- Photonics Research
- Vol. 8, Issue 11, 1703 (2020)
Abstract
1. INTRODUCTION
Optical fiber is a type of attractive waveguide offering advantages including low propagation loss, high flexibility, lightweight, and electromagnetic interference immunity. They also have special optical properties, which make them a suitable platform for lasers, amplifiers, and nonlinear optical generation [1–8]. In addition, optical fibers are also compatible with biological substances since they are mostly made of silica or polymer materials [9,10].
There are several typical groups of biomedical applications that take advantage of the flexibility and compactness of optical fibers to achieve remote delivery of light, such as optical biosensing, optical imaging, and optical stimulation. Aiming for single-molecule detection, optical biosensing technologies challenge the limit of detection (LOD). Making the fiber outer diameter down to a few micrometers or even sub-micrometer dimensions enhances the light–matter interaction [11,12]. The selection of new materials at the interface between fiber and bioanalyte helps to improve sensing performance [13,14]. The water dispersibility and biomolecule affinity are crucial factors while maintaining high-sensitivity performance.
Visualization of bio-organisms requires improved imaging resolution, especially for the in vivo modality. Fiber-based imaging with a high spatial resolution is controlled by the light field in the fiber core which is closely related to the microfiber or nanofiber probe parameters. The challenges remain in removing various aberrations, achieving a larger field of view and deeper imaging depth when designing the fiber-based catheter for 3D imaging [15]. Moreover, engineering the optical waveguide dispersion, nonlinearity, and polarization-maintaining properties are other important perspectives when moving to ultrafast laser-based nonlinear optical imaging [16].
Sign up for Photonics Research TOC. Get the latest issue of Photonics Research delivered right to you!Sign up now
Optical stimulation is a process of targeting a light beam to a specific nucleus. The combination of optical stimulation with genetic engineering paves the way for optogenetics [17]. Bioengineering of light-sensitive ion channels from the bacteria has made it possible to utilize light to modulate neuronal activity artificially. The precise manipulation of the beam is essential for selective control of the activity of neurons. Fiber optics probe becomes a preferred choice of implantable optrode [18] to regulate behavior and physiological functions.
References [19–22] review fiber-based biosensors from the perspectives including grating structures, plasmonic resonance schemes, and lab-on-fiber technology. References [23–25] review fiber-based bioimaging techniques such as fluorescent imaging systems. Based on these reviews, we aim to provide a different perspective focusing on advanced fiber probe designs, i.e., microstructured and nanostructured fibers, for biophotonics applications. The modifications on the fiber or in the fiber could extend the device design freedom from waveguide modification to functional material integration. Also, this review covers special fiber probes for optical stimulation which is an emerging field in the biomedical community.
2. FIBER PROBES FOR BIOSENSING
Fiber-based biosensors have gained a lot of interest from research and development contributed by the advantages of fiber waveguides mentioned above. In this section, a summary of the optical fiber-based biosensors is presented, which is categorized based on their working principles. The focus is how the probe designs can help to improve the sensing performance. Driven by the motivation of high sensitivity and low detection limit of the biological samples, we will start with a surface resonance-based biosensor, followed by an interference-based biosensor, considering both are able to enhance the sensing signal. For each type of the above two fiber-based biosensors, the sensing principle is included, and the selected recent works within the past 5 years are summarized in a table. Typical schematics from each category of the fiber-based sensor are selected, with sensing performance results presented as well.
A. Resonance-Based Optical Fiber Sensors
1. Plasmon Resonance-Based Fiber Sensors
The traditional approach to excite the surface plasmon resonance (SPR) on a metallic–dielectric interface is by using a prism to inject light onto the interface. In comparison, the optical fiber-based plasmonic biosensors utilize the microscale/nanoscale fiber structure to excite the SPR, contributed by the compactness of the optical fiber. The optical fiber was originally designed to guide waves through total internal reflection at the interface between the core and the cladding. To make the core-guided light interact with the metal coatings or nanoparticles (NPs) attached to the fiber, modifications need to be done on the optical fiber structure, as summarized in the following three approaches. The first approach is to remove the cladding of the fiber via chemical etching or side-polishing to form D-shaped fibers, including standard step-index fibers [26–33] and microstructure fibers [34]. The refractometric sensitivity can reach 22,779 nm/refractive index unit (RIU) [32]. The schematic of the experiment is shown in Fig. 1(a) left panel, with the fiber cross section illustrated in the inset. The experimental result is shown in Fig. 1(a) right panel, illustrating the normalized transmission spectra under different glucose solution concentrations. The redshift of the SPR resonant wavelength can be observed as glucose concentration increases. After doing the fitting of the resonance wavelength versus glucose solution mass concentration, an averaged sensitivity of 24.50 nm/wt.%, which corresponds to an RI sensitivity of 17,560 nm/RIU, can be obtained. Figure 1(b) inset shows the cross section of a typical D-shaped microstructure fiber for an SPR-based sensor. The polished fiber is used for the demonstration of plasmonic-enhanced fluorescence emission from rhodamine (Rh) B. The fluorescence emission spectra of Rh B are shown in Fig. 1(b). The distinction between the excitation and emission is achieved through the energy coupling from the surface plasmon wave of thin gold film to Rh B molecules. The second approach is to make tapered fibers with a thinner core so that the evanescent wave can interact with the metal coating on the tapered facet [35–38]. Its refractometric sensitivity can reach 20,300 nm/RIU [37]. In addition to that, electron-rich two-dimensional material can also be coated on the tapered fiber to provide strong SPR at a visible wavelength for biosensing with an ultralow LOD of 1 pg/mL [39]. The third approach is to coat the metal on the inner wall of the air holes containing analyte solutions in a microstructured fiber. Different fiber structure designs have been proposed for this approach [40–43]. A typical cross section of the microstructured fiber is illustrated in Fig. 1(c).
Figure 1.Plasmon resonance-based fiber sensors. (a) Left: schematic of the fiber biosensor based on SPR with cladding partially polished for mode overlap with the metal layer. Right: normalized transmission spectra of the SPR-based sensor under different concentrations of glucose solution. (Adapted with permission from [32]. Copyright Optical Society of America.) (b) Fluorescence emission spectrum of Rh B under different concentrations in side-polished microstructured fiber with gold coating. Inset: cross section of D-shaped microstructured fiber with gold coated on top surface. (Adapted with permission from [34]. Copyright 2011 Elsevier.) (c) Microstructured fiber with Au coated on the inner wall of the air hole filled with analyte solution. (Adapted with permission from [40]. Copyright IOP Publishing.) (d) Left: schematic of fiber biosensor based on LSPR with Au nanorods coated on the fiber core. Right: normalized excitation spectrum showing LSPR redshift as OTA concentration increases. (Adapted with permission from [44]. Copyright 2018 Elsevier.) (e) Left: LSPR with Au NPs coated on tapered fiber, demonstrating an ultralow LOD of 5 aM. Right: sensing result showing the variation of transmission spectrum as the cholesterol concentration increases. (Reprinted with permission from [50]. Copyright 2019 Elsevier.) (f) Left: LMR with either
In comparison with the SPR, which is a lossy propagation wave along the metal surface [20], the localized surface plasmon resonance (LSPR) is an enhanced physical phenomenon. It is the localized electromagnetic wave trapped within metallic NPs with a sub-wavelength scale. A typical schematic of an LSPR-based fiber biosensor is shown in Fig. 1(d) left panel, making use of gold nanorods coated on the fiber core. The advantage of using NPs is contributed by the increase of the surface area and roughness [20]. Therefore, the biosensor based on the LSPR can achieve low analytes concentration detection [44–49]. Figure 1(d) right panel shows the sensing result of ochratoxin A (OTA) with concentrations varying from 0 μM to 1 μM (1 M 1 mol/L). A redshift of the LSPR peak in spectra can be observed as the OTA concentration increases. An LOD of 12 pM was obtained by taking 3 times of the standard deviation of the measured signal with blank samples. Furthermore, in a recent work, a low LOD of 5 aM has been demonstrated using the LSPR from Au NPs coated on a tapered fiber [50], with the fiber schematic and measurement result shown in Fig. 1(e) left and right panels, respectively. The black curve in the measurement result illustrates the stabilized LSPR peak due to the Au NPs on the microfiber surface. The coated microfiber is immersed in cholesterol solutions with concentrations from 5 aM to 0.5 μM, and the transmissions under different concentrations have been plotted. The distinguishable deepening of the attenuation band can be observed. Low LOD of 5 aM is contributed by the efficient interaction between -cyclodextrin-capped Au NPs and the cholesterol molecules.
