Recent advances in generation of terahertz vortex beams and their applications

Honggeng Wang; Qiying Song; Yi Cai; Qinggang Lin; Xiaowei Lu; Huangcheng Shangguan; Yuexia Ai; Shixiang Xu

doi:10.1088/1674-1056/aba2df

[1] X C Zhang, A Shkurinov, Y Zhang. Nat. Photon, 11, 16(2017).

[2] M F Pererira, O V Shulika. Terahertz and Mid Infrared Radiation: Detection of Explosives and CBRN (Using Terahertz)(2014).

[3] R A Lewis. J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys, 47(2014).

[4] C Zhang, L Deng, J Zhu, W Hong, L Wang, W Yang, S Li. Materials, 11, 1054(2018).

[5] T Kampfrath, K Tanaka, K A Nelson. Nat. Photon, 7, 680(2013).

[6] S Koenig, D Lopez-Diaz, J Antes, F Boes, R Henneberger, A Leuther, A Tessmann, R Schmogrow, D Hillerkuss, R Palmer, T Zwick, C Koos, W Freude, O Ambacher, J Leuthold, I Kallfass. Nat. Photon, 7, 977(2013).

[7] E Pickwell, V P Wallace. J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys, 39, R301(2006).

[8] K Miyamoto, B J Kang, W T Kim, Y Sasaki, H Niinomi, K Suizu, F Rotermund, T Omatsu. Sci. Rep, 6(2016).

[9] T Watanabe, Y Iketaki, T Omatsu, K Yamamoto, M Sakai, M Fujii. Opt. Express, 11, 3271(2003).

[10] K Miyamoto, K Sano, T MIyakawa, H Niinomi, K Toyoda, A Vallés, T Omatsu. Opt. Express, 27(2019).

[11] M Tonouchi. Nat. Photon, 1, 97(2007).

[12] D M Mittleman. Opt. Express, 26, 9417(2018).

[13] K Kawase, Y Ogawa, Y Watanabe, H Inoue. Opt. Express, 11, 2549(2003).

[14] M Hangyo. Jpn. J. Appl. Phys, 54(2015).

[15] L Ju, B Geng, J Horng, C Girit, M Martin, Z Hao, H A Bechtel, X Liang, A Zettl, Y R Shen, F Wang. Nat. Nanotechnol, 6, 630(2011).

[16] S S Dhillon, M S Vitiello, E H Linfield et al. J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys, 50(2017).

[17] K Humphreys, J Loughran, M Gradziel, W Lanigan, T Ward, J Murphy, C O’Sullivan. Proceedings of the 26th Annual International Conference of the IEEE EMBS, 1302(2004).

[18] Z D Taylor, R S Singh, D B Bennett, P Tewari, C P Kealey, N Bajwa, M O Culjat, A Stojadinovic, H Lee, J P Hubschman, E R Brown, W S Grundfest. IEEE T. THz Sci. Techn, 1, 201(2011).

[19] M Walther, B M Fischer, A Ortner, A Bitzer, A Thoman, H Helm. Anal. Bioanal. Chem, 397, 1009(2010).

[20] J Y Suen, P Tewari, Z D Taylor, W S Grundfest, H Lee, E R Brown, M O Culjat, R S Singh. Stud. Health Technol. Inform, 142, 364(2009).

[21] T Omatsu, K Chujo, K Miyamoto, M Okida, K Nakamura, N Aoki, R Morita. Opt. Express, 18(2010).

[22] D Zhang, A Fallahi, M Hemmer, X Wu, M Fakhari, Y Hua, H Cankaya, A L Calendron, L E Zapata, N H Matlis, F X Kärtner. Nat. Photon, 12, 336(2018).

[23] J Vieira, J T Mendonça. Phys. Rev. Lett, 112(2014).

[24] J Hebling, J A Fülöp, M I Mechler, L Pálfalvi, C Töke, G Almási(2011).

[25] A J Silenko, P Zhang, L Zou. Phys. Rev. Lett, 119(2017).

