• Photonics Research
  • Vol. 3, Issue 1, 5 (2015)
Farhat Abbas1, Akhlesh Lakhtakia2, Qaisar A. Naqvi1, and and Muhammad Faryad3、*
Author Affiliations
  • 1Department of Electronics, Quaid-i-Azam University, Islamabad 45320, Pakistan
  • 2Department of Engineering Science and Mechanics, Pennsylvania State University, University Park, Pennsylvania 16802, USA
  • 3Department of Physics, Lahore University of Management Sciences, Lahore 54792, Pakistan
  • show less
    DOI: 10.1364/PRJ.3.000005 Cite this Article Set citation alerts
    Farhat Abbas, Akhlesh Lakhtakia, Qaisar A. Naqvi, and Muhammad Faryad. An optical-sensing modality that exploits Dyakonov–Tamm waves[J]. Photonics Research, 2015, 3(1): 5 Copy Citation Text show less

    Abstract

    Surface-wave-based optical sensing of an analyte in a fluid relies on the sensitivity of the surface wave to the electromagnetic properties of the analyte-containing fluid in the vicinity of the guiding interface. Surfaceplasmon-polariton (SPP) waves are most commonly used for optical sensing because of the ease of the excitation of an SPP wave when the fluid is partnered with a metal. If the fluid is replaced by a porous, anisotropic, and periodically nonhomogeneous solid filled with the fluid, while the metal is replaced by an isotropic homogeneous dielectric material, the surface wave is called a Dyakonov–Tamm (DT) wave. We have theoretically determined that the incorporation of the DT-waveguiding interface in a prism-coupled configuration provides an alternative to the analogous SPP wave-based sensor, with comparable dynamic sensitivity.

    1. INTRODUCTION

    Any electromagnetic surface wave propagates bound to an interface of two dissimilar materials [1,2]. This localization of the surface wave to the interface allows its use in optical sensing, because a small change in the electromagnetic properties of either of the two partnering materials near the interface can result in a significant change in the characteristics of the surface wave.

    Surface-plasmon-polariton (SPP) waves are extensively used for optical sensors [37]. The propagation of an SPP wave is guided by the interface of a metal and a dielectric material. Although the partnering dielectric material is usually a fluid containing the analyte to be sensed [36], it can also be a porous material that is infiltrated by the analyte-containing fluid [8]. Interestingly, the experimentally measured dynamic sensitivity of a prism/metal/fluid-infiltrated porous material/fluid setup [8] has been found to significantly exceed the theoretical sensitivity of the prism/metal/fluid setup [4].

    A surface wave called the Tamm wave is guided by the interface of two isotropic dielectric materials, at least one of which is periodically nonhomogeneous in the direction perpendicular to the interface [9,10]. The Tamm wave has also been experimentally exploited for optical sensing, with the analyte-containing fluid partnering a periodically stratified solid material [1113].

    Surface waves called Dyakonov–Tamm (DT) waves were theoretically predicted a few years ago [14]. Guided by the interface of two dielectric materials of which at least one is both anisotropic and periodically nonhomogeneous normal to the interface [2], DT waves were experimentally observed very recently [15,16].

    Not surprisingly, DT waves should also be useful for optical sensing. In the initial proposal [17], the commonplace prism-coupled configuration [2,5,6] was adopted. A monochromatic collimated light beam is supposed to be incident on one of the two slanted faces of a prism made of a material with a sufficiently high refractive index nprism. The base of the prism is coated with a chiral sculptured thin film (STF) [18], which is a porous, anisotropic, and periodically nonhomogeneous material. When the chiral STF contacts the analyte-containing fluid, their interface can guide a DT wave [17]. The chiral STF functions as an anisotropic and periodically nonhomogeneous partner, while the fluid is the isotropic and homogeneous partner. The intensity of light exiting the second slanted face of the prism is recorded as the angle of incidence θinc on the base of the prism is varied by changing the direction of propagation of the light beam incident on the first slanted face of the prism. A pronounced and rather narrow dip in the recorded intensity can indicate the excitation of a DT wave.

    As the analyte-containing fluid also infiltrates the chiral STF due to its porosity, the proposed sensor should be quite sensitive as changes in the concentration of the analyte will affect the dielectric properties of both partnering materials. However, this sensing modality does not offer flexibility in the choice of the partnering isotropic dielectric material.

