• Acta Photonica Sinica
  • Vol. 49, Issue 9, 0912001 (2020)
Wen-tao LI1, Hao TANG2, and Jian ZHOU1、*
Author Affiliations
  • 1Department of Optoelectronic Engineering, College of Advanced Interdisciplinary Studies, National University of Defense Technology, Changsha 410073, China
  • 2Hunan Institute of Metrology and Test, Changsha 410014, China
  • show less
    DOI: 10.3788/gzxb20204909.0912001 Cite this Article
    Wen-tao LI, Hao TANG, Jian ZHOU. Research on Laser Velocimeter for Overspeed Detection on Highways[J]. Acta Photonica Sinica, 2020, 49(9): 0912001 Copy Citation Text show less

    Abstract

    In order to reduce the illegal overspeed on highways and improve the traffic safety monitoring system, a portable laser Doppler velocity measuring system for long-distance work is proposed. The principle of laser Doppler velocimeter and the method of beam transformation are described in detail. And using the structure of the double lens telescope system, the laser velocimeter for highway overspeed detection is built. The results of theory and experiment show that this laser Doppler velocity measuring system has the characteristics of long working distance and large depth of field, and the vehicle's velocity can be obtained with high accuracy. Compared with traditional laser velocimeters, the center working distance and the depth of field are increased by this portable laser Doppler velocity measuring system. The center working distance of this novel laser Doppler velocimeter is 10 m; the depth of field is ±1 m, and the velocity measurement accuracy can reach to 0.1%.

    0 Introduction

    Overspeed is one of the biggest hidden dangers which will lead to traffic accidents. It not only affects the normal traffic order, but also poses a huge threat to people's lives and property. According to relevant statistics, over 70% of traffic accidents on highways in China are caused by overspeed. Therefore, developing advanced vehicle velocity measuring technology and detecting velocity of vehicles in traffic are important and significant[1, 2].

    The traditional overspeed detection technology includes radar detection, ground sense coil detection and video detection[3]. Radar detection transmits radar waves with a certain frequency to a moving vehicle, and detects the frequency of the reflected waves[4, 5]. Finally, the vehicle's velocity can be calculated by the difference between the transmission and reception frequencies. Due to the large cone angle of the radar wave and its wide irradiation area, radar detection has the advantage of easy target detection, but its effective measurement distance will also be reduced, and the measurement accuracy will be affected by other vehicles. The ground sense coil detection is to embed the induction coil on the ground and calculate the velocity by sensing the electromagnetic signal of the vehicle. This method has high accuracy and sensitivity, but it requires a large amount of construction to lay the induction coil under the ground, and it is greatly affected by environmental factors and road surface quality. The later maintenance cost is relatively high. In addition, the video detection technology uses a closed-circuit television or digital camera to digitally analyze the behavior of vehicles to obtain their velocity information[6, 7]. This detection technology has the advantage of providing management information such as visual images, but its detection accuracy is sensitive to the change of light at the intersection, and the quality of the image algorithm directly affects the detection effect.

    The laser Doppler velocity measurement technology is widely used in many fields, such as machinery, aviation and medical[8, 9], due to its advantages of high accuracy, good linearity, fast dynamic response, large measurement range[10, 11]. At the same time, the working frequency of the Laser Doppler Velocimeter (LDV) is high, so its accuracy will not be affected by the number of measured objects, and it also performs well in harsh environments such as dim light[12]. Although there are many mature LDV products on the market and the scholars at home and abroad are constantly improving them[13-15], they have not been well applied in the field of overspeed detection on highways because of its short working distance (The working distance of common velocimeters is about 0.5 m).

    Therefore, in order to make up for the shortcomings of the traditional overspeed detection technology on highways, and to be able to combine the laser Doppler velocity measurement technology with the overspeed detection well, the principle and implementation method of beam transformation are discussed in detail, and a portable laser Doppler velocity measuring system that can be operated from a long distance is designed based on the optical structure of single-beam LDV in this paper, and used to detect mobile overspeed vehicles on highways.

