• Journal of Geographical Sciences
  • Vol. 30, Issue 8, 1266 (2020)
Chao YE, Simeng LI, Zhao ZHANG*, and Xiaodan ZHU
Author Affiliations
  • Key Laboratory of Geographic Information Science (Ministry of Education), School of Geographic Sciences, East China Normal University, Shanghai 200241, China
  • show less
    DOI: 10.1007/s11442-020-1781-0 Cite this Article
    Chao YE, Simeng LI, Zhao ZHANG, Xiaodan ZHU. A comparison and case analysis between domestic and overseas industrial parks of China since the Belt and Road Initiative[J]. Journal of Geographical Sciences, 2020, 30(8): 1266 Copy Citation Text show less
    Type evolution of national-level industrial parks at home and abroad (China) Note: The circle position on the timeline represents its earliest year of establishment; the circle size refers to the total number of parks of this type. The colors of blue and red mean “domestic” and “overseas” respectively.
    Fig. 1. Type evolution of national-level industrial parks at home and abroad (China) Note: The circle position on the timeline represents its earliest year of establishment; the circle size refers to the total number of parks of this type. The colors of blue and red mean “domestic” and “overseas” respectively.
    Temporal evolution of national-level COCZs along the B&R and domestic industrial parks of ChinaSource: Directory of Audit Bulletins of Chinese Development Zones (2018 Edition) (http://www.ndrc.gov.cn/ gzdt/201803/t20180302_878800.html); the Ministry of Commerce of the People's Republic of China (http://fec.mofcom. gov.cn/article/jwjmhzq/article01. shtml)
    Fig. 2. Temporal evolution of national-level COCZs along the B&R and domestic industrial parks of ChinaSource: Directory of Audit Bulletins of Chinese Development Zones (2018 Edition) (http://www.ndrc.gov.cn/ gzdt/201803/t20180302_878800.html); the Ministry of Commerce of the People's Republic of China (http://fec.mofcom. gov.cn/article/jwjmhzq/article01. shtml)
    The overseas national-level COCZs and their connections with domestic cities in China Note: CHBETCZ (China-Hungary Boside Economic and Trade Cooperation Zone), HSETLCZ (Hungary Sino-European Trade and Logistics Cooperation Zone), CESETCZ (China-Egypt Suez Economic and Trade Cooperation Zone), EEIZ (Ethiopian Eastern Industry Zone), CNETCZ (China-Nigeria Economic and Trade Cooperation Zone), ZCETCZ (Zambia-China Economic and Trade Cooperation Zone), CUPSIA (China-Uzbekistan Peng Sheng Industrial Area), KASAICZ (Kyrgyzstan Asia Star Agricultural Industry Cooperation Zone), PHREZ (Pakistan Haier-Ruba Economic Zone), SRTFETZ (Sino-Russia Tomsk Forestry Economic and Trade Zone), RLFETCZ (Russia Longyue Forestry Economic & Trade Cooporation Zone), SRMAICZ (Sino-Russian Modern Agricultural Industry Cooperation Zone), CRUETCZ (China-Russia Ussuriysk Economic and Trade Cooperation Zone), VSDZ (Vientiane Saysettha Development Zone), TCRIZ (Thai-Chinese Rayong Industrial Zone), CSSEZ (Cambodia Sihanoukville Special Economic Zone), VLJIP (Vietnam Long Jiang Industrial Park), CIIIPQP (China-Indonesia Integrated Industrial Park Qingshan Park), CIJAICZ (China-Indonesia Julong Agricultural Industry Cooperation Zone), SIETCZ (Sino-Indonesia Economic and Trade Cooperation Zone)
    Fig. 3. The overseas national-level COCZs and their connections with domestic cities in China Note: CHBETCZ (China-Hungary Boside Economic and Trade Cooperation Zone), HSETLCZ (Hungary Sino-European Trade and Logistics Cooperation Zone), CESETCZ (China-Egypt Suez Economic and Trade Cooperation Zone), EEIZ (Ethiopian Eastern Industry Zone), CNETCZ (China-Nigeria Economic and Trade Cooperation Zone), ZCETCZ (Zambia-China Economic and Trade Cooperation Zone), CUPSIA (China-Uzbekistan Peng Sheng Industrial Area), KASAICZ (Kyrgyzstan Asia Star Agricultural Industry Cooperation Zone), PHREZ (Pakistan Haier-Ruba Economic Zone), SRTFETZ (Sino-Russia Tomsk Forestry Economic and Trade Zone), RLFETCZ (Russia Longyue Forestry Economic & Trade Cooporation Zone), SRMAICZ (Sino-Russian Modern Agricultural Industry Cooperation Zone), CRUETCZ (China-Russia Ussuriysk Economic and Trade Cooperation Zone), VSDZ (Vientiane Saysettha Development Zone), TCRIZ (Thai-Chinese Rayong Industrial Zone), CSSEZ (Cambodia Sihanoukville Special Economic Zone), VLJIP (Vietnam Long Jiang Industrial Park), CIIIPQP (China-Indonesia Integrated Industrial Park Qingshan Park), CIJAICZ (China-Indonesia Julong Agricultural Industry Cooperation Zone), SIETCZ (Sino-Indonesia Economic and Trade Cooperation Zone)
    Percentage distribution of leading industries of national-level development zones and COCZsSource: Directory of Audit Bulletins of Chinese Development Zones (2018 Edition) (http://www.ndrc.gov.cn/ gzdt/201803/t20180302_878800.html)
    Fig. 4. Percentage distribution of leading industries of national-level development zones and COCZsSource: Directory of Audit Bulletins of Chinese Development Zones (2018 Edition) (http://www.ndrc.gov.cn/ gzdt/201803/t20180302_878800.html)
    Zone namePark typeLeading industryImplement corporate ownershipSize/km2
    PHREZPMPAppliances, automobiles, textiles, building materials, chemicals, etc.Privately-owned2.33
    CRUETCZPMPLight industry, electrical and mechanical (household appliances, electronics), wood industry, etc.Privately-owned2.28
    ZCETCZCIPMetal smelting, logistics, business services, processing and manufacturing.State-owned17.28
    TCRIZPMPAutomobile and motorcycle fittings, hardware, machinery, electronics, etc.Privately-owned12
    CSSEZPMPTextile and clothing, hardware machinery, light industrial appliances, etc.Privately-owned11.13
    CNETCZCIPManufacturing, machinery and electronics, trade logistics, service real estate, etc.State-owned30
    SRTFETZCIPForest tending and logging, deep processing of wood, trade and logistics, etc.State-owned6.95
    EEIZPMPMetallurgy, building materials, electrical machinery, etc.Privately-owned5
    VLJIPPMPElectronics, machinery, light industry, building materials, biopharmaceutical industry, agricultural and forestry products processing, rubber, paper industry, new materials, man-made fibers, etc.privately-owned6
    CESETCZPMPTextile and clothing, petroleum equipment, high and low voltage electrical appliances, new building materials and fine chemicals.State-owned10
    SIETCZPMPHousehold appliances, fine chemicals, biopharmaceuticals, intensive processing of agricultural products, machinery manufacturing and new materials related industriesState-owned4.55
    CUPSIAPMPCeramics, leather products, food processing, etc.Privately-owned1.02
    CHBETCZPMPChemical, biological and chemical industries.Privately-owned6.15
    HSETLCZTLPCommerce, logistics, warehousing, etc.Privately-owned0.0987
    VSDZCIPAgricultural and sideline products processing, textile and apparel, hardware and building materials, machinery manufacturing, clean energy production, logistics and commerce, etc.State-owned11.49
    SRMAICZAIPPlanting, breeding, processing of agricultural products, etc.Privately-owned680
    RLFETCZRUPForest cultivation, timber harvesting, intensive processing, exhibition, logistics and transportation, etc.Privately-owned9
    KASAICZAIPLivestock and poultry slaughtering and processing, food deep processing, international trade logistics, etc.Privately-owned5.67
    CIIIPQPPMPNickel mining, nickel iron smelting, stainless steel smelting, fine processing, trade logistics, etc.Privately-owned21
    CIJLAICZAIPOil palm planting and development, palm oil preliminary processing, refining and fractionation, brand oil packaging production, oil chemical industry and biodiesel refining, etc.Privately-owned4.21
    Table 1.