Another type of resonance-based fiber sensor is making use of the lossy mode resonance (LMR) created by depositing thin film as lossy cladding for the waveguide [51]. As the original optical mode from fiber interacts with the deposited thin film, it will experience a transition to be guided within the film [22]. Such transition creates wavelength-dependent loss in the optical fiber. Figure 1(f) left panel shows the schematic of a recently reported LMR-based fiber biosensor. By using the LMR on a -coated D-shaped fiber, a record low LOD of 1 fM and high sensitivity are achieved [52]. The experimental result is shown in Fig. 1(f) right panel. It illustrates the LMR wavelength with respect to different antigen concentrations for three kinds of sensors: indium tin oxide (ITO)- and -coated unclad multimode fiber (MMF) biosensors, and -coated D-shaped single-mode fiber (SMF) biosensors. The LOD of 1 fM is obtained using the D-shaped SMF biosensor with repeatability and reproducibility. The record low LOD and high sensitivity are contributed by the enhanced light–matter interaction within the fiber sensor structure. The selected recent works within the past 5 years on plasmon resonance-based fiber sensors, including SPR, LSPR, and LMR, are summarized in Table 1.
Sensing Mechanism | Functional | Wavelength | Analyte | Sensitivity | LOD | Ref. |
SPR (on D-shaped fiber) | Au | 750–1200 nm | Glucose | 0.46 nm/mM | – | [ |
SPR (on unclad fiber) | Graphene oxide and Ag | 500–650 nm | Immunoglobulin G (IgG) | 0.4985 nm/(μg/mL) | 0.04 μg/mL | [ |
LSPR (on tapered fiber) | Au NPs | 400–700 nm | Cholesterol | – | 5 aM | [ |
LSPR (on tapered fiber) | Au NPs | ∼607 nm | Cholesterol | 0.125%/mM (resonance intensity change/concentration change) | 53.1 nM | [ |
LSPR (on unclad fiber) | Au nanorods | ∼790 nm | Ochratoxin A | 601.05 nm/RIU | 12 pM | [ |
LMR (on unclad or D-shaped fiber) | ITO or | ∼570 nm (ITO)∼1460 nm ( | IgG | – | 23 pM (ITO on MMF)1 fM ( | [ |
LMR (on D-shaped fiber) | ITO | 1380–1480 nm | C-reactive protein | 10–169 nm/(mg/L) | 0.0625 mg/L | [ |
Table 1. Summary of Recent Plasmon-Resonance-Based Optical Fiber Biosensors
2. Surface-Enhanced Raman-Scattering-Based Fiber Biosensor
Raman spectroscopy has been widely applied in the detection of bioanalyte since it can identify the spectral characteristics or fingerprint of the biomolecules, while the detection is limited by the intrinsic low efficiency of the Raman effect. To enhance the Raman signal, the surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) technique is commonly used [55–64]. The additional coating on the surface increases the roughness and enhances the optical mode through the localization of the signal generated from the Raman scattering. For most of the SERS-based fiber sensors, the backscattered signal, which is the combination of Raman gain and the metallic loss, is collected from the same side of the launching probe signal [65–72], as shown in Figs. 2(a) and 2(b); while a few are based on the detected signal from the forward propagating direction [73,74]. Both backward and forward signal detection approaches have been included in Table 2, which presents the selected recent works on SERS-based fiber sensors within the past 5 years.
Figure 2.SERS-based fiber biosensors. (a) Left: schematic of the SERS-based fiber optic biosensor with metallic nanoparticle coated on the inner wall of PCF. Right: SERS spectra of R6G molecules with concentration of
Sensing | Functional Material | Excitation Wavelength | Analyte | Detection Type | LOD | Ref. |
SERS (fiber facet) | Ag nanodendrites | 532 nm | Permethrin pesticide | Backward scattering | 0.0035 ppm | [ |
SERS (hollow fiber tip) | Au@Ag core-shell nanorods and Ag nanospheres assembled layer-by-layer | 632.8 nm | Methylene blue; cytochrome C; melamine | Backward scattering | 1 fM (methylene blue); 1 μg/mL (cytochrome C);100 nM (melamine) | [ |
SERS (soft polymer optical fiber) | Ag NPs | 785 nm | R6G and 4-mercaptopyridine | Forward scattering | [ | |
SERS (two fibers) | Au NPs | 785 nm | Rh B | Forward scattering (one fiber for Raman excitation, the other fiber for collection) | [ | |
SERS (tapered fiber tip) | Ag NPs | 785 nm | 4-Aminothiophenol (4-ATP) | Backward scattering | [ | |
SERS (on side-channel PCF) | Au NPs | 632.8 nm | Rhodamine 6G (R6G) | Backward scattering | 50 fM | [ |
Table 2. Summary of Recent SERS-Based Optical Fiber Biosensors
There are two common methodologies to implement SERS functionality on optical fiber [21]: (1) to coat the metallic nanoparticle or nanowire directly on the inner wall of the photonic crystal fiber (PCF) [63,75–79], with a typical schematic shown in Fig. 2(a) left panel; (2) to mix the metallic nanoparticle with bioanalyte in a liquid solution for PCF interaction [65–67,80], with a typical schematic shown in Fig. 2(b). The measurement results are shown in the right panel of Figs. 2(a) and 2(b), respectively. The SERS spectra of the R6G molecules with a concentration of using a liquid-core PCF (LCPCF) with sealed and unsealed ends are illustrated in Fig. 2(a) right panel. They are in comparison with the direct sampling, whose enlarged SERS spectrum is included in the inset of the plot. The SERS signal from the sealed fiber structure is around 100 times stronger than that from the direct sampling, which is contributed by the surface enhancement from the silver NP and the LCPCF design. Figure 2(b) right panel shows the SERS spectra of the protein cytochromec detected by bulk solution and a tip-coated multimode fiber (TCMMF) probe at a concentration of 0.2 μg/mL. It shows that the TCMMF probe can achieve an LOD of 0.2 μg/mL, which is an order of magnitude lower than that of bulk detection. This is due to the enhanced electromagnetic field from the SERS substrate on the TCMMF probe.
For both approaches mentioned above, the PCF air cavity can either be in the core of the hollow-core fiber (HCF) or the cladding of the solid-core fiber (SCF). The LOD of the SERS-based fiber sensor is determined by the spatial overlap between the optical mode and the analyte solution. Therefore, the LOD is found to be generally lower for the case where the mixed solution is confined within the HCF core [21] due to higher spatial overlap with the optical mode (e.g., of LOD in Ref. [80]), compared with the SCF case where the mixed solution interacts with the evanescent wave of the optical mode within the cladding area of the fiber (e.g., of LOD in Ref. [79]). The cross section of the above-mentioned HCF achieving LOD is shown in the inset of Fig. 2(c). The measurement result presented in Fig. 2(c) shows the SERS spectrum from the detection of R6G using liquid solution to fill the core of the HCF. The liquid solution is a mixing of R6G and silver NPs. The spectrum peaks are marked from (a) to (l) as shown in the figure. The peaks (a) and (c) are contributed by the silver NPs, and the rest peaks are R6G peaks. One more point worth mentioning is that the LOD on the level of 50 fM is achieved by using the side-channel PCF through the significant increase of the interaction area between liquid samples and the guided light wave within the fiber core [68]. The SERS spectra of different R6G concentration solutions are illustrated in Fig. 2(d). The fiber cross section is shown in the inset of Fig. 2(d). The detection limit of 50 fM R6G concentration solution can be confirmed by the Raman spectrum with notable peaks at , , , and , which correspond to the vibration modes of R6G molecules. Also, an even lower LOD of 1 fM is recently reported by coating layer-by-layer assembly of Ag nanospheres and nanorods on the tip of the HCF [72].