    1 Principle of laser velocimeter for overspeed detection

    1.1 Optical principle of laser Doppler velocity measuring

    Doppler effect is the theoretical basis of laser Doppler velocimeter, it refers to that when a beam of laser light with a single frequency shines to a moving particle, and the frequency of the light received by the particle is different with that of the light source. The light frequency f′ received by particle can be given by

    $ {f^\prime } = {f_{\rm{o}}}\left( {1 - \frac{{\mathit{\boldsymbol{v}} \cdot {\mathit{\boldsymbol{e}}_{\rm{o}}}}}{c}} \right) $

    where fo is the frequency of the light source, v is the velocity of the moving particle, eo is the unit vector of the incident light of the light source.

    Using Eq.(1) of single Doppler effect, the frequency fs detected by the photodetector when the light wave reaches the photodetector through the moving particles can be calculated (twice Doppler effect), and then the difference fD (the Doppler frequency shift) between fs and fo can be expressed by

    $ f_{\mathrm{D}}=f_{\mathrm{s}}-f_{\mathrm{o}}=\frac{\boldsymbol{v} \cdot\left(\boldsymbol{e}_{\mathrm{s}}-\boldsymbol{e}_{\mathrm{o}}\right)}{\lambda} $

    where es is the unit vector of the scattered light of the particle, and λ is the wavelength of the light emitted by the light source in the medium.

    When the laser source and the photodetector are packaged together, the relative positions of the components in Fig. 1(a) can be shown as Fig. 1(b), and eo=-es, then Eq.(2) can be expressed as

    Relative positions of light source, moving particle and light detector

    Figure 1.Relative positions of light source, moving particle and light detector

    $ f_{\mathrm{D}}=2 \frac{\boldsymbol{v} \cdot \boldsymbol{e}_{\mathrm{s}}}{\lambda} $

    According to Eq.(3), if the angle between the direction of the vehicle's velocity and the direction of the light is θ, the Doppler frequency can be given by

    $ f_{\mathrm{D}}=2 \frac{|\boldsymbol{v}| \cos \theta}{\lambda} $

    Therefore, the velocity of the vehicle can be given by

    $ |\boldsymbol{v}|=\frac{\lambda f_{\mathrm{D}}}{2 \cos \theta} $

    Because the beam output by the laser velocimeter is Gaussian beam and it has a certain divergence angle, the spot diameter at middle and long distance of the decameter range becomes larger which causes the echo signal to be very weak and the system can not work normally. The light field distribution of Gaussian beam is shown as Fig. 2(a), where ω(z) is the radius of the spot at the coordinate z, ω0 is the radius of the waist spot of the laser beam, and θ0 is the divergence angle of the far field.

    Gaussian beam field distribution and its transmission trough a single lens

    Figure 2.Gaussian beam field distribution and its transmission trough a single lens

    In order to enhance the echo signal and improve the signal-to-noise ratio of the Doppler signal, so the Laser speedometer can work with long distance. The Gaussian beam emitted from the system is transformed by one lens group in this paper[16]. The transmission of the Gaussian beam through a single lens is shown in Fig. 2(b), and the mathematical principle can be expressed by

    $ {l^\prime } = F + \frac{{(l - F){F^2}}}{{{{(F - l)}^2} + {{\left( {\frac{{{\rm{ \mathsf{ π} }}\omega _0^2}}{\lambda }} \right)}^2}}} $

    $ \omega _0^{\prime 2} = \frac{{{F^2}\omega _0^2}}{{{{(F - l)}^2} + {{\left( {\frac{{{\rm{ \mathsf{ π} }}\omega _0^2}}{\lambda }} \right)}^2}}} $

    where F is the focal length of the lens, ω0 is the radius of waist spot of the incident Gaussian beam, l is the distance between the waist spot and the lens, q0 is the parameter q at the waist of the incident Gaussian beam, qB is the parameter q of the Gaussian beam at the exit surface of the lens, q0 is the parameter q at the waist of the exit Gaussian beam, ω0 is the radius of the waist of the Gaussian beam and l′ is the distance between the waist and the lens.

    Considering that it is difficult for a single lens to focus the laser beam to a long distance (decameter level), we use a short-focus concave lens and a long-focus convex lens to form a telescope-like system, and transform the Gaussian beam based on the system, as shown in Fig. 3.