[26] H Zheng, U M Mirsaidov, L W Wang, P Matsudaira. Nano Lett, 12, 5644(2012).

[27] F Tamburini, B Thidé, G Molina-Terriza, G Anzolin. Nat. Phys, 7, 195(2011).

[28] M Harwit. Astrophys. J, 597, 1266(2003).

[29] D J Sanchez, D W Oesch, O R Reynolds. Astron. Astrophys, 556, A130(2013).

[30] B Thidé, H Then, J Sjöholm, K Palmer, J Bergman, T D Carozzi, Y N Istomin, N H Ibragimov, R Khamitova. Phys. Rev. Lett, 99(2007).

[31] W L Chan, H T Chen, A J Taylor, I Brener, M J Cich, D M Mittleman. Appl. Phys. Lett, 94(2009).

[32] A Podzorov, G Gallot. Appl. Opt, 47, 3254(2008).

[33] S Walia, C M Shah, P Gutruf, H Nili, D R Chowdhury, W Withayachumnankul, M Bhaskaran, S Sriram. Appl. Phys. Rev, 2(2015).

[34] K Miyamoto, K Suizu, T Akiba, T Omatsu. Appl. Phys. Lett, 104(2014).

[35] B J Kang, K Miyamoto, W T Kim, K J Ahn, T Omatsu, F Rotermund. Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics Pacific Rim (CLEO-PR)(2018).

[36] X Wang, J Shi, W Sun, S Feng, P Han, J Ye, Y Zhang. Opt. Express, 24, 7178(2016).

[37] P Schemmel, G Pisano, B Maffei. Opt. Express, 22(2014).

[38] P Schemmel, S Maccalli, G Pisano, B Maffei, M W R Ng. Opt. Letters, 39, 626(2014).

[39] N V Petrov, M S Kulya, A N Tsypkin, V G Bespalov, A A Gorodetsky. IEEE T. THz Sci. Techn, 6, 464(2016).

[40] V A Semenova, M S Kulya, N V Petrov, Y V Grachev, A N Tsypkin, S E Putilin, V G Bespalov. 41st International Conference on Infrared, Millimeter and Terahertz Waves (IRMMW-THz)(2016).

[41] V Semenova, M Kulya, V Bespalov. J. Phys.: Conf. Ser, 735(2016).

[42] T Wakayama, T Higashiguchi, H Oikawa, K Sakaue, M Washio, M Yonemura, T Yoshizawa, J S Tyo, Y Otani. Sci. Rep, 5, 9416(2015).

[43] L Wang, X W Lin, X Liang, J B Wu, W Hu, Z G Zheng, B B Jin, Y Q Qin, Y Q Lu. Opt. Mater. Express, 2, 1314(2012).

[44] X W Lin, J B Wu, W Hu, Z G Zheng, Z J Wu, G Zhu, F Xu, B B Jin, Y Q Lu. AIP Adv, 1(2011).

[45] G Turnbull, D Robertson, G Smith, L Allen, M Padgett. Opt. Commun, 127, 183(1996).

[46] A I Hernandez-Serrano, E Castro-Camus, D Lopez-Mago. J. Infrared Millim. Te, 38, 938(2017).

[47] W D Furlan, V Ferrando, J A Monsoriu, P Zagrajek, E Czerwińska, M Szustakowski. Opt. Lett, 41, 1748(2016).

[48] L Zhu, X Wei, J Wang, Z Zhang, Z Li, H Zhang, S Li, K Wang, J Liu. Optical Fiber Communications Conference and Exhibition (OFC)(2014).

[49] C Liu, J Liu, L Niu, X Wei, K Wang, Z Yang. Sci. Rep, 7, 3891(2017).

[50] S Fallah, K Rouhi, A Abdolali. J. Phy. D: Appl. Phys, 53(2020).

[51] K Rouhi, H Rajabalipanah, A Abdolali. Carbon, 149, 125(2019).

[52] A Momeni, K Rouhi, H Rajabalipanah, A Abdolali. Sci. Rep, 8, 6200(2018).

[53] K Rouhi, H Rajabalipanah, A Abdolali. Ann. Phys, 530(2017).