    In this paper, we focus our attention on a new sensing modality exploiting the DT-wave phenomenon. As shown in Fig. 1(a), a nonporous layer of thickness Ld and made of an isotropic material of refractive index nd is interposed between the prism and the chiral STF. With a proper choice of nd, it would be possible to excite a DT wave guided by the interface of the nonporous solid material and the fluid-infiltrated chiral STF, rather than the interface of the fluid-infitrated chiral STF and the fluid. A short description of the model used for the fluid-infiltrated chiral STF is presented in Section 2 and the numerical results are presented and discussed in Section 3. Concluding remarks are presented in Section 4.

    Schematic representations: (a) proposed optical-sensing modality, and (b) underlying canonical boundary-value problem.

    Figure 1.Schematic representations: (a) proposed optical-sensing modality, and (b) underlying canonical boundary-value problem.

    2. FLUID-INFILTRATED CHIRAL STF

    A schematic of the canonical boundary-value problem underlying the sensing modality proposed in this paper is shown in Fig. 1(b). The half space z<0 is occupied by the isotropic partner of refractive index nd, and the half-space z>0 is occupied by the chiral STF infiltrated with an analyte-containing fluid of refractive index n. A change in analyte concentration would alter n.

    Essentially, a chiral STF is fabricated by obliquely directing a collimated vapor flux under low pressure onto a uniformly rotating substrate [18]. The angle between the direction of the vapor flux and the substrate is denoted by χv(0°,90°]. Under suitable conditions, an assembly of parallel nanohelixes form, with the helical axes perpendicular to the substrate. The porosity and morphology of a chiral STF can be tailored during fabrication [18].

    The relative permittivity dyadic of a chiral STF can be stated as [18] where the superscript T denotes the transpose; the dyadic involves 2Ω as the helical pitch and either h=+1 for structural right-handedness or h=1 for structural left-handedness; and the dyadic contains χ[0°,90°] as the angle of rise of the nanohelixes. Both χ and the scalars εa, εb, and εc depend on the angle χv as well as on the evaporated material. Furthermore, εa,b,c also depend on the free-space wavelength λ0 and n. Each nanohelix can be viewed as a string of highly elongated ellipsoidal inclusions, which permits the use of homogenization theory to predict the effective relative permittivity dyadic of a fluid-infiltrated chiral STF from the effective relative permittivity dyadic of an uninfiltrated chiral STF [2,19].

    3. ILLUSTRATIVE NUMERICAL RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

    For all numerical results presented here, we fixed λ0=633nm, nprism=2.6, χv=15°, and Ω=197nm. We chose magnesium flouride (nd=1.377 [15]) as the isotropic dielectric partner. We used the forward and inverse Bruggeman homogenization formalisms in the manner detailed elsewhere [19] to estimate εa,b,c for the chiral STF infiltrated with a fluid of refractive index n[1,1.5] by taking measured data for a columnar thin film made by evaporating patinal titanium oxide [20]. Also, consistently with predecessor works [14,17,19], we used χ=37.6745°; furthermore, we fixed εa=2.13952, εb=3.66907, and εc=2.82571 when n=1.

    Let us begin with the canonical boundary-value problem depicted in Fig. 1(b), because it provides predictions for the prism-coupled configuration of Fig. 1(a). Without significant loss of generality and for the sake of illustration, we let the DT wave propagate along the x axis with an exp(iqx) dependence. Adopting the theoretical formalism described elsewhere [2,14] for the dependence on z, we obtained a dispersion equation for the relative wavenumber q/k0, where k0=2π/λ0 is the free-space wavenumber. The computed values of q/k0 are presented in Fig. 2 against the refractive index n of the fluid infiltrating the void regions of the chiral STF.

    Values of relative wavenumbers q/k0 of DT waves guided by the interface of magnesium fluoride (nd=1.377) and the chosen titanium-oxide chiral STF infiltrated by a fluid of refractive index nℓ. In Figs. 2–4, the blue and red curves represent different DT waves.

    Figure 2.Values of relative wavenumbers q/k0 of DT waves guided by the interface of magnesium fluoride (nd=1.377) and the chosen titanium-oxide chiral STF infiltrated by a fluid of refractive index n. In Figs. 24, the blue and red curves represent different DT waves.

    For a specific n[1,1.5], the chosen interface supports either one or two DT waves, represented by the blue and red curves in Fig. 2. Both of these waves have different phase speeds, spatial profiles, and degree of localization to the interface between the partnering materials. No polarization state can be assigned to either of the two DT waves, because of the rotational nonhomogeneity of the chiral STF (i.e., Section 1.7.4 of [2]).