    Diagram of beam transformation of double-lens telescopic system

    Figure 3.Diagram of beam transformation of double-lens telescopic system

    1.2 Optical

    structure of laser velocimeter for overspeed detection The optical structure of the velocity measuring system is shown in Fig. 4. The beam emitted by the laser is divided into two beams with equal intensity by the beam splitter. The reflected beam returns in the original direction through the mirror and the attenuator, and then enters the avalanche diode through the beam splitter, polaroid, filter and diaphragm, which is the reference light; te transmitted beam passes through the beam conversion lens group and gets to the side of the vehicle. At this time, there are scattered lights in all directions. Among them, the scattered beams return in the original direction are converted by the lens group again. And similarly they get to the avalanche diode through the beam splitter, polaroid, filter, and diaphragm, which is the signal light. There are two main functions of the beam conversion lens group here: the first one is to change the beam waist of the laser to the far lane; the second one is to receive the echo signal. The reference light and the signal light interfere with each other on the photosensitive surface of the avalanche diode, and the voltage signal output by the avalanche diode module contains the Doppler signal with the Doppler frequency because of the square rate effect of the photodetector. The subsequent circuit can process the Doppler signal and extract the Doppler frequency, and then the velocity can be calculated.

    Structure of the laser velocity measuring system

    Figure 4.Structure of the laser velocity measuring system

    As for the signal processing method, Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) is used, mainly because this method has a strong ability to extract signals from noise and can accept discontinuous signals.The flow chart of signal processing is shown in Fig. 5. After the avalanche diode module converts the optical signal into the electrical signal, the data acquisition card completes the signal acquisition and transmits it to the PC. The original signal is first high-pass filtered to remove the base signal in the LabVIEW platform. Then, the FFT is performed on the filtered signal to obtain its frequency spectrum. The frequency spectrum refinement algorithm and correction technique are used to refine and correct the frequency spectrum of the signal[17, 18]. Finally, the Doppler frequency is extracted from the corrected frequency spectrum to obtain the velocity of the object.

    The flow chart of signal processing

    Figure 5.The flow chart of signal processing

    2 Experiments and analysis

    According to Fig. 4, the optical path is adjusted, and a laser velocity measuring system is designed. The main technical parameters of the system are shown in Table 1.

    ParameterValue
    Wavelength/nm532
    LaserPower/mW50
    modeSingle longitudinal
    Focal length of concave lens/mm-35
    Beam conversion lens groupFocal length of convex lens/mm500
    Distance between lenses/mm335
    PhotodetectorAPD
    Beam angle/(°)75
    Signal processing algorithmFFT
    Central working distance/m10
    Measurement accuracy/%< 0.1
    Resolution/(m·s-1)0.01
    Measuring range/(km·h-1)0~200

    Table 1. Main technical parameters of laser velocimeter

    The central working distance of the system is 10 m, and the measuring depth of field is 2 m. The results of measuring the spot diameters within the working distance by a spot analyzer are as follows:the spot diameter at the beam waist is 1.28 mm (Fig. 6), and the spot diameters at 9 m and 11 m from the system are 1.31 mm and 1.35 mm respectively. It can be seen that the lens group convert Gaussian beam very well, and the spot diameters within the target working distance are less than 1.5 mm, which enables the system to collect strong echo signal.

    Two-dimensional image of the spot at the central working distance

    Figure 6.Two-dimensional image of the spot at the central working distance

    Before the actual velocity measurement test on the road, the precision evaluation experiment of the laser velocimeter was implemented using a turntable of the Provincial Institute of Metrology. The rotational speed of this turntable is very stable and the accuracy is good to 3×10-5, so the speed of the turntable can be regarded as the reference value. Since the actual velocity of vehicles on the road can not meet the test conditions of low speed to high speed changes ideally, in order to verify that the laser velocimeter can still guarantee a certain accuracy when it works under different velocity conditions, the speed of the turntable is set to 20 km/h, 80 km/h and 200 km/h respectively. The accuracy evaluation experiment was carried out, and the experimental results are shown in Table 2. Therefore, the measuring accuracy of the laser velocimeter in this paper is good to 10-3, and the measuring range can meet 0~200 km/h.