In the SERS-based fiber sensor design, the optical mode propagation length is an important parameter. To optimize the Raman signal for sensing, the trade-off between the Raman gain and metallic loss has been investigated [63,76]. It is found that for a metallic NP-based sensor, when the particle density is higher than a certain level, the scattering loss will be dominating over the Raman gain. While for the case when the particle density is lower than that level, the Raman signal can build up along the propagation of the optical fiber. Such a trade-off can be illustrated from the simulation result shown in Fig. 2(e) [76]. In addition, different scattering enhancement mechanisms, such as stimulated Raman scattering [81] and enhanced random scattering [82], can be explored on a fiber platform to achieve better sensing performance in terms of higher sensitivity and lower LOD.
B. Interference-Based Optical Fiber Sensors
1. Bragg Grating-Based Fiber Sensors
The Bragg grating-based fiber makes use of the periodic perturbation to create the phase matching either along the fiber propagation direction or along the fiber radial direction. Therefore, the currently demonstrated Bragg grating-based fiber biosensors can be categorized into the following four types based on grating structure: fiber Bragg gratings (FBGs), tilted fiber Bragg gratings (TFBGs), long-period fiber gratings (LPFGs or LPGs), and photonic bandgap fiber (PBGF). For the FBG type sensor, the gratings create the coupling between the fundamental co-propagating mode and the counter-propagating mode and act as a wavelength selective mirror, whose reflection wavelength is determined by the Bragg condition [83]
The second type of grating-based sensor is to create the coupling between the core and the cladding mode by using the TFBG. Since the cladding modes have lower effective index compared with the core mode, the transmission spectrum of the TFBG will have a few drops at the shorter wavelength compared with the reflected wavelength within the core mode. These shorter wavelengths can be determined by the following modified Bragg condition:
The LPFG type fiber sensor also creates coupling between the fundamental core mode and the cladding mode in the optical fiber. In comparison with the FBG, the grating period of the LPFG-based sensor typically has a range from 100 μm to 700 μm [19,86–88]. The resonant wavelength can be expressed in the following equation:
An ultrasensitive biosensor with a remarkably low LOD of 0.2 aM was demonstrated recently by an LPFG coated with GO, which has high water dispersibility and high biomolecule affinity [13]. The fiber sensor schematic is shown in Fig. 3(a) top panel. The sensing result is included in Fig. 3(a) bottom panel, showing the sensorgrams. The axis of the sensorgram represents the ratio between the wavelength shift [unit: nanometer (nm)] and the surrounding refractive index (SRI) sensitivity (unit: nm/RIU), and the axis represents the analyte concentration. From the figure, it can be observed that when the concentration of the biotinylated bovine serum albumin (bBSA) analyte varies from 0.1 aM to 1 fM, the responses for sensors and are very close. Both of them have the streptavidin (SA) layer for binding purpose but have different polycarbonate layer thickness. In comparison, the sensor has low response to bBSA due to the absence of the SA layer. The selective binding between the SA and biotin can be observed through the response difference between (or ) and .
Figure 3.Bragg grating-based fiber sensors. (a) Top: schematic of grating-based fiber sensors with LPBG using GO coating to achieve ultrasensitive detection. Bottom: sensorgram showing wavelength shift normalized to SRI sensitivity under different analyte concentrations for three sensors. (Adapted with permission from [13]. Copyright 2018 Elsevier.) (b) Top: cross section of PBGF with PS/PMMA multilayer structure. Bottom: transmission spectra of PBGF during the PVB layer dissolution process. (Reprinted with permission from [89]. Copyright Optical Society of America.) (c) Top: schematic of side-polished PBGF. Bottom: the PBGF wavelength shift with respect to refractive index change for three different polishing depths (PDs). (Reprinted with permission from [91]. Copyright 2012 IEEE.)
The PBGF type of sensor achieves the mode confinement by using either the periodic multilayer or photonic crystal structure along the radial direction of the fiber, which differentiates themselves from the previous three types. A polystyrene (PS)/poly-methacrylate (PMMA) multilayered hollow-core structure can be used to form the photonic bandgap [89,90]. This kind of fiber provides a good platform for biosensing contributed by the fact that the biomolecules can be easily bonded to the PMMA surface [10]. A typical fiber cross section is illustrated in Fig. 3(b) top panel. A thin layer of polyvinyl butyral (PVB) film with a thickness of 500 nm is coated on the inner surface of the fiber core. The dissolution dynamics of PVB has been monitored to demonstrate the surface sensing modality. The result is shown in Fig. 3(b) bottom panel. At first, the reference spectrum was taken at the beginning when 16 wt.% NaCl solution in water was used. The solution has the same refractive index as ethyl alcohol and is chemically inert. Then the ethyl alcohol was introduced into the fiber, and the PVB analyte layer was dissolved. The transmission spectra were taken every minute and plotted in the figure. As the PVB layer was dissolved, the transmission spectrum shifted to the shorter wavelength. A surface sensitivity of 0.052 nm/nm can be obtained from the wavelength shift with respect to the layer thickness change. In addition, the surface sensitivity has been increased to 0.07 nm/nm by squeezing a section of the fiber, due to the increase of the overlap between the core-guided modes and the analyte layer.
An alternative PBGF structure is using a photonic crystal SCF. The sensing functionality can be realized by side polishing to form the D-shaped cross section [91], with a schematic illustrated in Fig. 3(c) top panel. The sensing result is shown in Fig. 3(c) bottom panel, illustrating the blueshift of the PBGF wavelength with respect to refractive index change under three different polishing depths (PDs). Both PD1 and PD2 demonstrate a sensing resolution of RIU. By comparing the gradient of the fitted curve for PD1, PD2, and PD3, we can see that the PD3 (with high polishing depth) has the lowest sensitivity. This might be contributed by the damage of the fiber microstructure, which introduces higher fiber transmission losses and results in the reduced sensitivity to index change. In addition, the selected recent works within the past 5 years on grating-based optical fiber biosensors, including FBG, TFBG, LPFG, and PBGF, are summarized in Table 3.
Sensing | Functional Material | Wavelength | Analyte | Sensitivity | LOD | Ref. |
FBG | Graphene oxide | – | C-reactive protein | 20.15 pm for 1 mg/L CRP | 0.01 mg/L | [ |
FBG | Aldehyde group and antibody | 1559 nm | 25 pm for 1:100 | – | [ | |
Au film | ∼1545 nm | Glycoprotein | 2.867 dB/(mg/mL) | 15.56 nM | [ | |
Au film | ∼1543 nm | Cytokeratin 17 | 1.5 dB amplitude shift at | [ | ||
LPFG | Polycarbonate-GO multilayer | 1300–1650 nm | Biotinylated BSA (bBSA) | 2000 nm/RIU | 0.2 aM | [ |
LPFG | Silica-titania film | 1560–1570 nm | Anti-IgG | 7000 nm/RIU | 0.025 mg/L | [ |
PBGF | PS/PMMA multilayer | 550–750 nm | Polyvinyl butyral dissolution dynamic in liquid | 0.07 nm/nm (surface spectral sensitivity) | – | [ |
PBGF | PS/PMMA multilayer | 600–800 nm | Liquid analyte solution | 1850 nm/RIU | – | [ |
Table 3. Summary of Recent Grating-Based Optical Fiber Biosensors
2. Interferometry-Based Optical Fiber Sensors
An interferometer works based on the superposition of multiple optical modes. Depending on the phase relation among multiple signals from different optical paths, the transmission and attenuation bands can be formed [22]. The fiber-based interferometer can be categorized into two types: transmissive and reflective fiber interferometers.
