多个节面的材料 (a) Cu3Se2; (b) Rb2Se5; 布里渊区中的节面分布用橙色标记[63]
    Fig. 18. Materials with multiple nodal surfaces: (a) Cu3Se2; (b) Rb2Se5. The location of the nodal surfaces is indicated by the orange color[63]. 存在多个节面的材料 (a) Cu3Se2; (b) Rb2Se5; 布里渊区中的节面分布用橙色标记[63]
    A method to circumvent the Nielson-Ninomiya no-go theorem: (a) Schematic figure showing the single Weyl point; (b) Berry curvature distribution; (c), (d) show that there is no surface Fermi arc emitted from the Weyl point, the white dot labels the surface projection of the Weyl point[117].绕过Nielson-Ninomiya不可行定理的方法 (a)一个单独外尔点的示意图; (b)贝利曲率分布; (c), (d)显示了在表面上不存在连接单外尔点的费米弧表面, 白色点标记了体内外尔点在表面的投影[117]
    Fig. 19. A method to circumvent the Nielson-Ninomiya no-go theorem: (a) Schematic figure showing the single Weyl point; (b) Berry curvature distribution; (c), (d) show that there is no surface Fermi arc emitted from the Weyl point, the white dot labels the surface projection of the Weyl point[117]. 绕过Nielson-Ninomiya不可行定理的方法 (a)一个单独外尔点的示意图; (b)贝利曲率分布; (c), (d)显示了在表面上不存在连接单外尔点的费米弧表面, 白色点标记了体内外尔点在表面的投影[117]
    Shan-Shan Wang, Wei-Kang Wu, Sheng-Yuan Yang. Progress on topological nodal line and nodal surface[J]. Acta Physica Sinica, 2019, 68(22): 227101-1
    Download Citation