Topochemical reactions are a promising method to obtain crystalline polymeric materials with distance-determined regio- or stereoselectivity. It has been concluded on an empirical basis that the closest intermolecular C⋯C distance in crystals of alkynes, d_(C⋯C)min, should reach a threshold of ∼3 Å for bonding to occur at room temperature. To understand this empirical threshold, we study here the polymerization of acetylene in the crystalline state under high pressure by calculating the structural geometry, vibrational modes, and reaction profile. We find d_(C⋯C)min to be the sum of an intrinsic threshold of 2.3 Å and a thermal displacement of 0.8 Å (at room temperature). Molecules at the empirical threshold move via several phonon modes to reach the intrinsic threshold, at which the intermolecular electronic interaction is sharply enhanced and bonding commences. A distance–vibration-based reaction picture is thus demonstrated, which provides a basis for the prediction and design of topochemical reactions, as well as an enhanced understanding of the bonding process in solids.