The structure of the transmissive type can be formed by splicing three fiber segments, including SMF, a fiber-based cavity for optical interference (e.g., an MMF [92,93]), and then SMF. A typical schematic is shown in Fig. 4(a), where MMF is used as a cavity for optical interference. In the sensor, the optical mode couples from SMF to MMF and then couples back to SMF. To enhance the sensitivity of the sensor, etching, polishing, and thin film deposition can be applied to the middle fiber segment [92–95]. The schematic in Fig. 4(b) left panel illustrates the concept of etching the cladding of the MMF toenhance the optical mode interaction with the analyte. The measurement result of sensing anti-IgG analyte with different concentrations is illustrated in Fig. 4(b) right panel. The interference wavelength shift can be observed when the concentration varies from 4 mg/L to 200 mg/L. The Hill equation fitting of the wavelength shift data gives an LOD of 0.2 mg/L (or 200 ng/mL) [92].
Figure 4.Interferometer-based optical fiber sensors. (a) Schematic of fiber with SMF-MMF-SMF structure for the interferometry-based sensor. (b) Left: schematic of interferometry-based fiber sensor with SMF-etched MMF-SMF. Right: sensing result of wavelength shift corresponding to different concentrations of goat anti-IgG from 4 mg/L to 200 mg/L. (Adapted with permission from [92]. Copyright 2018 Elsevier.) (c) Top: schematic of the fiber sensor with SMF-misaligned fiber-SMF. Bottom: sensing measurement data showing wavelength shift with respect to the analyte concentration. The measurement data is fitted by Langmuir isotherm curve. Inset: the linear fitting curve in a low analyte concentration range from 0.5 to 5 μg/mL. (Adapted with permission from [96]. Copyright 2018 Elsevier.) (d) Top: schematic of the fiber sensor SMF-NCF-SMF structure. Bottom: sensing measurement result showing the absolute wavelength shift with respect to the analyte concentration. (Adapted with permission from [14]. Copyright 2018 Elsevier.) (e) Top: schematic of the interferometry-based sensor with the FP cavity external of the optical fiber. Bottom: measured reflection spectra from the samples with different refractive indices. (Adapted with permission from [103]. Copyright Optical Society of America.)
Besides using MMF, other ways to create an interferometric structure for mode beating include implementing the following fiber segments between the two fiber pigtails: PCF [9], misaligned fiber [96,97], tapered fiber [98,99], and noncore fiber (NCF) [14]. The schematic of the misaligned fiber is shown in Fig. 4(c) top panel. It is formed by a section of SMF fusion spliced between two sections of SMF with a core offset of 62.5 μm. Its sensing measurement result is shown in Fig. 4(c)bottom panel, with the inset illustrating the linear fitting curve in a low analyte (human IgG) concentration range from 0.5 μg/mL to 5 μg/mL. Based on the measurement results, theLOD of the sensor can be obtained as 47 ng/mL. Figure 4(d) shows the schematic of the NCF-based sensor and the sensing result. From the schematic, we can see that the nickel ions on the surface of the NCF can bind the analyte for sensing purpose. The sensing result illustrates the wavelength shifts with respect to the analyte concentration variation. The experimental data is fitted by using the Langmuir isotherm model, from which the LOD can be obtained as 0.8368 ng/mL. It is worth mentioning that a record low LOD of 125 pg/mL was reported contributed by the modified fiber surface with a high affinity toward a specific protein [9]. In addition, the length of the middle segment can also be optimized to achieve high sensitivity and low LOD [96].
Alternatively, the reflective interferometer can be formed by a Fabry–Perot (FP) cavity through the backreflection from two interfaces. These interfaces can either be internal [104,105] or external [103] of the optical fiber. In Ref. [104], the internal FP cavity is formed by the backreflections from different surfaces of the microbubble created by the arc on the fiber splicing machine. In the meanwhile, the external FP cavity can be formed by the backreflections from the surface of the fiber facet and the sample with an air gap in between. The schematic is shown in Fig. 4(e) top panel. The spectra of reflected signal from glass samples with different refractive indices are shown in Fig. 4(e) bottom panel. From the fringe contrasts, the refractive index of the sample can be calculated. The FP-based fiber interferometer has the advantage of low cost, compactness, and ease of implementing analyte for biomedical applications [106,107]. FP structure-based fiber sensors are used to detect BSA with the LOD reported to be 0.48 ng [106], and measure liposome with a concentration range from 2.5 mM to 10 mM [107]. Also, the selected recent works within the past 5 years on interferometer-based optical fiber biosensors covering all the structures mentioned above are summarized in Table 4.
Sensing | Functional Material | Wavelength | Analyte | Sensitivity | LOD | Ref. |
SMF-etched MMF-SMF | Eudragit L100 and IgG | 1360–1380 nm | Anti-IgG | 280 nm/RIU | 200 ng/mL | [ |
SMF-PCF-SMF | – (fiber surface modification for immobilization) | 1535–1550 nm | Antigen bovine serum albumin | 722.3 nm/RIU | 125 pg/mL | [ |
SMF-tapered SMF-SMF | Biomarker antibody | 1510–1560 nm | Breast cancer biomarker (HER2) | 2333 nm/RIU | 2 ng/mL | [ |
SMF-misaligned SMF-SMF | Staphylococcal protein A, goat anti-human IgG | 1300–1700 nm | Human-IgG | 13936 nm/RIU | 47 ng/mL | [ |
SMF-NCF-SMF | Chitosan (CS)-nickel (Ni) film | 1570–1610 nm | Hexa-histidine tagged microcin | 0.0308 nm/(ng/mL) | 0.8368 ng/mL | [ |
MMF-FP | – | 1530–1570 nm | Water-glycerin mixture | 5.49 nm/RIU | – | [ |
Table 4. Summary of Recent Interferometer-Based Optical Fiber Biosensors
3. FIBER PROBES FOR BIOIMAGING
In this section, various fiber-based technology development is reviewed to improve the image quality and miniaturization for in vivo applications. At the end of the section, future directions are given based on new exciting emerging technologies that have been demonstrated for other fields and have the potential to be applied in the bioimaging field. Note that fiber-based imaging systems that did not demonstrate biomedical applications are not included.
A. Optical Bioimaging
Many optical bioimaging techniques, especially endoscopes, are based on fibers with their capabilities to transmit, reflect, and scatter light. Imaging techniques based on the light at the far field, such as optical coherence tomography (OCT), multiphoton microscopy, and nonlinear Raman scattering microscopy, will be introduced with the focus on how the development of optical fibers helps to improve the image resolution. However, the light at the far field is being affected by diffraction, which is a fundamental property of light. Hence, the resolution cannot go beyond the diffraction limit. Near-field imaging techniques capture the sample image at the near field by using the evanescent wave of the light before it propagates to the far field and hence, the resolution is not affected by the diffraction.
Fiber-based imaging with a high spatial resolution is controlled by the confinement of the light field in the fiber core, which is closely related to the PCF design parameters, e.g., core diameter, pitch size, and refractive index contrast between the core and the cladding. It has been shown that the effective mode area is
1. Optical Coherence Tomography (OCT)
OCT is a noninvasive imaging technique that was developed in the early 1990s and was since successfully applied in biomedical diagnosis. Because it can achieve micrometer resolution at millimeter depth within a scattering medium, such as biological tissue, it is widely used in ophthalmology and optometry to obtain detailed images from the retina. It has also been used in head and neck, cardiology, and dermatology clinical diagnosis. Specifically, the use of fiber optics enables the OCT imaging of internal organs. OCT uses low-coherence light interferometry configuration and detects the change in the refractive index of the sample. The input light is divided into two arms, a sample arm (attached to a tissue sample) and a reference arm (attached to a movable reference mirror). The reflected light from the two arms recombines and forms an interference signal only when the optical path lengths of the two arms are matched within the coherence length of the input light. Depth scanning is achieved by moving the reference mirror.
It has been shown that the image resolution in the axial direction is proportional to the wavelength of the input light () and inversely proportional to the bandwidth of the input light () [109]. Hence, a light source with a small and large is desired to achieve a high image resolution, i.e., small . Optical fibers can help increase of light sources. In vivo imaging of the cornea and anterior segment with a resolution of 6.5 μm and a sensitivity of 119 dB was demonstrated. OCT systems operating at a center wavelength of 1.7 μm were also developed [109]. An all-fiber-based system was generated by a normal-dispersion highly nonlinear fiber with a femtosecond ultrashort pulsed Er-doped fiber laser as the seed source. A large-mode-area PCF and a polarization-maintaining fiber were also used for dispersion compensation. In vitro OCT images showed an ultrahigh resolution of 3.3 μm and a sensitivity of 95 dB.