    Speed level/(km·h-1)Serial numberTurntable/(km·h-1)Laser velocimeter/(km·h-1)Accuracy/%
    20120.053 22120.042 6-0.053
    220.053 35720.046 9-0.032
    320.053 29320.055 50.011
    420.053 22120.038 2-0.075
    520.053 15020.059 80.033
    620.053 00720.051 2-0.009
    80180.152 35980.140 3-0.015
    280.152 42880.170 80.023
    380.152 46680.174 30.027
    480.152 49680.139 1-0.017
    580.152 46680.108 3-0.055
    680.152 39080.140 8-0.014
    2001200.227 173200.124 0-0.052
    2200.227 249200.428 00.100
    3200.227 463200.276 00.024
    4200.227 737200.233 00.003
    5200.228 104200.233 00.002
    6200.228 348200.319 00.045

    Table 2. Experimental results atdifferent velocity levels

    In particular, the working frequency of the velocimeter in this paper can reach 200 Hz (that is, the period is 5 ms). When a normal car whose length is 4 m passes the velocimeter at a high speed of 200 km/h, it takes 72 ms, which is greater than 5 ms, so the velocimeter can still work normally when the traffic volume is large.

    In addition, the resolution of the velocimeter is 0.01 m/s, which is obtained by the resolution of Doppler frequency. According to the optical Doppler effect, the velocity of the measured object can be calculated from the Doppler frequency shift (Eq.(5)), so the resolution of velocity is determined by the frequency resolution, and the frequency resolution is given by

    $ \Delta f = {f_{\rm{s}}}/N $

    where fs is sampling frequency, N is the sampling points (analysis data length).

    After the above analysis of main performance parameters, several well-known velocimeter products' parameters are listed in Table 3 in order to further demonstrate the advantages of the velocimeter in this paper.

    BrandMaximum working distance/mmDepth of field/mmMeasurement range/(m·min-1)
    Elovis500±200~3 600
    POLYTEC2 500±300~7 000
    BETA3 000±1750~4 000
    Velocimeter in this paper10 000±1 0000~3 600

    Table 3. Performance comparison of velocimeter products

    As can be seen from Table 3, the working distance of the velocimeter in this paper has obvious advantages, and the measured vehicle can be allowed to move within a certain range in the longitudinal position due to the large depth of field. The measurement range can reach 0~3 600 m/min, and the corresponding maximum velocity is about 200 km/h, so it can meet the actual velocity measurement requirements on the road.

    After the critical performance of the laser velocimeter has been verified, the laser velocimeter is used for actual roadside testing, which includes the experiment of the effect of the beam conversion lens group on theecho signal and the velocity test of the actual driving vehicles.

    The measuring system is installed for testing by a tripod on the roadside, as shown in Fig. 7. In order to verify the effect of the beam conversion lens group to enhance the echo signal, a comparative experiment based on two systems (one system with the beam conversion lens group and another without the lens group) is carried out. At the distance of 10 m from the system, the handheld cardboard sways back and forth against the laser, and the results are shown in Fig. 8, where Fig. 8(a) and Fig. 8(c) are the voltage signals and their spectrum collected by the system without the conversion lens group; Fig. 8(b) and Fig. 8(d) are the voltage signals and their spectrum collected by the system with the conversion lens group. It can be seen from Fig. 8 that when the conversion lens group is not installed in the measuring system, the Doppler signal can not be extracted due to the noise. After the conversion lens group is installed, the echo signal is significantly enhanced, and the signal-to-noise ratio of the Doppler signal is relatively high. This is mainly because the spot radius within the working distance is greatly reduced after the conversion lens group transforms the Gaussian beam, which enhances the scattered light returning in the original path and it is received by the system. According to the spectrum of the signal, we can know that the corresponding Doppler frequency is fD=4.18 MHz.

    Actual testing environment of the system

    Figure 7.Actual testing environment of the system

    Signals of the system without the conversion lens group and the system with conversion lens group

    Figure 8.Signals of the system without the conversion lens group and the system with conversion lens group

    In addition, we measure the passing vehicles' velocities by the measuring system with conversion lens group, and the result is shown in Fig. 9. Fig. 10(a)~Fig. 10(f) are enlarged views of the six peaks in Fig. 9 respectively. It can be seen from Fig. 9 and Fig. 10 that the entire test process takes less than 8 minutes and 6 vehicles passed by. The maximum velocity is 14.61 m/s and the minimum velocity is 6.93 m/s. Moreover, the time corresponding to obtain the velocity of each car is different, and the time of the first car is 0.28 s(shortest), the time of the fifth car is the 0.71 s(longest). This is mainly because the length of each car is not the same, and the velocity of each car is also different. When the body length is the same, the lower the speed when the vehicle passes, the longer it takes to obtain the vehicle's velocity.