[54] S Asgari, M Rahmanzadeh. Opt. Commun, 456(2020).

[55] Z Liu, B Bai. Opt. Express, 25, 8584(2017).

[56] K Qu, Q Jia, N J Fisch. Phys. Rev. E, 96(2017).

[57] Y Yang, X Ye, L Niu, K Wang, Z Yang, J Liu. Opt. Express, 28, 1417(2020).

[58] J Lin, X C Yuan, S H Tao, R E Burge. Opt. Lett, 30, 3266(2005).

[59] X Wei, C Liu, L Niu, Z Zhang, K Wang, Z Yang, J Liu. Appl. Opt, 54(2015).

[60] Z Wu, X Wang, W Sun, S Feng, P Han, J Ye, Y Yu, Y Zhang. Opt. Express, 26, 1506(2018).

[61] M W Beijersbergen, R P C Coerwinkel, M Kristensen, J P Woerdman. Opt. Commun, 112, 321(1994).

[62] L Marrucci, C Manzo, D Paparo. Phys. Rev. Lett, 96(2006).

[63] L Marrucci, C Manzo, D Paparo. Appl. Phys. Lett, 88(2006).

[64] A Minasyan, C Trovato, J Degert, E Freysz, E Brasselet, E Abraham. Opt. Lett, 42, 41(2017).

[65] S Ge, P Chen, Z Shen, W Sun, X Wang, W Hu, Y Zhang, Y Lu. Opt. Express, 25(2017).

[66] B Piccirillo, V D’Ambrosio, S Slussarenko, L Marrucci, E Santamato. Appl. Phys. Lett, 97(2010).

[67] A Rubano, F Cardano, B Piccirillo, L Marrucci. J. Opt. Soc. Am. B, 36, D70(2019).

[68] R Imai, N Kanda, T Higuchi, K Konishi, M Kuwata-Gonokami. Opt. Lett, 39, 3714(2014).

[69] X Wang, S Wang, Z Xie, W Sun, S Feng, Y Cui, J Ye, Y Zhang. Opt. Express, 22(2014).

[70] R Imai, N Kanda, T Higuchi, Z Zheng, K Konishi, M K Gonokami. Opt. Express, 20(2012).

[71] B A Knyazev, Y Y Choporova, M S Mitkov, V S Pavelyev, B O Volodkin. Phys. Rev. Lett, 115(2015).

[72] B Volodkin, Y Choporova, B Knyazev, G Kulipanov, V Pavelyev, V Soifer, N Vinokurov. Opt. Quant. Electron, 48, 223(2016).

[73] Y Zhang, W Liu, J Gao, X Yang. Adv. Opt. Mater, 6(2018).

[74] R N Heckenberg, R McDuff, C P Smith, A G White. Opt. Lett, 17, 221(1992).

[75] A M Yao, M J Padgett. Adv. Opt. Photonics, 3, 161(2011).

[76] Q Zhan. Adv. Opt. Photonics, 1, 1(2009).

[77] R Dorn, S Quabis, G Leuchs. Phys. Rev. Lett, 91(2003).

[78] S N Khonina, S V Alferov, S V Karpeev. Opt. Lett, 38, 3223(2013).

[79] J He, X Wang, D Hu, J Ye, S Feng, Q Kan, Y Zhang. Opt. Express, 21(2013).

[80] M Zhuldybina, C Trudeau, X Ropagnol, M Bolduc, R J Zednik, F Blanchard. Photonics North (PN) Conference(2018).

[81] Y Taira, Y Nakata, F Miyamaru, M W Takeda. Progress in Electromagnetic Research Symposium (PIERS), 2396(2016).

[82] Y Chen, S Suzuki, M Asada. 43rd International Conference on Infrared, Millimeter, and Terahertz Waves (IRMMW-THz)(2018).

[83] H Zhou, J Dong, S Yan, Y Zhou, X Zhang. IEEE Photonics J, 6(2014).

[84] X N Li, L Zhou, G Z Zhao. Acta Phys. Sin, 68(2019).