    In Fig. 2, q is purely real. If the dielectric material of refractive index nd were to be replaced by a metal, the DT waves would be replaced by SPP waves with complex q [2,19]. SPP waves attenuate during propagation, but ideally DT waves do not.

    In the prism-coupled configuration, a DT wave is excited when the absorptance as a function of the incidence angle θinc (1) has a peak that is independent of the thicknesses of the partnering dielectric materials beyond threshold values, and (2) the absorptance peak’s angular position is the same as the prediction θincC=sin1(q/k0nprism) from the underlying canonical boundary-value problem [2,14]. Figure 3 shows θincC predicted as a function of n. All of the values of θincC are practically convenient as they lie between 30° and 50°.

    Values of the angle of incidence θincC in the prism-coupled configuration in relation to the refractive index nℓ of the fluid infiltrating the chiral STF, as predicted by the canonical boundary-value problem.

    Figure 3.Values of the angle of incidence θincC in the prism-coupled configuration in relation to the refractive index n of the fluid infiltrating the chiral STF, as predicted by the canonical boundary-value problem.

    The dynamic sensitivity ρ=dθincC/dn is the change in the angular position of the absorptance peak in the prism-coupled configuration due to change in the refractive index n of the fluid infiltrating the chiral STF. The predicted values of ρ versus n are presented in Fig. 4. A comparison of the sensitivity ρ of DT waves in Fig. 4 with that of SPP waves using the same prism and the same chiral STF [19] indicates that the sensitivity of DT waves is generally similar to that of SPP waves. For the SPP waves, by using aluminum instead of magnesium fluoride, ρ lies between 22° and 32° per refractive index unit (RIU). For the DT waves studied in this paper, ρ lies between 14° and 27° per RIU.

    Dynamic sensitivity ρ as a function of nℓ in the prism-coupled configuration computed from the predicted data presented in Fig. 3.

    Figure 4.Dynamic sensitivity ρ as a function of n in the prism-coupled configuration computed from the predicted data presented in Fig. 3.

    Let us now present the actual results of the prism-coupled configuration, the algorithm for the computations being explained in detail elsewhere [2]. The light incident on the base of the prism is assumed to have an electric field of unit magnitude. For θinc>sin1(n/nprism), there can be no transmittance in the fluid on top of the fluid-infitrated chiral STF in Fig. 1(a), so that the absorptance and the reflectance (calculated at the base of the prism) must add up to unity. In the plots of absorptance A versus the incidence angle θinc, the excitation of a DT wave is indicated by a peak that is independent of the thicknesses of the partnering dielectric materials beyond threshold values. The thickness-dependent peaks could indicate the excitation of waveguide modes [8,21].

    Figure 5 presents the absorptances As and Ap for incident s- and p-polarized light, respectively, when n=1.33, χv=15°, Ld=200nm, and Np=LSTF/2Ω{4,5,6}. For these calculations, we set nd=1.377+104i. The tiny imaginary part was added to get nonzero values of the absorptances [17].

    Absorptances (a) As and (b) Ap plotted as functions of θinc for Np=LSTF/2Ω∈{4,5,6}, when nℓ=1.33, χv=15°, Ld=200 nm, and nd=1.377+10−4i. Downward arrows indicate the peaks that represent the excitation of DT waves.

    Figure 5.Absorptances (a) As and (b) Ap plotted as functions of θinc for Np=LSTF/2Ω{4,5,6}, when n=1.33, χv=15°, Ld=200nm, and nd=1.377+104i. Downward arrows indicate the peaks that represent the excitation of DT waves.

    When n=1.33, there can be no transmission for θinc30.8°; furthermore, Fig. 3 indicates that the canonical boundary-value problem predicts the excitation of one DT wave at θincC=44.8° in the prism-coupled configuration. In Fig. 5(a), the As-peak at θinc=44.6° is independent of LSTF8Ω. The plots of Ap in Fig. 5(b) show that the DT wave at θinc=44.6° can be excited by p-polarized incident plane waves as well. We have verified that these conclusions also hold for Ld{180,220} nm. Accordingly, we conclude that linearly polarized light can excite DT waves and sense the refractive index variation.

    4. CONCLUDING REMARKS

    Our numerical studies have demonstrated that the excitation of DT waves guided by the planar interface of an isotropic homogeneous dielectric material and a porous chiral STF could be used for optical sensing, with comparable sensitivity as that of the SPP-waves-based sensors with the same prism and chiral STF [19].