Another way to improve resolution is to focus the light coming from the fiber by adding a focusing element directly on the fiber facet or in the light pathway before reaching the sample (e.g., tissues). Graded-index (GRIN) lenses and ball lenses are widely used options as focusing elements. GRIN lenses have been fused onto SMF and PCF [110] for in vivo microscopic brain motion measurements and biological sample imaging with a working distance of up to 1270 μm and resolution of 14.2 μm, which are comparable to the values obtained by using a conventional objective lens. Not only GRIN lenses, researchers have also tried to attach a sapphire ball lens at an SMF tip with an air gap [working distance , ] or an ultraviolet epoxy spacer (, ). Because of the high refractive index of sapphire (), high focusing power and lateral resolution were achieved even when the probe was submerged in the vitreous gel. Ultrahigh sensitivity up to 88 dB OCT fiber probe was applied for corneal and retinal imaging [111].
The latest trend is to adopt nanotechnology into the development of nanoendoscopic OCT for better imaging performance than GRIN lenses and ball lenses. A new type of nano-optics endoscopic OCT probe was recently developed based on metasurface which tackles the spherical aberration and chromatic aberration [112]. The metasurface is an assembly of nanostructures capable of manipulating light properties such as amplitude, phase, and/or polarization at sub-wavelength precision. In particular, a metasurface lens (metalens) is a type of metasurface that functions as a lens but is ultrathin and flat [113]. A metalens was attached to a prism on an SMF facet encased in an OCT catheter and achieved near-diffraction-limited focusing resolution and high depth of focus. Endoscopic OCT imaging in resected human lung specimens and in sheep airways in vivo was demonstrated using the probe.
2. Nonlinear Optical Imaging
Multiphoton (or two-photon) excitation microscopy is a fluorescence imaging technique that utilizes a nonlinear process whereby a fluorophore is excited by two or multiple infrared photons (typically 700–1000 nm) and emits a single photon of higher photon energy in the visible spectrum (typically 400–500 nm). Because infrared light can penetrate deeper into the tissue and cause less photodamage, it has advantages over the confocal microscopy using single-photon excitation. However, two or multiple photons need to be absorbed simultaneously. The probability of fluorescence emission increases dramatically with the excitation intensity, so femtosecond lasers are required which are much more expensive than the continuous wave lasers used in confocal microscopy.
Three-dimensional two-photon excitation microscopy endoscopic imaging in vitro of a gastrointestinal tract tissue and a human breast cancer tissue was demonstrated [114,115]. The imaging system consists of a double-clad PCF (DCPCF), a GRIN lens, and a two-axis microelectromechanical system mirror. The DCPCF consists of a large core surrounded by two cladding layers. The excitation light propagates in the core region and the collected fluorescence light propagates in the cladding, which supports multimode [see Figs. 5(a)–5(c)]. In this way, both the excitation and collection efficiencies are increased. The penetration depth was approximately 100 μm and the axial resolution was 10 μm. A similar and improved configuration based on DCPCF was reported [117]. Besides DCPCF, a hollow-core PCF was also used for two-photon fluorescence imaging. A miniaturized two-photon fluorescence endoscopy was demonstrated [118]. It was composed of a PCF for light delivery, an MMF for light collection, a high-numerical-aperture (NA) GRIN lens for focusing, and a two-axis piezo scanner system for scanning. It achieved an axial resolution of 5.8 μm with a field of view for imaging mitochondria. A major problem with the fiber-based two-photon imaging technique is the small aperture of the fiber probes limiting the collection efficiency of the fluorescent signal. To solve this problem, solutions based on DCPCFs have been proposed. In Ref. [119], the short pulse excitation signal passed through the inner single-mode core and the fluorescent signal was collected through a high-NA multimode outer core ( at the fluorescent wavelength). In this way, both the excitation and collection efficiencies were kept high. It was shown that an order of magnitude improvement over the conventional SMF or MMF can be achieved. A modified version of this experiment was reported in Ref. [120] through a guided-wave mechanism. Here, when the PCF probe was brought in contact with the target molecules, a few nanoliters of two-photon excited molecules filled the air holes in the fiber cladding and were interrogated with the evanescent field of the PCF waveguide modes. The fluorescent signal detected in this way showed a 2 order of magnitude improvement over that in Ref. [119]. Experiments were done with an R6G dye and the Alexa Fluor family of dyes, which are commonly used in cell biology, fluorescent microscopy, and green fluorescent protein.
Figure 5.Nonlinear bioimaging techniques. (a) Schematic of a two-photon fluorescence endoscope. (b) Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) image of a DCPCF overlaid with the light output patterns: single-mode propagation in the core at 800 nm and multimode propagation in the inner cladding at 410 nm. (c) 3D visualization of the human breast cancer tissue imaged using system in (a). [(a)–(c) reprinted from [115] licensed under CC BY 4.0.] (d) Schematic of a fiber-probe based CARS imaging system. Fiber 1 was used for delivery of the excitation pulses and fiber 2 was used for detecting the CARS signal from the sample. (e) CARS image of small adipocytes of mouse ear skin. (f) CARS image of adipocytes of the subcutaneous layer of rabbit skin. Scale bar is 50 μm. [(d)–(f) reprinted with permission from [116]. Copyright Optical Society of America.)
Coherent anti-Stokes Raman scattering (CARS) is another nonlinear optical modality that has a growing interest. Different from multiphoton fluorescence imaging, which is induced by a single laser pulse, CARS imaging requires two pulses with different wavelengths. Because the CARS signal is coherent, it is orders of magnitude stronger than the Raman signal, which is spontaneous emission. There are three frequencies of interest: a pump beam with frequency , a Stokes beam of frequency , and a probe beam with frequency . The output anti-Stokes frequency will be . This gives rise to design challenges such as how to suppress the optical nonlinearities in the delivery fiber and how to effectively collect the backward-scattered signal in the detection fiber [116]. Three types of fibers were investigated for light delivery, including an SMF, a DCPCF, and a large-mode-area PCF. The large-mode-area PCF was chosen for light delivery with minimal spectral broadening effect and a large-mode-area MMF was chosen for maximum signal collection. Examples of CARS imaging of the mouse ear skin, the rabbit skin tissues, and the meibomian gland in mouse ex vivo are shown in Figs. 5(d)–5(g). Another challenge is how to tailor the short-pulse laser excitation source spectrally and temporally. PCFs were used to address this problem [121,122]. For example, a PCF was used to generate a frequency-tunable Stokes source through a soliton self-frequency shift. By varying the power of laser pulses launched into the PCF, the soliton output from the PCF was tuned from 1.35 to 1.75 μm. The dispersion, nonlinearity, and length of the PCF were carefully designed to match the input laser pulse parameters. The efficiency of energy conversion of these PCFs was 15%. Experiments with mouse brain were carried out and CARS spectra were taken [15]. By studying the peaks of the lipid symmetric C-H stretch vibrational mode and the symmetric and asymmetric stretch vibrational modes, it was shown that the system was able to distinguish two regions in the mouse brain with different lipids and water contents and orientation. This will help distinguish the white matter from the gray matter in the mouse brain tissues.
3. Near-Field Optical Microscopy
In scanning near-field optical microscopy (SNOM), the incident light is focused through an aperture, usually a fiber tip with a diameter smaller than the wavelength generating evanescent waves that are nonpropagating and only exist in the close distance to the aperture. The sample is placed in the near-field regime of the light and imaged by a detector which is mounted on a piezoelectric stage for raster scanning to form an image. The spatial resolution of SNOM is not dependent on the incident wavelength, but only on the length of the aperture or the diameter of a microscopic probe tip, e.g., a tapered fiber tip. Hence, the ability to fabricate a high-quality small-diameter fiber tip is important. In the review [123], the authors summarized several fabrication techniques including grinding and polishing, chemical etching, thermal pulling, focused ion beam milling, femtosecond laser machining, electron-beam lithography, nanoimprinting lithography, and photopolymerization methods, etc.