[85] X Zang, Y Zhu, C Mao, W Xu, H Ding, J Xie, Q Cheng, L Chen, Y Peng, Q Hu, M Gu, S Zhuang. Adv. Opt. Mater, 7(2019).

[86] M Kang, J Chen, B Gu, Y Li, L T Vuong, H T Wang. Phys. Rev. A, 85(2012).

[87] M Sakamoto, K Oka, R Morita, N Murakami. Opt. Lett, 38, 3661(2013).

[88] Y Tokizane, K Oka, R Morita. Opt. Express, 17(2009).

[89] X D Zhang, Y H Su, J C Ni, Z Y Wang, Y L Wang, C W Wang, F F Ren, Z Zhang, H Fan, W J Zhang, G Q Li, Y L Hu, J W Li, D Wu, J R Chu. Appl. Phys. Lett, 111(2017).

[90] S J Ge, Z X Shen, P Chen, X Liang, X K Wang, W Hu, Y Zhang, Y Q Lu. Crystals, 7, 314(2017).

[91] Y Li, J Kim, M J Escuti. Appl. Opt, 51, 8236(2012).

[92] H Wu, W Hu, H C Hu, X W Lin, G Zhu, J W Choi, V Chigrinov, Y Q Lu. Opt. Express, 20(2012).

[93] J Ala-Laurinaho, T Hirvonen, P Piironen, A Lehto, J Tuovinen, A V Räisänen, U Frisk. IEEE T. Antenn. Propag, 49, 1264(2001).

[94] J Salo, J Meltaus, E Noponen, M M Salomaa, A Lönnqvist, T Koskinen, V Viikari, J Säily, J Häkli, J Ala-Laurinaho, J Mallat, A V Räisänen. J. Opt. A: Pure Appl. Opt, 4, S161(2002).

[95] J Säily, J Ala-Laurinaho, J Häkli, J Tuovinen, A Lehto, A V Räisänen. Electron. Lett, 36, 111(2000).

[96] J Meltaus, J Salo, E Noponen, M M Salomaa, V Viikari, A Lönnqvist, T Koskinen, J Säily, J Häkli, J Alá-Laurinaho, J Mallat, A V Räisänen. IEEE MTT-S International Microwave Symposium Digest, 1305(2002).

[97] Z Xie, X Wang, J Ye, S Feng, T Akalin, Y Zhang. Sci. Rep, 3, 3347(2013).

[98] J Meltaus, J Salo, E Noponen, M M Salomma, V Viikari, A Lönnqvist, T Koskinen, J Säily, J Häkli, J Ala-Laurinaho, J Mallat, A V Räisänen. IEEE T. Microw. Theory, 51, 1274(2003).

[99] J Arlt, K Dholakia. Opt. Commun, 177, 297(2000).

[100] R Petit. Electromagnetic Theory of Gratings(1980).

[101] Y Z Yu, W B Dou. Int. J. Infrared Milli. Waves, 29, 693(2008).

[102] B Ferguson, X C Zhang. Nat. Materials, 1, 26(2002).

[103] A A Dhaybi, J Degert, E Brasselet, E Abraham, E Freysz. J. Opt. Soc. Am. B, 36, 12(2019).

[104] Q Chen, M Tani, Z Jiang, X C Zhang. J. Opt. Soc. Am. B, 18, 823(2001).

[105] Q Lin, S Zheng, Q Song, X Zeng, Y Cai, Y Li, Z Chen, L Zha, X Pan, S Xu. Opt. Lett, 44, 887(2019).

[106] J R Danielson, A D Jameson, J L Tomaino, H Hui, J D Wetzel, Y S Lee, K L Vodopyanov. J. Appl. Phys, 104(2008).

[107] H Sobhani, E Dadar. J.Opt. Soc. Am. A, 36, 1187(2019).

[108] M Kreß, T Löffler, M D Thomson, R Dörner, H Gimpel, K Zrost, T Ergler, R Moshammer, U Morgner, J Ullrich, H G Roskos. Nat. Phys, 2, 327(2006).

