• Chinese Journal of Lasers
  • Vol. 51, Issue 4, 0402302 (2024)
Xingyu Chen1、2, Hao Li1、2, Qiaoyu Chen1、2, Haisheng Xu3, Fanxuan Xie1、2, Zheng Li1、2, Tianye Huang4, Kai Guan5, Zuowei Yin1、2, Liang Hao1、2, and Jie Yin1、2、*
Author Affiliations
  • 1Gemological Institute, China University of Geosciences, Wuhan 430074, Hubei, China
  • 2Advanced Manufacturing Research Institute, China University of Geosciences, Wuhan 430074, Hubei, China
  • 3Hubei Sanjiang Aerospace Jiangbei Machinery Engineering Co., Ltd., Xiaogan 432000, Hubei, China
  • 4School of Mechanical Engineering and Electronic Information, China University of Geosciences, Wuhan 430074,Hubei, China
  • 5TSC Laser Technology Development (Beijing) Co., Ltd., Beijing 102200, China
  • show less
    DOI: 10.3788/CJL231437 Cite this Article Set citation alerts
    Xingyu Chen, Hao Li, Qiaoyu Chen, Haisheng Xu, Fanxuan Xie, Zheng Li, Tianye Huang, Kai Guan, Zuowei Yin, Liang Hao, Jie Yin. Recent Progress in Laser Additive Manufacturing Using Copper‑Chromium‑ Zirconium Alloys: Formation, Microstructure, and Comprehensive Properties (Invited)[J]. Chinese Journal of Lasers, 2024, 51(4): 0402302 Copy Citation Text show less
    Characteristics and application areas of CuCrZr alloys
    Fig. 1. Characteristics and application areas of CuCrZr alloys
    L-PBF equipment, printing principle, and prepared sample. (a) LiM-X260A L-PBF additive manufacturing equipment; (b) schematic of L-PBF printing principle[33]; (c) CuCrZr alloy sample prepared by L-PBF
    Fig. 2. L-PBF equipment, printing principle, and prepared sample. (a) LiM-X260A L-PBF additive manufacturing equipment; (b) schematic of L-PBF printing principle[33]; (c) CuCrZr alloy sample prepared by L-PBF
    Relationship between EA and density in different L-PBF experiments (the legend for samples prepared by near-infrared laser is red and the legend for samples prepared by green laser is green)
    Fig. 3. Relationship between EA and density in different L-PBF experiments (the legend for samples prepared by near-infrared laser is red and the legend for samples prepared by green laser is green)
    Metallurgical microscopes diagrams of CuCrZr alloy samples[38]. (a) Sample with 99.15% density; (b) samples with 98.83% density; (c) sample with 98.62% density
    Fig. 4. Metallurgical microscopes diagrams of CuCrZr alloy samples[38]. (a) Sample with 99.15% density; (b) samples with 98.83% density; (c) sample with 98.62% density
    Absorptivity rate of laser by CuCrZr powder, pure Cu powder, surface-oxidized Cu powder, and Cu powder with CrZr coating (Cu@CrZr)
    Fig. 5. Absorptivity rate of laser by CuCrZr powder, pure Cu powder, surface-oxidized Cu powder, and Cu powder with CrZr coating (Cu@CrZr)
    Defects in LAM-fabricated CuCrZr samples. (a) Balling effect[39]; (b) partially melted powders[45]; (c) irregular pores[50]; (d) lack of fusion pores[16]; (e) metallurgical pores[16]; (f) crack[50]
    Fig. 6. Defects in LAM-fabricated CuCrZr samples. (a) Balling effect[39]; (b) partially melted powders[45]; (c) irregular pores[50]; (d) lack of fusion pores[16]; (e) metallurgical pores[16]; (f) crack[50]
    SEM images of as-built L-PBF CuCrZr sample [20]. (a)(b) Microstructure in horizontal building direction; (c)(d) microstructure in vertical building direction
    Fig. 7. SEM images of as-built L-PBF CuCrZr sample [20]. (a)(b) Microstructure in horizontal building direction; (c)(d) microstructure in vertical building direction
    XRD patterns[26]. (a) CuCrZr alloy powder and L-PBF alloy; (b) 73°‒75° localized magnification
    Fig. 8. XRD patterns[26]. (a) CuCrZr alloy powder and L-PBF alloy; (b) 73°‒75° localized magnification
    Microstructure of horizontal direction of SLMed CuCrZr alloy by SEM[45]. (a)(d)(g)(j) Microstructure of AB samples; (b)(e)(h)(k) microstructure of ST samples; (c)(f)(i)(l) microstructure of SAT samples
    Fig. 9. Microstructure of horizontal direction of SLMed CuCrZr alloy by SEM[45]. (a)(d)(g)(j) Microstructure of AB samples; (b)(e)(h)(k) microstructure of ST samples; (c)(f)(i)(l) microstructure of SAT samples
    Microstructure of building direction of SLMed CuCrZr alloy by SEM[45]. (a)(d)(g)(j) Microstructure of AB samples; (b)(e)(h)(k) microstructure of ST samples; (c)(f)(i)(l) microstructure of SAT samples
    Fig. 10. Microstructure of building direction of SLMed CuCrZr alloy by SEM[45]. (a)(d)(g)(j) Microstructure of AB samples; (b)(e)(h)(k) microstructure of ST samples; (c)(f)(i)(l) microstructure of SAT samples