A hybrid system combining an SNOM tip attached to a conventional inverted optical microscope was built [124]. It was used to image fibroblasts sub-surface cellular structures at 250 nm resolution and 100 nm depth. It was also used to image the fragile chromosomes at 100 nm resolution. In another example, SNOM was combined with atomic force microscopy (AFM) to provide nanoscale fluorescence imaging of single amyloid fibrils [125]. The SNOM probe is a metal-coated tapered fiber tip having an aperture of 100 nm. The sample was imaged at the near field approximately 10 nm below the fiber tip. Fluorescent signals generated from fibrils were collected by a microscope objective and an avalanche photodiode and used as the feedback signal for AFM topological structural imaging. The study of amyloid fibril formation is helpful in a variety of human diseases diagnoses.
Another arm of near-field imaging is using a microsphere as a tool to transfer the near-field image to the far field and the image was captured by a fiber or an objective. It is often called a near-field nanoscope. A biomaterial-based near-field nanoscope constructed by trapping a cell on a fiber tip was recently developed [126]. Unlike nanoscopes that are made of inorganic materials, nanoscopes that are made of biomaterials suffer from intrinsic small refractive index contrast that limits their performance as high-resolution imaging devices. The authors overcome this by having a spherical-shaped cell (termed a “biomagnifier”) semi-immersed in a suspension and combining with the interference effect from the reflection of a mirror substrate. A sub-diffraction light spot and focusing were achieved. Human epithelial cells were used as imaging samples. A resolution of 100 nm () was achieved at a scanning rate of 20 μm/s. Moreover, the focal length could be tuned from 0.7 μm to 5 μm by varying the shape of the biomagnifier.
B. Acoustic Bioimaging
Ultrasound imaging uses sound waves or acoustic waves to view the internal organs, monitor heart rates, and examine baby growth in expectant mothers and for other nonmedical applications. Compared with optical bioimaging, acoustic waves can penetrate much deeper into the tissue, but the resolution is poorer. Two important parameters of ultrasound transducers are high sensitivity and large bandwidth. Unfortunately, most commonly used piezoelectric transducers based on the piezoelectric effect face this challenge of the inherent trade-off between sensitivity and bandwidth. Hence, researchers have proposed to use optical methods to generate and receive ultrasound as an effective alternative to overcome this challenge. In addition, optical methods based on optical fibers offer the additional benefit of being a small footprint for minimally invasive endoscopic ultrasound.
A comprehensive review paper was published to summarize the technology development in the laser-generated ultrasound (LGUS) as well as optical detection of ultrasound as an all-optical ultrasound imaging platform [127]. For ultrasound generation, it is mainly based on the photoacoustic effect where materials absorb incident light and generate ultrasound [see Fig. 6(a)]. Widely used light-absorbing materials are carbon nanotubes and gold nanoparticles attached at the fiber tip. For ultrasound detection, it is mainly based on resonant cavities such as FP cavities, Bragg gratings, and microring resonators. The first two have been applied in the fiber context.
Figure 6.Fiber probes for acoustic bioimaging. (a) SEM images of carbon nanotubes and gold nanoparticles as the light-absorbing materials attached at the fiber tip for LGUS. (Adapted from [128] licensed under CC BY 4.0. Adapted with permission from [129]. Copyright 2014 AIP Publishing.) (b) All-optical ultrasound imaging based on fibers encased in a needle for interventional imaging. (c) The needle tip was positioned at the right atrial appendage wall with imaging depths extended more than 1 cm into the tissue. [(b) and (c) adapted from [130] licensed under CC BY 4.0.] (d) Schematic of the all-optical endoscopic imaging system with a dual clad fiber. (e) Photo of the concave cavity FP sensor probe. [(d) and (e) adapted with permission from [131]. Copyright 2011 SPIE.]
The earlier development was based on FBG. Bragg gratings are used to selectively reflect the light of a certain wavelength () with high sensitivity. Since is sensitive to perturbations of the grating structures, FBG can be used for pressure (e.g., caused by acoustic waves) and temperature sensing [132]. The change in due to the strain caused by ultrasound was measured electrically by a radio frequency spectrum analyzer. However, it was found that the grating was subject to a nonuniform strain, i.e., a portion of the grating was modulated while another portion was unmodulated, which made the system response complex. To make it an effective ultrasound probe, the authors concluded that the grating length should be less than half of the acoustic wavelength in fused quartz, which limits the acoustic frequency detection range. It was further suggested that proper desensitization of the fiber is helpful.
Detecting ultrasound signals by using FP cavities has also attracted attention recently. Acoustic waves incident on the FP cavity will cause a change in the cavity characteristics which can be detected by the reflectivity change of the interrogation light beam. An all-optical ultrasound imaging probe based on optical fibers was developed and used for interventional imaging for the first time [130]. Two optical fibers separated by a metal septum for acoustic isolation were encased in a cardiac needle for in vivo imaging [see Figs. 6(b) and 6(c)]. The optical transmitter is an MMF with one end coated with multiwalled carbon nanotube-polydimethylsiloxane for ultrasound generation. The optical receiver is an SMF with an FP cavity attached at one end. A preclinical swine study was conducted. The needle was able to image the dynamic movement of a beating heart at a 50 Hz scan rate at a depth of 2.5 cm with an axial resolution of 64 μm. An improved FP cavity design based on a planar–concave optical microresonator was proposed to improve the performance [133]. A tightly focused interrogation light beam was incident on the planar side and diverged as it propagated inside the cavity, but the divergence was perfectly matched with the concave side which refocuses the beam and prevents the beam from any lateral position shift. As a result, a high value of greater than was achieved corresponding to large bandwidth and high sensitivity, i.e., low noise-equivalent pressure. All-fiber-based 3D pulse-echo ultrasound imaging of ex vivo porcine aorta was performed. The sensor bandwidth is 55 MHz (tunable by the cavity thickness). The axial and lateral resolutions are 94.2 μm and 65.9 μm, respectively. Other references based on FP cavities are, for example, Refs. [134–136].
Photoacoustic imaging (PAI) is based on the photoacoustic effect where pulsed light energy was absorbed by the sample and converted to thermal energy causing the transient thermal expansion motion and emission of ultrasound waves in the megahertz range. The ultrasound signals are detected by ultrasound transducers and are proportional to the absorbed light energy. Hence, by studying the emitted ultrasound signal strength, one can obtain the optical contrast information of different samples. Photoacoustic imaging uses light as the excitation and sound as the detection, so the imaging resolution and depth are in between optical imaging and acoustic imaging techniques. It has been used in medical applications including functional brain imaging [137,138], breast cancer [139], tumor margin detection [140], and skin diseases such as nonmelanoma skin cancer detection [141] and psoriasis [142]. Optical fibers can play a role in PAI in three areas: the light source, the light delivery, and ultrasound detection. Similar to all-optical ultrasound imaging, an all-optical-based photoacoustic imaging probe was proposed [131]. The fiber was a dual-clad 1550 nm SMF, where the core area was used for ultrasound detection and the inner multimode cladding was used for excitation light delivery [see Figs. 6(d) and 6(e)]. The ultrasound detection principle was based on the FP cavity similar to the one in Ref. [133]. A variety of phantom studies were conducted to demonstrate the potential applications for endoscopic imaging. This approach presents the minimum possible photoacoustic probe that can be achieved, i.e., the diameter of a single fiber ().
4. FIBER PROBES FOR OPTICAL STIMULATION
In recent decades, there has been a lot of interest to explore the potential capabilities to optically stimulate cells, control the neurons activeness, and simultaneously monitor the neural activity. Compared with the established electrical and magnetic stimulation, the optical approach can confine the light in regions with micrometer scale and hence achieve better performance in terms of higher spatial resolution, targeting precision, and biological specificity. However, implanting solid-state light sources (light-emitting diodes or laser diodes) directly into the region of interest would cause tissue damage after large-area exposure or long-time illumination. Several prototypes have been built as alternative approaches to deliver light to the biological specimen through flexible optical fiber. The term “optrode” was used in analogy to “electrode” to describe the fiber probe for optical stimulation. This section specifically describes several configurations of fiber probes in such an application scenario.