[109] K Y Kim, J H Glownia, A J Taylor, G Rodriguez. Opt. Express, 15, 4577(2007).

[110] M D Thomson, M Kreß, T Löffler, H G Roskos. Laser Photonics Rev, 1, 349(2007).

[111] Y Bai, L Song, R Xu, C Li, P Liu, Z Zeng, Z Zhang, H Lu, R Li, Z Xu. Phys. Rev. Lett, 108(2012).

[112] H Wang, Y Bai, E Wu, Z Wang, P Liu, C Liu. Phys. Rev. A, 98(2018).

[113] H Wang, Q Song, S Zheng, Q Lin, E Wu, Y Ai, C Liu, S Xu. J. Opt, 21(2019).

[114] M Ivanov, I Thiele, L Bergé, S Skupin, D Buožius, V Vaičaitis. Opt. Lett, 44, 3889(2019).

[115] , Q Jin, A Tcypkin, X C Zhang. Appl. Phys. Lett, 113(2019).

[116] Q Jin, , K Williams, J Dai, X C Zhang. Appl. Phys. Lett, 111(2017).

[117] I Dey, K Jana, V Y Fedorov, A D Koulouklidis, A Mondal, M Shaikh, D Sarkar, A D Lad, S Tzortzakis, A Couairon, G R Kumar. Nat. Commun, 8, 1184(2017).

[118] Q Jin, , L Zhang, C Zhang, A Tcypkin, S Kozlov, X C Zhang. 43rd International Conference on Infrared, Millimeter, and Terahertz Waves (IRMMW-THz)(2018).

[119] G Jiang, L Zhang, S Zhang, C Zhang. Infrared, Millimeter-Wave, and Terahertz Technologies V, Proc. SPIE(2018).

[120] R Piesiewicz, M Jacob, M Koch, J Schoebel, T Kürner. IEEE J. Sel. Top. Quant, 14, 421(2008).

[121] J Federici, L Moeller. J. Appl. Phys, 107(2010).

[122] C Han, A O Bicen, I F Akyildiz. IEEE T. Signal Proces, 64, 910(2016).

[123] X Wei, L Zhu, Z Zhang, K Wang, J Liu, J Wang. Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics (CLEO)–-Laser Science to Photonic Application(2014).

[124] R Fickler, R Lapkiewicz, W N Plick, M Krenn, C Schaeff, S Ramelow, A Zeilinger. Science, 338, 640(2012).

[125] T Nagatsuma, G Ducournau, C C Renaud. Nat. Photon, 10, 371(2016).

[126] A Hirata, T Kosugi, H Takahashi, R Yamaguchi, F Nakajima, T Furuta, H Ito, H Sugahara, Y Sato, T Nagatsuma. IEEE T. Microw. Theory, 54, 1937(2006).

[127] H Takahashi, A Hirata, J Takeuchi, N Kukutsu, T Kosugi, K Murata. 15th European Microwave Week-Space for Microwaves Conference Proceedings, 313(2012).

[128] S Cherry. IEEE Spectrum, 41, 58(2004).

[129] N Bozinovic, Y Yue, Y Ren, M Tur, P Kristensen, H Huang, A E Willner, S Ramachandran. Science, 340, 1545(2013).

[130] J Wang, J Y Yang, I M Fazal, N Ahmed, Y Yan, H Huang, Y Ren, Y Yue, S Dolinar, M Tur, A E Willner. Nat. Photon, 6, 488(2012).

[131] Z Wang, N Zhang, X C Yuan. Opt. Express, 19, 482(2011).

[132] X Gao, S Huang, J Zhou, Y Wei, C Gao, X Zhang, W Gu. J. Opt, 15(2013).

[133] V G Bespalov. Russ. Phys. J, 58, 1420(2016).

[134] P U Jepsen, D G Cooke, M Koch. Laser Photonics Rev, 5, 124(2011).

[135] C Jansen, S Wietzke, O Peters, M Scheller, N Vieweg, M Salhi, N Krumbholz, C Jördens, T Hochrein, M Koch. Appl. Opt, 49, E48(2010).