    Thermodynamics calculation results of CuCrZr alloys using CALPHAD[29]. (a) Full range calculation results; (b) minor phases
    Fig. 11. Thermodynamics calculation results of CuCrZr alloys using CALPHAD[29]. (a) Full range calculation results; (b) minor phases
    High-angle annular dark field (HAADF) analysis of DA samples[16]. (a) Aging treatment samples at 480 ℃ for 4 h; (b) aging treatment samples at 530 ℃ for 4 h; (c) aging treatment samples at 580 ℃ for 4 h
    Fig. 12. High-angle annular dark field (HAADF) analysis of DA samples[16]. (a) Aging treatment samples at 480 ℃ for 4 h; (b) aging treatment samples at 530 ℃ for 4 h; (c) aging treatment samples at 580 ℃ for 4 h
    TEM-EDS analysis results[16]. (a) Dispersed distribution of chromium precipitates in sample (480 ℃ aging treatment for 4 h); (b) aggregated and growing chromium and zirconium precipitates in sample (580 ℃ aging treatment for 4 h)
    Fig. 13. TEM-EDS analysis results[16]. (a) Dispersed distribution of chromium precipitates in sample (480 ℃ aging treatment for 4 h); (b) aggregated and growing chromium and zirconium precipitates in sample (580 ℃ aging treatment for 4 h)
    HAADF/STEM and Cr and Zr EDX analysis results[20]. (a) No micro and nano-precipitates detected in the as-built samples; (b) Cr precipitates detected after DAH; (c) Zr precipitates appearing next to Cr precipitates after DAH; (d) substrate of pure Cu
    Fig. 14. HAADF/STEM and Cr and Zr EDX analysis results[20]. (a) No micro and nano-precipitates detected in the as-built samples; (b) Cr precipitates detected after DAH; (c) Zr precipitates appearing next to Cr precipitates after DAH; (d) substrate of pure Cu
    XRD patterns[25]. (a) CuCrZr samples in the as-built state and CuCrZr samples with heat treatments; (b) enlarged spectra in the 40°~45° 2θ range
    Fig. 15. XRD patterns[25]. (a) CuCrZr samples in the as-built state and CuCrZr samples with heat treatments; (b) enlarged spectra in the 40°~45° 2θ range
    Mechanical behavior of L-PBF-built CuCrZr alloys[31]. (a) Stress and strain plots of samples in horizontal and vertical building directions; (b) tensile fracture surface plots in horizontal building direction; (c) tensile fracture surface plots in vertical building direction
    Fig. 16. Mechanical behavior of L-PBF-built CuCrZr alloys[31]. (a) Stress and strain plots of samples in horizontal and vertical building directions; (b) tensile fracture surface plots in horizontal building direction; (c) tensile fracture surface plots in vertical building direction
    Tensile test results of samples along the build direction at room temperature, 204 ℃, and 427 ℃[57]. (a) AB sample; (b) 420 ℃ aging treatment for 2 h; (c) 500 ℃ aging treatment for 2 h; (d) 575 ℃ aging treatment for 2 h; (e) 650 ℃ aging treatment for 2 h
    Fig. 17. Tensile test results of samples along the build direction at room temperature, 204 ℃, and 427 ℃[57]. (a) AB sample; (b) 420 ℃ aging treatment for 2 h; (c) 500 ℃ aging treatment for 2 h; (d) 575 ℃ aging treatment for 2 h; (e) 650 ℃ aging treatment for 2 h
    Relationship between density and electrical conductivity[30]
    Fig. 18. Relationship between density and electrical conductivity[30]
    Effect of heat treatment on electrical conductivity. (a) Tang et al. [25] on heat treatment affecting electrical conductivity; (b) Yang et al. [16] on heat treatment affecting electrical conductivity; (c) Salvan et al. [20] on heat treatment affecting electrical conductivity
    Fig. 19. Effect of heat treatment on electrical conductivity. (a) Tang et al. [25] on heat treatment affecting electrical conductivity; (b) Yang et al. [16] on heat treatment affecting electrical conductivity; (c) Salvan et al. [20] on heat treatment affecting electrical conductivity
    Thermal and electrical properties of L-PBF-built CuCrZr alloys[31] . (a) Variation of thermal conductivity with temperature for CuCrZr samples; (b) effect of aging temperatures on thermal conductivity of samples
    Fig. 20. Thermal and electrical properties of L-PBF-built CuCrZr alloys[31] . (a) Variation of thermal conductivity with temperature for CuCrZr samples; (b) effect of aging temperatures on thermal conductivity of samples
    Alloy gradeMass fraction /%
    CuCrZrFeSi
    C18150Balance0.50‒1.500.02‒0.20
    C18160Balance0.20‒1.200.05‒0.250.10.1
    Table 1. Chemical composition of regular grades of CuCrZr alloys[27]
    Optimal process parameter