A. Flat Distal End Fiber Probe
The most common configuration is a flat distal end fiber probe [143]. Once the fiber delivers the light (either coherent or noncoherent) into the target tissues, electrodes in the proximity location could conduct in vivo recordings of neuron activities [144]. This can determine how optical stimulation affects the local field potentials during the experiment. A benefit from the development in microtechnology, integration of optical fibers with microelectrode, could be realized as shown in Ref. [144]. More sophisticated probe designs were realized to combine three key functions for neuro-study, namely microchannels for chemical delivery/injection, optical waveguides/fibers for light stimulation, and electrode contacts for detection [145,146].
Due to the implantation nature of the device, the heat performance is always a concern for laser beam delivery. Through Monte Carlo simulations, Shin et al. calculated the optimized fiber-to-target distances by controlling the light intensity [147]. By considering the bioheat model, the analysis provided a guideline to design a fiber probe in an optogenetics experiment to avoid over-/under-illumination of the light-sensitive proteins.
B. Angled Fiber Probe
Extending the design freedom of the fiber probe from a flat distal end to structures varying in propagation direction is a trend. One of the typical cases is the angled fiber probe [148]. By side-firing, the polished or cleaved angle becomes another parameter to control the illumination direction. Through numerical simulation, the angle of side-firing can be optimized [149]. The experimental results show that a 38° angle polished fiber tip has the best radiant energy for the infrared wavelength. As illustrated in the fluorescence detection, the single fiber approach offers compactness, compared with the configuration of using separate fibers for light delivery and detection.
For some applications, it is required not only to deliver the light to the side, but also to focus the beam onto the tissues. Tan et al. designed a smart needle, as shown in Figs. 7(a) and 7(b) [150]. The ball-shape focusing lens was fabricated at the end of the coreless fiber via a commercial fusion splicer. The focal distance and the emission beam spot size at the focal plane were mainly determined by the curvature of the ball lens. In the work, the ball lens was designed to have a focal length of to ensure the positioning of the focal plane outside the catheter sheath and in the surrounding tissue. The designed sagittal and tangential radii of the ball lens were 75 μm and 100 μm, respectively. After that, the ball lens was further polished at an angle of 36°. The total internal reflection of the incident beam enables the side-viewing catheter design as shown in Fig. 7(a).
Figure 7.Selected examples of angled and tapered fiber probes for
Reflective coatings could be applied on the angle cleaved fibers to steer the beam direction. Tamaki et al. designed a fiber tip to be inserted in a tube-shaped probe for optical stimulation of neurons and electrical signal recording at arbitrary depths [151]. The silica-based MMF with a core diameter of 50 μm was cleaved at an angle of 45° and a thin layer of Al/Cr film was sputtered on the angle-cleaved surface to make sure the optical stimulation was in the vertical direction, as shown in Figs. 7(c)–7(e). The sideway illumination to the tissue material was ensured by an in situ power measurement during the probe assembly.
C. Tapered Fiber Probe
For a flat end-facet fiber even with side-firing, the light penetration depth is around a few hundred micrometers. This is mainly due to the strong absorption of the tissue. Increasing the interaction volume with biomaterials at the targeted region or illumination of spatially extended tissue regions is expected. By tapering an MMF gradually shrinks the cladding diameter from down to 500 nm within a few millimeters of length. The tapered fiber probe exposes a large area for light emission through ray radiation into the surrounding [152–154]. For use in optogenetic manipulation of small nuclei where larger than 100 μm fiber tips can easily damage the bio-organisms, the tapered fibers can be used to scan for multiple layers to search for a strong behavioral effect when the tissues are optogenetically activated. Some special materials such as crystalline could be used to fabricate fiber probes. New functions such as optically stimulated luminescence (OSL) could be obtained. A green laser was fed into the optical fiber and stimulated OSL from the dosimeter connected at the distal end, as shown in Ref. [155].
D. Multi-emitting Fiber Probe
In recent years, there has been an effort to increase the stimulating optrode from a single point to multiple points. With the increased density of stimulation and readout points, more information about the spatial distribution and even neuron circuitry connectivity could be obtained. The fabrication methods of the probes with multiemission functions require precision manufacturing down to the sub-micrometer level. The diameter of a standard silica fiber was tapered down from 125 μm to 200 nm at the tip by a “heating and pulling” method. Then the tapered region was coated with 300 nm gold film as reflective material to prevent leakage of light in propagation. A few local optical windows were created by removing the metallic coating using a focused ion beam system. The window dimensions (width and depth) were varying along the tapered region, but with a fixed adjacent distance. Both simulation and experimental results have demonstrated the capability of the fiber probe to provide multiple emitting points along a single fiber (up to seven in Ref. [156]). More interestingly, multiple wavelengths of the light beam could be independently delivered via a single fiber. This was realized by only changing the input angle of the light source to fiber coupling. A red emission beam and a green emission beam were output from two separate optical windows.
However, the above probe only demonstrated multiple emission in the vertical direction. In many other applications, multiple emission along the transverse direction is in need as well. Abaya et al. have fabricated a three-dimensional optrode array for infrared neural stimulation [157]. The array of optrodes with rows of varying lengths from 500 μm to 1.5 mm on a 400 μm pitch was fabricated on an undoped silicon substrate, as shown in Figs. 8(a)–8(c). An optical fiber was used at the back of the tip for coupling in this case; these tips also perform the function of miniaturized optical waveguides. More comprehensive designs and integrations with commercial neural interfacing devices can be found in Ref. [158]. It is worth mentioning here that the optical sources with near-infrared wavelengths at 1.87 μm and 2.1 μm have been identified as effective stimulation sources. They have been found with practical potential since they not only provide minimal nerve damage, but also correspond to a tissue penetration depth over 300 μm.
Figure 8.Three-dimensional optrode array for infrared neural stimulation. (a) SEM micrograph of the 3D optrodes array with different lengths, (b) tapered profile of the 3D optrode tip, and (c) a detailed description of the structure. (Reprinted with permission from [157]. Copyright Optical Society of America.)
E. Other Fiber Probe Designs
New optical approaches have in turn inspired the development of new technologies to optically interface with the central nerve systems. New classes of implantable nanophotonic and microphotonic devices have emerged for investigating causal connections in brain microcircuits, employing a combination of multipoint optical control and readout of brain activities [159–161]. One example of the special probe design was shown in Fig. 9. A chain design by three or five high-index spheres was proposed on the fiber probe [162]. Numerical simulation shows a twofold improvement in spatial resolution over a single sphere design could be achieved with 20%–40% optical loss. Sophisticated probe designs such as using a microlens or axicon on fiber tip [163] could potentially achieve high precision in beam delivery, but the complexity in fabrication control may remain as a challenge.
Figure 9.Ray tracing simulation of a contact focusing three-sphere microprobe. (Reprinted with permission from [162]. Copyright Optical Society of America.)
Beam engineering is a research direction that has drawn a lot of interest. Laser beam shaping is a potential technique to optimize light–biomaterial interactions, especially in improving the uniformity of the energy distribution. Through wet chemical etching of the distal fiber tip, a concave shape was produced to help transform the Gaussian spatial beam to a top-hat beam profile, as described in Ref. [164]. The redistribution of laser energy improves the beam utilization efficiency, minimizes the local hot spot, and hence avoids tissue damage. Moreover, the flat-top beam profile provides more uniform nerve irradiation and simplifies the alignment of the laser beam.
Nonlinear effects such as two-photon fluorescence could be excited by delivery of an ultrafast femtosecond laser [165]. However, compared with setups using microscope objectives and complex scanning beam geometries, the fiber tip provides cellular circuitry probing with more precise spatial modulation. Combining microendoscopy with laser stimulation is a collaborative effort between nonlinear optical imaging and optogenetics, which is another trend for deep brain research [166]. Although most literature presented fiber probes application in brain-related optical stimulation, it can be extended to other organs as well, such as the heart [167]. Klimas et al. summarized a group of genetically encoded optical indicators and actuators. Light from the fiber is focused onto the sample using an endoscopic probe. The fluorescence signal is then coupled back into the fiber using the same probe and sent to the detector using a dichroic mirror. A fiber bundle-based integrated platform for wide-field bioimaging and structured/modulated optical stimulation in the deep brain is another trend for precision targeting.