[136] T L Cocker, M A Huber, M Eisele, M Plankl, F Mooshammer, F Sandner, D Peller, J Repp, R Huber. Progress in Electromagnetic Research Symposium (PIERS), 3339(2016).

[137] Z Long, T Wang, C You, Z Yang, K Wang, J Liu. Appl. Opt, 58, 2731(2019).

[138] K Liu, Y Cheng, Z Yang, H Wang, Y Qin, X Li. IEEE Anten Wirel. Pr, 14, 711(2015).

[139] S C Chen, L H Du, K Meng, J Li, Z H Zhai, Q W Shi, Z R Li, L G Zhu. Opt. Lett, 44, 21(2019).

[140] Y Guo, F Ling, H Li, S Zhou, J Ji, J Yao. Appl. Opt, 58, 6244(2019).

[141] S Bretschneider, C Eggeling, S W Hell. Phys. Rev. Lett, 98(2007).

[142] I H Baek, K J Ahn, B J Kang, S Bae, B H Hong, D I Yeom, K Lee, Y U Jeong, F Rotermund. Appl. Phys. Lett, 102(2013).

[143] J Hebling, K Yeh, M C Hoffmann, K A Nelson. IEEE J. Sel. Top. Quant, 14, 345(2008).

[144] G Sharma, I Al-Naib, H Hafez, R Morandotti, D G Cooke, T Ozaki. Opt. Express, 20(2012).

[145] J C Cao, J C Lei. Phys. Rev. B, 67(2003).

[146] H Wen, M Wiczer, A M Lindenberg. Phys. Rev. B, 78(2008).

[147] D Sanvitto, F M Marchetti, M H Szymańska, G Tosi, M Baudisch, F P Laussy, D N Krizhanovskii, M S Skolnick, L Marrucci, A Lemaître, J Bloch, C Tejedor, L Viña. Nat. Phys, 6, 527(2010).

[148] K Toyoda, K Miyamoto, N Aoki, R Morita, T Omatsu. Nano Lett, 12, 3645(2012).

[149] K Toyoda, F Takahashi, S Takizawa, Y Tokizane, K Miyamoto, R Morita, T Omatsu. Phys. Rev. Lett, 110(2013).

[150] F Takahashi, K Miyamoto, H Hidai, K Yamane, R Morita, T Omatsu. Sci. Rep, 6(2016).

[151] E A Nanni, W R Huang, K H Hong, K Ravi, A Fallahi, G Moriena, R J D Miller, F X Kärtner. Nat. Commun, 6, 8486(2015).

[152] G Anzolin, F Tamburini, A Bianchini, G Umbriaco, C Barbieri. Astro. Astrophys, 488, 1159(2008).

[153] F Tamburini, G Anzolin, A Bianchini, C Barbieri. Phys. Rev. Lett, 97(2006).

[154] C Barbieri, G Naletto, T Occhipinti et al. J. Mod. Optic, 56, 261(2009).

[155] E Serabyn, D Mawet, R Burruss. Nature, 464, 1018(2010).

[156] J H Lee, G Foo, E G Johnson, G A Swartzlander Jr. Phys. Rev. Lett, 97(2006).

[157] A Bekshaev, K Y Bliokh, M Soskin. J. Opt, 13(2011).

[158] H Dehnen. Int. J. Theor. Phys, 7, 467(1973).

[159] P Carini, L L Feng, M Li, R Ruffini. Phys. Rev. D, 46, 5407(1992).

[160] L L Feng, W L Lee. Int. J. Mod. Phys. D, 10, 961(2001).

[161] A E Broderick, V L Fish, S S Doeleman, A Loeb. Astrophys. J, 697, 45(2009).

[162] C Jenkins. Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc, 384, 515(2008).

[163] C Delacroix, O Absil, P Forsberg, D Mawet, V Christiaens, M Karlsson, A Boccaletti, P Baudoz, M Kuittinen, I Vartiainen, J Surdej, S Habraken. Astron. Astrophys, 553, A98(2013).