    Wavelength /

    nm

    EA /

    (J·mm-3

    Density /%Ref.
    Laser power /WLaser scanning speed /(mm·s-1Hatching distance /μmLayer thickness /μm
    4003008030515411.199.1Wang et al.26,2022
    4854009030332.398.6Tang et al.252022
    5007005040106464.399.9Yang et al.16,2023
    42565011099.2Ma et al.372022
    425350903080.997.6Guan et al.232019
    370500802083.399.9Wallis et al.242019
    4807001003041.199.4Salvan et al.202021
    Table 2. Process parameters used for the highest density samples in each study
    Mass fraction of major alloying element /%Yield strength /MPa

    Ultimate tensile

    strength /MPa

    Elongation /%Heat treatment systemRef.
    CrZr
    0.5‒0.70.06‒0.15210.0267.021.0ABGuan et al.23 2019
    405.0490.012.5DAH(500 ℃×1 h)
    0.880.13218.0±6.1254.6±4.246.5±2.1ABBai et al.45 2021
    131.0±1.0254.9±4.541.4±2.0ST(950 ℃×0.5 h)
    231.3±3.2322.3±3.719.1±0.8SAT(950 ℃×0.5 h+480 ℃×2 h)
    0.880.14175.2265.549.4ABWang et al.26 2022
    502.5612.021.8DAH(480 ℃×2 h)
    0.6‒0.80.06‒0.2216.0338.042.4ABKuai et al.28 2022
    0.5‒0.70.06‒0.15400.0±11.0447.0±13.010.0±3.0ABTang et al.25 2022
    487.0±13.0566.0±18.015.0±1.0DAH(500 ℃×1 h)
    0.60.15213.0262.032.0ABYang et al.16 2023
    404.0501.020.0DA(480 ℃×4 h)
    0.5‒1.20.03‒0.3204.0±1.0287.0±2.020.5±2.2ABWallis et al.24 2019
    361.0±8.0466.0±8.012.3±0.4DAH(580 ℃×5 h)
    0.750.08270.0±6.0305.0±5.026.0±2.0ABSalvan et al.20 2021
    253.0±8.0380.0±7.025.0±2.0SAAH(980 ℃×1 h+490 ℃×6 h)
    527.0±3.0585.0±1.014.0±1.0DAH(490 ℃×1 h)
    1.50.5165.4±1.4200.3±4.117.5±2.3ABZeng et al.57 2019
    389.1±3.6413.7±7.75.7±1.0DAH(500 ℃×2 h)
    Table 3. Effect of heat treatment methods on mechanical properties

    Mass fraction of major

    alloying elements /%

    Density /%Conductivity /(% IACS)Heat treatment systemRef.
    CrZr
    0.880.1496.6‒98.322.2ABWang et al.26,2022
    0.5‒1.50.05‒0.2599.321.0‒26.0ABOu et al.30,2022
    91.20±0.49ST(1000 ℃×2 h)
    0.600.1599.928.0ABYang et al.162023
    97.0DA(580 ℃×4 h)
    0.5‒1.20.03‒0.399.424.6ABSalvan et al.202021
    88.1SAAH(980 ℃×1 h+490 ℃×3 h)
    0.50‒0.700.06‒0.1598.030.0±1.0ABTang et al.252022
    84.0±1.0SAAH(960 ℃×1 h+500 ℃×1 h)
    83.0±1.0DAH(550 ℃×1 h)
    0.50‒0.700.06‒0.1530.0ABXie et al.312023
    64.0DAH(500 ℃×1 h)
    Table 4. Effect of heat treatment method on electrical conductivity
    Mass fraction of major alloying elements /%Density /%Thermal conductivity /[W·(m·K)-1Heat treatment systemRef.
    CrZr
    0.5‒0.70.06‒0.1598.0125.0±4.0ABTang et al.25,2022
    346.0±4.0DAH(550 ℃×1 h)
    350.0±4.0SAAH(960 ℃×1 h+500 ℃×1 h)
    0.60.1599.9102.0ABYang et al.16,2023
    313.0DA(580 ℃×4 h)
    0.5‒1.20.03‒0.399.9100.0±2.0ABWallis et al.24,2019
    297.0±6.0SAAH(950 ℃×0.25 h+450 ℃×2 h)
    0.5‒0.70.06‒0.15307.0

    DAH(550 ℃×1 h)

    parallel horizontal direction

    Xie et al.31,2023
    255.0

    DAH(550 ℃×1 h)

    parallel vertical direction

    Table 5. Effect of heat treatment method on thermal conductivity
    Xingyu Chen, Hao Li, Qiaoyu Chen, Haisheng Xu, Fanxuan Xie, Zheng Li, Tianye Huang, Kai Guan, Zuowei Yin, Liang Hao, Jie Yin. Recent Progress in Laser Additive Manufacturing Using Copper‑Chromium‑ Zirconium Alloys: Formation, Microstructure, and Comprehensive Properties (Invited)[J]. Chinese Journal of Lasers, 2024, 51(4): 0402302
    Download Citation