After or during optical stimulation, the electrical signal was mainly collected as an observing parameter for biomedical analysis. However, the optical fiber itself can be designed based on the optical coupler/splitter concept, in order to retrieve the reflection signal. In this case, a photometry device can be integrated with fiber stimulation [168] for an all-optical approach.
5. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION
In this paper, first, the resonance-based and interference-based optical fiber sensors demonstrated within the recent 5 years have been reviewed. The sensors are categorized based on different sensing principles. For each sensor type, fiber sensor probe design and measurement results have been illustrated in the figures. Also, the sensing mechanism, functional material, working wavelength, analyte type, sensitivity, and LOD have been summarized in the corresponding tables. Various functional materials including metal-organic framework and covalent organic framework have been applied to enhance the sensor performance [169–175]. It is worth noting that these materials have drawn a lot of interest in biosensing contributed by their biocompatibility [176–178]. Hence, one of the focuses for future work could be the exploration of novel functional materials for various bioanalyte samples to demonstrate the lab-on-fiber sensor devices [21,179] with high sensitivity, selectivity, and low LOD.
Regarding imaging probes, we have systematically reviewed the roles of optical fibers including as the excitation source, as the light delivering medium, and as the signal collection channel in various bioimaging applications. Fibers are flexible and excellent waveguides for endoscopy and remote imaging applications. However, the effect of bending, twist angles, and linear motion of the fiber probe on the imaging quality has to be carefully examined, which may be complex compared to conventional plane waveguides. In the future, one of the exciting areas to explore is the rapid advancement of fiber fabrication technologies and nanotechnologies; optical fibers with patterned nanostructures will be empowered with added functionalities such as beam steering [180], beam focusing [181], and Bessel beam generation [182], which can be readily applied in the biomedical imaging field. Another area of exploration is on the quantitative phase and polarization-sensitive imaging. Biological objects, such as amino acids, enzymes, glucose, and collagen, possess intrinsic polarization (or chirality or handedness). Polarization is also an indication of the health of certain tissues and cells. Hence, polarization-sensitive imaging is an important research topic in the biology community. Conventionally, it is relying on cascading of multiple optical components in a sophisticated setup that is bulky. Lin et al. developed an all optical fiber-based polarization-sensitive OCT imaging system where bulk quarter-wave plates were replaced by fiber optics polarization controllers. The system was demonstrated with in vivo imaging of human fingertip and nail [183]. Similarly, Fu et al. developed a fiber-optic catheter-based polarization-sensitive OCT imaging system. Experiments were conducted on biological samples such as human finger skin in vivo, and untreated and thermally ablated porcine myocardium ex vivo. The obtained phase retardation images based on the tissue birefringence and the scattered intensity information provide more accurate and robust results than conventional OCT alone [184]. Gordon et al. used a fiber bundle for the quantitative phase and polarization-sensitive imaging, which can be easily applied on biosamples [185]. One of the applications of PCFs is the polarization-maintaining fibers. Future work in this area can be the design of PCFs for a shorter beat length that reduces the bend-induced coupling between polarization states and thus a high polarization extinction ratio, as well as much reduced thermal sensitivity of birefringence.
The challenges for next-generation fiber-based stimulation probes as a multifunctional device will be their compatibility with existing high-resolution or whole-brain imaging and stimulation techniques. Multimodality and integration with existing systems, for example, with magnetic resonance imaging, are shown in Refs. [159,186,187]. To link brain function to behavior, optical approaches should also be compatible with untethered and free-moving animal models. This will require the integrated remote/wireless systems to have control of multiple optical stimulations and drug delivery. Experiments in freely moving animals would also be facilitated by the development of wireless powering systems, to mitigate the weight and undependability of on-board batteries. Various components of optogenetic neural interfaces, expected multipoint optical modulation and control of neural activity, as well as in situ drug delivery and specific monitoring of neurotransmitter release, could be demonstrated for in vivo prototypes.
In summary, optical fibers could be considered as a class of flexible optical platform. They offer remote-access capabilities that could not be easily realized in free-space optical components. The microfabrication and nanofabrication technologies on the fiber and in the fiber make the diversity of new functionalities integrated in the updated generation of devices, including sensors, imaging, and stimulation probes. Looking forward, to achieve compactness enabled by microintegration technologies, light-weight as well as biocompatible materials could be the technical challenges with future potentials. From the optical engineering perspective, spatiotemporal beam shaping, ultrafast laser for nonlinear optics, and compatibility with existing biomedical approaches to realize multimodalities are the trends in fiber probes technology.
atomic force microscopy aminothiophenol biotinylated bovine serum albumin coherent anti-Stokes Raman scattering C-reactive protein chitosan cetyltrimethylammonium bromide double-clad photonic crystal fiber fiber Bragg grating Fabry-Perot graphene oxide graded-index hollow-core fiber immunoglobulin G indium tin oxide liquid-core photonic crystal fiber laser-generated ultrasound lossy mode resonance limit of detection long-period fiber grating localized surface plasmon resonance multimode fiber numerical aperture noncore fiber nickel near-infrared nanoparticle optical coherence tomography optically stimulated luminescence ochratoxin A photoacoustic imaging photonic bandgap fiber photonic crystal fiber polishing depth poly-methacrylate polystyrene polyvinyl butyral rhodamine 6G rhodamine refractive index unit streptavidin solid-core fiber scanning electron microscopy surface-enhanced Raman scattering single-mode fiber scanning near-field optical microscopy silver nanoparticles surface plasmon resonance surrounding refractive index tip-coated multimode fiber tilted fiber Bragg gratings working distance
Acknowledgment
Acknowledgment. We thank Nancy Meng Ying Zhang for helpful discussion on the fiber-based biosensor.
References
[15] A. M. Zheltikov. Microstructure fibers in biophotonics. Handbook of Biophotonics(2013).
[17] E. S. Boyden. Optogenetics and the future of neuroscience. Nat. Neurosci., 18, 1200-1201(2015).
[28] J. Pollet, F. Delport, D. T. Thi, M. Wevers, J. Lammertyn. Aptamer-based surface plasmon resonance probe. Sensors, 1187-1190(2008).
[135] E. Biagi, S. Cerbai, L. Masotti, L. Belsito, A. Roncaglia, G. Masetti, N. Speciale. Fiber optic broadband ultrasonic probe for virtual biopsy: technological solutions. IEEE International Ultrasonics Symposium, 200-203(2009).
[144] Y.-K. Song, W. R. Patterson, C. W. Bull, J. Zhang, C. R. Sheldon, A. V. Nurmikko, J. J. Stein, M. D. Serruya, J. P. Donoghue. Fiber optic guided functional electrical stimulation with microscale photovoltaic neurostimulator devices. Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics, CTuEE4(2007).
[145] B. Lee, J. Jin, J. Park, J. Kim. Flexible neural probe integrated microchannel and optical fiber for multifle stimulation. Transducers & Eurosensors XXVII: The 17th International Conference on Solid-State Sensors, Actuators and Microsystems (TRANSDUCERS & EUROSENSORS XXVII), 321-324(2013).
[153] M. Pisanello, F. Pisano, L. Sileo, E. Maglie, E. Bellistri, B. Spagnolo, G. Mandelbaum, B. L. Sabatini, M. De Vittorio, F. Pisanello. Exploiting modal demultiplexing properties of tapered optical fibers for tailored optogenetic stimulation, 199273.
[158] F. Wu. Implantable neural probes for electrical recording and optical stimulation of cellular level neural circuitry in behaving animals(2015).
[164] S. Tozburun. Optical stimulation of the prostate nerves: a potential diagnostic technique(2012).
Set citation alerts for the article
Please enter your email address