    COCZs approved by the Ministry of Commerce of the People's Republic of China

    COCZsETDZsHTIDZs
    Main geographical distributionAlong the B&REast coastAlong the coast and river
    Average duration (year)81112
    Average area (km2)8.411.6211.32
    Subject of establishmentMinistry of Commerce, Ministry of FinanceMinistry of Commerce, Ministry of Land and Resources, Ministry of Construction
    Procedure of formationReaching the Target-Application- Assessment-Acceptance-ReplyApplication -Preliminary Examination-Approval-Reply
    Enterprise pathGo GlobalBring in
    Dominant forceGovernment < MarketGovernment > Market
    Mode of cooperationSino-foreign joint venture, and Chinese enterprises as the main investment bodySino-foreign joint venture, sino-foreign cooperation and wholly foreign-owned
    Capital cycleLongShort
    Table 2.

    Comparison of major national-level COCZs and domestic development zones of China

    TCRIZTEDA
    Setting up time20061984
    Leading industriesAutomobiles, motorcycles and parts, new energy, new materials, machinery and electronics, high value-added industries such as electronic appliancesAutomobiles, equipment manufacturing, electronic communications, food, machinery, biology medicine
    Construction area enterpriseTCRIZ Development Co., Ltd (developed by Holley Group (China) and Amata Group (Thailand))TEDA Investment Holding Co., Ltd
    Operating mechanismMarketMarket
    Management subjectsHolley Group (China)TEDA management committee and TEDA Investment Holding Co., Ltd
    Management mechanismEnterpriseSemi-government management
    Table 3.

    Comparison between TCRIZ and TEDA

    Chao YE, Simeng LI, Zhao ZHANG, Xiaodan ZHU. A comparison and case analysis between domestic and overseas industrial parks of China since the Belt and Road Initiative[J]. Journal of Geographical Sciences, 2020, 30(8): 1266
    Download Citation