    References

    [1] A. D. Boardman. Electromagnetic Surface Modes(1982).

    [2] J. A. Polo, T. G. Mackay, A. Lakhtakia. Electromagnetic Surface Waves: A Modern Perspective(2013).

    [3] R. J. Green, R. A. Frazier, K. M. Shakesheff, M. C. Davies, C. J. Roberts, S. J. B. Tendler. Surface plasmon resonance analysis of dynamic biological interactions with biomaterials. Biomaterials, 21, 1823-1835(2000).

    [4] J. Homola, I. Koudela, S. S. Yee. Surface plasmon resonance sensors based on diffraction gratings and prism couplers: sensitivity comparison. Sens. Actuat. B: Chem., 54, 16-24(1999).

    [5] I. Abdulhalim, M. Zourob, A. Lakhtakia. Surface plasmon resonance for biosensing: a mini-review. Electromagnetics, 28, 214-242(2008).

    [6] S. K. Arya, A. Chaubey, B. D. Malhotra. Fundamentals and applications of biosensors. Proc. Ind. Nat. Acad. Sci., 72, 249-266(2006).

    [7] J. H. T. Luong, K. B. Male, J. D. Glennon. Biosensor technology: technology push versus market pull. Biotechnol. Adv., 26, 492-500(2008).

    [8] S. E. Swiontek, D. P. Pulsifer, A. Lakhtakia. Optical sensing of analytes in aqueous solutions with a multiple surface-plasmon-polariton-wave platform. Sci. Rep., 3, 1409(2013).

    [9] P. Yeh, A. Yariv, C.-S. Hong. Electromagnetic propagation in periodic stratified media. I. General theory. J. Opt. Soc. Am., 67, 423-438(1977).

    [10] P. Yeh, A. Yariv, A. Y. Cho. Optical surface waves in periodic layered media. Appl. Phys. Lett., 32, 104-105(1978).

    [11] M. Shinn, W. M. Robertson. Surface plasmon-like sensor based on surface electromagnetic waves in a photonic band-gap material. Sens. Actuat. B, 105, 360-364(2005).

    [12] V. N. Konopsky, E. V. Alieva. Photonic crystal surface waves for optical biosensors. Anal. Chem., 79, 4729-4735(2007).

    [13] P. Rivolo, F. Michelotti, F. Frascella, G. Digregorio, P. Mandracci, L. Dominici, F. Giorgis, E. Descrovi. Real time secondary antibody detection by means of silicon-based multilayers sustaining Bloch surface waves. Sens. Actuat. B: Chem., 161, 1046-1052(2012).

    [14] A. Lakhtakia, J. A. Polo. Dyakonov-Tamm wave at the planar interface of a chiral sculptured thin film and an isotropic dielectric material. J. Eur. Opt. Soc. Rapid Pub., 2, 07021(2007).

    [15] D. P. Pulsifer, M. Faryad, A. Lakhtakia. Observation of the Dyakonov-Tamm wave. Phys. Rev. Lett., 111, 243902(2013).

    [16] D. P. Pulsifer, M. Faryad, A. Lakhtakia, A. S. Hall, L. Liu. Experimental excitation of the Dyakonov–Tamm wave in the grating-coupled configuration. Opt. Lett., 39, 2125-2128(2014).

    [17] A. Lakhtakia, M. Faryad. Theory of optical sensing with Dyakonov–Tamm waves. J. Nanophoton., 8, 083072(2014).

    [18] A. Lakhtakia, R. Messier. Sculptured Thin Films: Nanoengineered Morphology and Optics(2005).

    [19] T. G. Mackay, A. Lakhtakia. Modeling chiral sculptured thin films as platforms for surface-plasmonic-polaritonic optical sensing. IEEE Sens. J., 12, 273-280(2012).

    [20] I. J. Hodgkinson, Q. h. Wu, J. Hazel. Empirical equations for the principal refractive indices and column angle of obliquely-deposited films of tantalum oxide, titanium oxide and zirconium oxide. Appl. Opt., 37, 2653-2659(1998).

    [21] N. S. Kapany, J. J. Burke. Optical Waveguides(1972).

    Farhat Abbas, Akhlesh Lakhtakia, Qaisar A. Naqvi, and Muhammad Faryad. An optical-sensing modality that exploits Dyakonov–Tamm waves[J]. Photonics Research, 2015, 3(1): 5
    Download Citation