    Results of velocity measuring of passing vehicles

    Figure 9.Results of velocity measuring of passing vehicles

    The enlarged views of the six peaks in Fig. 9

    Figure 10.The enlarged views of the six peaks in Fig. 9

    3 Conclusion

    Aiming at the problem of short measuring distance of traditional laser Doppler velocimeter, a portable laser Doppler velocity measuring system with the double lens telescopic system was successfully designed based on the reference beam measuring model in this paper. The Gaussian beam after the conversion was measured and analyzed, and the actual velocity test by the developed measuring system was carried out. Finally, the velocities of passing vehicles were obtained successfully. Compared with traditional laser Doppler velocimeters, this portable laser Doppler velocity measuring system improves the center working distance and the depth of field greatly. The center working distance is 10 m, and the depth of field is ±1 m, and the velocity measurement accuracy can reach to 0.1%. Therefore, it is feasible to use this portable laser Doppler velocity measuring system for overspeed detection on highways.

    References

    [1] Tian-gang QIANG, Yu LIN, Zhan-hong WU. Research on the measurement of vehicle speed on highways based on video analysis. Forest Engineering, 32, 68-71(2016).

    [2] Jian-min DUAN, Guan-yu LIU, Bang-gui ZHENG. Front vehicle identification algorithm based on visual and multi-feature. Journal of Beijing University of Technology, 41, 1326-1333(2015).

    [3] Hui-ming MA. Review of detection technology for vehicle velocity. Journal of North University of China (Natural Science Edition), 28, 139-144(2007).

    [4] Ying LIANG, Ke-li LI, Fang-hong BI. Research on LFMVW radar velocity ranging optimization system based on FPGA. Procedia Computer Science, 166, 187-194(2020).

    [5] J V B SEVERINO, A ZIMMER, T BRANDMEIER. Pedestrian recognition using micro Doppler effects of radar signals based on machine learning and multi-objective optimization. Expert Systems with Applications, 136, 304-315(2019).

    [6] A ARINALDI, A PRADANAJ, A A GURUSINGA. Detection and classification of vehicles for traffic video analytics. Procedia Computer Science, 144, 259-268(2018).

    [7] M BUGEJA, A DINGLI, M ATTARD. Comparison of vehicle detection techniques applied to IP camera video feeds for use in intelligent transport systems. Transportation Research Procedia, 45, 971-978(2020).

    [8] Yan-yan ZHANG, Ke GONG, Shu-fang HE. Progress in laser Doppler velocity measurement techniques. Laser and Infrared, 40, 1157-1162(2010).

    [9] Yi-ping CHEN. Principle of laser doppler velocimetry and its application. Electronics World, 35-37(2013).

    [10] Xiao-ming NIE, Jian ZHOU. Pitch independent vehicle-based laser Doppler velocimeter. Optics and Lasers in Engineering, 131, 106072(2020).

    [11] Da ZHANG, Hong-bo ZHAO, Jian-kun YANG. A high precision signal processing method for laser Doppler velocimeter. Optik, 186, 155-164(2019).

    [12] Xiong SHEN. Laser doppler velocimetry and its application(2004).

    [13] Jian ZHOU, Xing-wu LONG. Laser Doppler velocimeter for vehicle inertial navigation system. Chinese Journal of Lasers, 37, 1316-1321(2010).

    [14] Xiu-ming LI, Zhan-hua HUANG, Xiang-yu LI. Two-dimensional point laser Doppler velocimeter for velocity measurement. Optics and Precision Engineering, 22, 2627-2632(2014).

    [15] Ying-hong LI, Long MA. Design and application of a new dual laser velocimeter system. Journal of Electronic Measurement and Instrumentation, 30, 256-264(2016).

    [16] A MIKS, P NOVAK. Paraxial properties of two-element zoom systems for Gaussian beam transformation. Optik, 126, 4249-4253(2015).

    [17] Zhi-qiang GAO, Ling-song HE, Jian-hao DU. Micro frequency-shift based spectral refinement algorithm and its application in spectrum analysis during milling process. Measurement, 117, 8-20(2018).

    [18] Jian ZHOU, Hua HUANG. Application of frequency spectrum refinement and correction technology in laser Doppler velocimeter. Laser and Infrared, 40, 144-151(2010).

    Wen-tao LI, Hao TANG, Jian ZHOU. Research on Laser Velocimeter for Overspeed Detection on Highways[J]. Acta Photonica Sinica, 2020, 49(9): 0912001
    Download Citation